5 star hotels in Dunkirk, NY

1. Quality Inn (2-star hotel)

  • Address: 3925 Vineyard Dr, Dunkirk, NY 14048
  • Phone: (716) 672-4450
  • Ratings: 3.9 (339 reviews) Good
  • Website : Quality Inn
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 12:00 PM
  • Quick Summary: Simple hotel with unfussy rooms offering a free breakfast & WiFi, plus an exercise room and a sauna.

About this hotel

This simple, 2-story hotel is set near Interstate 90 and is 1.3 miles from SUNY Fredonia and 2.2 miles from the center of Fredonia. Dunkirk Beach is 3.9 miles away.The unfussy rooms and suites include free WiFi and have en suite bathrooms with showers as well as flat-screen TVs, fridges and coffeemakers. Upgraded suites include whirlpool tubs.A complimentary hot breakfast buffet is provided, and there’s free parking for vehicles of all sizes. Other amenities include an exercise room, a sauna and a business center.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the unfussy rooms
  • 5 min drive to Telecommunications Society
  • Guests praised the service, which has a concierge
  • Guests praised the breakfast

Feedback From Real Customers

Sarah Lawrence

Quality Inn was not so QualityThey had a good amount of parking, they take dogs, and the room itself seemed fairly clean The man at the front desk was also friendly

However, the sink in our bathroom wouldn’t drain (like at all, the sink was full the entire time), the chair in the room had a leg broken off, the hallways were pretty dirty/tired and there wasn’t an elevator I would look elsewhere for a place to stay next time for $180

Elizabeth Brandjes

This hotel needs an update The room we stayed in was tired Cracked tile around the hot tub, stains on the rug and chairs

The room seemed clean, but so worn out it’s hard to make such a dump sparkle The fridge was not working I told the front desk and she didn’t seem concerned “Oh What room?” That was all The most concerning part was the back door was completely broken No security to enter Totally sketchy hotel And way overpriced Worst room I’ve had in years Such a disappointment

2. Westfield / Lake Erie KOA Journey

About this hotel

8001 East Lake Road, NY-5, Westfield, NY 14787(800) 562-3973

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests liked the bathrooms
  • 2 min drive to the Barcelona Light
  • Guests liked “streams”, mentioned 11 times in reviews
  • Guests mentioned “Food truck” 12 times
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a pool

Feedback From Real Customers

C10 G

Last minute camping tripThe place was beautiful, clean and amazing hospitality There was so much for the kids to do and we were nestled in the trees It felt like real camping even tho I didn’t have to worry about a thing like food, coffee, showers because we were traveling

It gave the kids a chance to run around after a really long car ride Best traveling idea it sure beat a hotel

Erin S

Pros for staying here: Location! It’s right across the street from Lake Erie, 2 minute drive to Barcelona beach where you can swim and collect rocks, the creek on the property is beautiful and def great for kids to wade in, pond is a short walk on property and the fish literally jump on the hook, wineries a-plenty, family restrooms (one was missing soap) that were mostly cleanCons: it’s noisy from the all night train passing by, and I-90 is right behind the campground (see pic with red arrow) Bring a noise maker or ear plugs if you don’t like those sounds

Otherwise it is a quiet campgroundIt’s not as kid friendly as they seem to make it sound The playground is outdated and was COVERED with carpenter bees They didn’t have a scavenger hunt when I asked, the man didn’t know what I was talking about They had maybe 2 banana bikes but didn’t look like anyone ever used them, we also didn’t see a game room that they mention The tent and pop up sites are grassy/dirt and if it just rained it is very soft and could easily be muddy so be aware when bookingI will say that despite those cons, the location more than made up for it

Kurt Olesen

We like to stay close to the playground so our daughter can take off and play all day without us having to stay at the playground to watch her We called in to ask if we could get a spot close to the playground The gentleman that was originally helping us was great and trying to accommodate us

Lisa took over the conversation and rudely said they won’t assign us a spot We said we would like to just cancel as other KOAs will let us pick She got snippy that we wanted to cancel over that She quickly rushed us off the phone We were excited to go but now we have no desire to ever go back if that’s how the staff feels it’s acceptable to treat guests

3. Theater Motel (1-star hotel)

  • Address: 7592 US-20, Westfield, NY 14787
  • Phone: (716) 326-2161
  • Ratings: 4.2 (177 reviews) Very good
  • Website : Theater Motel
  • Check-in time: 2:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Simple rooms in this classic 1940s motel, with fridges & microwaves as standard.

About this hotel

This classic 1940s motel was originally a drive-in movie theater and is 1.5 miles from the shops and restaurants of Westfield and 3.3 miles from Westfield Harbor on Lake Erie.Rooms are simply furnished in a traditional style with air-conditioning and heating as standard. All include TVs with cable channels, fridges and microwaves. Smoking rooms are available.There’s daily maid service and the parking lot can accommodate RVs. Guests can visit the old movie house and see the remnants of the drive in theater.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests liked the clean rooms and praised the kitchenettes
  • Guests praised the beds
  • Guests praised the bathrooms
  • 3 min drive to Barcelona Harbor beach
  • Guests liked the friendly service
  • Guests mentioned microwaves 10 times
  • Guests mentioned refrigerators 16 times

Feedback From Real Customers

Rich Bartley

Ive got to tell you that the owners are some of the nicest people Ive ever met Ive been staying here for years throughout the summers The rooms are always clean

If there is ever an issue, the staff tries to fix it immediately Absolutely the cheapest price in the area Rooms include air conditioning, small fridge, microwave, and coffee maker I would stay just based on how nice the staff truly is

Mizz J

I loved the older fixtures and color schemes – they are some of the reasons I chose this location The place was clean, easy to get in/out of, ample parking right outside your door, and it doesn’t break the bank I enjoyed a hot shower and restful sleep – just what I needed for my 10 hour drive the next day (and after a 9 hour drive yesterday)

Tye and his wife are two very nice people who are welcoming and smiling I would definitely stay here again!

4. Lighthouse Inn

About this hotel

965 Main Rd, Irving, NY 14081(716) 934-3877

Things You Need to Know

  • 15 min walk to Sunset Bay State Marine Park
  • Guests praised the service

Feedback From Real Customers

Melody Bennett

Owner is friendly Motel is out dated, but clean Walls are thin and if another guest is talking loud you hear them clearly

TRAIN didn’t go all night, but reminded us of the scene in the movie, My Cousin Vinny Bed was really comfortable If you’re looking for a reasonable price, that’s way cheaper than everything else around, this is the place to stay

5. Clarion Hotel Conference Center on Lake Erie (2-star hotel)

About this hotel

Overlooking Lake Erie, this straightforward hotel 2 miles from a maritime museum at Dunkirk Lighthouse and 3 miles from Interstate 90.Straightforward rooms offer free Wi-Fi and flat-screens, plus coffeemakers. Upgraded rooms add lake views. Suites feature minifridges, whirlpool tubs and/or living areas with sofabeds.A breakfast buffet and parking are complimentary. Other amenities include a bar/restaurant and a lobby lounge with a fireplace. There’s also a seasonal outdoor pool, a business center and meeting space.

Things You Need to Know

  • Walking distance to Dunkirk City Pier and Dunkirk Boardwalk Market
  • Guests mentioned the service is friendly
  • Guests praised the beds but some complained about the kitchenettes
  • Some guests complained about the bathrooms
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a restaurant
  • Guests mentioned microwaves 10 times
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a casino
  • One of the few hotels in the area with an outdoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Marc Maynard

I have stayed here a couple times before This hotel is under construction They are remodeling so if you are averse to dust, materials scattered about, unfinished work, and dirty contractors walking around, then you might want to wait a bit before going here

My room was fine, well equipped, clean, and the bed was comfortable All the staff I met was courteous and efficient I will likely come here again I like the location a lot

Laurie Starr

This hotel is conveniently located with a potential good view of the lake However, the windows were damaged and fogged up so we were unable to see clearly Also, the bathroom tub was quite rusty and dated

The walls in our room were so thin we could clearly hear the guest in the adjacent room talking to his family The guest room and hallway need to be updated We parked on the side of the building nearest our room; the side entry was in poor repair and looked unsafe (although there was a note saying we were being recorded on a security camera) The check-in was easy and the desk clerks were very friendly

Salvatore Aversa

Advertises room service but has none Front desk said was able to charge food and drinks to room Restaurant said different

Waitress walked away from both me and the manager Was very rude and immature Wifi is either terrible or not working Rooms are from the 1900s Very outdated Waste of money Never coming here again Had no parking spaces because let’s anyone park in the lots Experience is terrible Advertises pool but has none I can keep going on But now I am checking out and going somewhere else to eat dinner

6. BUTLER HOUSE at The Cherry Creek Inn

About this hotel

This 1860s Italian-inspired villa sits on 31.5 acres and is 1.5 miles from Cherry Creek in Amish country. Buffalo is 51 miles away.The 3 rooms and 1 suite are individually-decorated and furnished in an elegant traditional style. All rooms are non-smoking and have private bathrooms, while the 2-bedroom suite includes satellite TV and a separate sitting room. WiFi is available.A hearty breakfast is included and English afternoon teas are regularly served. There’s a tower room with board games, an exercise room, a pavilion with hot tub and a conservatory. Amish-themed tours can be arranged at the hotel.

Things You Need to Know

  • 5 min drive to Cockaigne Resort
  • Guests liked the service

Feedback From Real Customers

Tom Pand

I have been advised by my friend to check this place for my snowmobiling trip for me and my friends from PA to Cherry Creek New York, I have to say this place surprised me as we just was looking for a space for the night on the snowmobiling trails, but this place can absolutely offer much more, Amazing Old House with rooms named after characters from my all time favorite show Downton Abbey, I was staying in Lady Mary Room LOVE ITThey also have amazing hot tub that we was offered to use, very nice backyard views and a fire pit that I’m sure will be back to check this summer complimentary Tea Coffee and snacks with lots of fruits available 24hOverall amazing house to stay in, that takes you back in time with a lovely fireplace room for good time with friends after a long cold day, The host MK is a great guy so welcoming and kindWe will be back for sure, well recommended to stay Butler House at Cherry Creek inn

Meg

My parents treated my fiancee and I to a stay at the Butler House this past summer on what would have been our wedding weekend (we had to postpone due to COVID) While the butler wasn’t there during our stay, we still had a great time! Renee and her mom were so sweet and kind, and made us feel welcome right away Cherry Creek is a fairly small, quiet area, but there’s plenty to do if you’re willing to drive a little (Jamestown, Fredonia, and Buffalo are all 30 – 60 minutes away)

We hiked at Panama Rocks, but also spent a lot of time on the screened porch and in the backyard The hot tub, fire pit, and garden swings are all great touches! If you’ve got a sweet tooth, don’t miss the Amish donuts for breakfast – they’re huge and SO delicious! I’d highly recommend a stay for anyone looking to have a quiet, relaxing getaway We had a wonderful time and will definitely be going back to get the full Butler House experience!

Natashia Tuttle

My husband, my daughter and I stayed in the Victoria room! It was our 11 year wedding anniversary and we were in Erie with no luck with somewhere to stay The owner called us and texted us her availability so we decided to try something different and stay in a bed and breakfast Upon arrival the host met us outside

She offered to help us carry our things in as it was very late when we arrived We went in and she took our temperature at the door due to the new COVID laws We were all in good health She showed us our room and while walking to our room, the atmosphere gave us the feeling of peace The old Victorian style home is beautiful! We didn’t have a chance to go outside but from what we could see in the dark it was nice The cleanliness of the building was absolutely pristine The host was very kind and was full of hospitality The food was fresh, the Linens clean, the noise of everyday life was gone, our stay was over all wonderful! We woke up feeling refreshed, just what we were looking for I would recommend this place for anyone!

7. The Amber Tree Inn

About this hotel

4 Buffalo St, Lily Dale, NY 14752(716) 268-1018

Things You Need to Know

  • One of the few hotels in the area with air conditioning
  • Walking distance to Cassadaga Lakes and Lily Dale Museum
  • Guests praised the service

Feedback From Real Customers

Nikki Deal

I could not possibly speak highly enough of Frances and Stephen and my incredible experience staying at The Amber Tree Inn They are both such kind, attentive, welcoming hosts and went above and beyond to make sure our stay was comfortable The Inn is beautiful, pristine, and has such a calming atmosphere

I will definitely be back in the future and highly recommend everyone to book their stay here

8. Gold Brook Farm

About this hotel

233 E Main St, Westfield, NY 14787(716) 581-2610

Things You Need to Know

  • 4 min drive to McClurg Museum/Chautauqua County Historical Society
  • The hotel has a concierge
  • The hotel has childcare

Feedback From Real Customers

Lauren Whiting

We 100%, without a doubt, highly recommend Gold Brook Farm! The place is a beautiful, restored, historical house that has charm and character The homemade jams and made-to-order breakfast were amazing each morning The farm and gardens out back are beautiful

The hosts are wonderful and so accommodating They are more than happy to give recommendations, if desired The place is centrally located to Lake Erie, Chautauqua Lake, wineries, breweries, the Institute, and so much more! We are definitely going to stay again!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *