5 star hotels in Geneva, NY

1. Geneva On The Lake (4-star hotel)

  • Address: 1001 Lochland Rd, Geneva, NY 14456
  • Phone: (315) 789-7190
  • Ratings: 4.3 (284 reviews) Very good
  • Website : Geneva On The Lake
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Italian-style, all-suite villa on 10 acres of landscaped gardens, with a pool, dining & lake views.

About this hotel

Housed in a palatial 1914 Italian-style villa amid 10 acres of landscaped gardens on Seneca Lake, this upscale hotel is 0.6 miles from Hobart and William Smith Colleges, and 2.9 miles from Ravines Wine Cellars.The antiques-filled suites feature free Wi-Fi, flat-screens, living rooms and kitchens. Some have 4-poster beds, terraces with lake views, or whirlpool tubs. Room service is offered.Free perks include the use of bikes and lawn games, and breakfast served in a grand marble-columned restaurant or on a terrace. There’s a gym and a seasonal outdoor pool, along with formal gardens, classical sculptures and a boathouse.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the rooms, which have kitchenettes
  • 2 min drive to White Springs Winery
  • One of the few hotels in the area with room service
  • Guests praised the grounds
  • Guests liked the breakfast
  • Guests praised the lake views
  • Guests praised the nightlife

Feedback From Real Customers

Eve Schwartz

My husband and I loved our stay at Geneva on the Lake hotel! We enjoyed the gorgeous and immaculately maintained grounds and pool The beautifully furnished rooms are quiet and each came equipped with a full kitchen We dined at the hotel’s restaurant for one dinner and two breakfasts

The food was farm to table fresh ! All of the staff were incredibly kind, patient, and courteous I would definitely return for another stay!

Dankmar Hoffmann

We were there at the restaurant 2 weeks ago with a party of 6 for dinner Very nice place, great view and garden, but the whole dinner was very disappointing and too expensive for what is being offered It started out that the cocktail ( whiskey sour) came without any garnish

Followed by unpolished wineglasses full of water stains I shared the crab cake appetizer with my husband Looked and tasted like deep fried Had nothing to do with a fluffy moist crab cake We had a rack of lamb and the duck breast for main course I expected more than 4 thin slices of duck for 49 dollar The lamb was cold, the veggies lukewarm After complaining about that the meat was lukewarm but at least the veggies were hot 😉 (52dollar)The waitress was very nice and polite but in a restaurant like this I expect a well trained and attentive staff We had to get up and get the bottle from the wine cooler ourself to refill our wineglassesThis is definitely not called “fine dining”

ThreeBoyz ATV Mower Chainsaw LLC

What a great new look! Our visit to Geneva On The Lake for the Father’s Day Buffet was fantastic The made-to-order shrimp Alfredo made for a great meal along with the smoky beef brisket and pulled pork sandwich For dessert, the brownies were made in house, the vanilla ice cream, and the ‘help yourself’ vat of real hot fudge was the grand finale

The recently renovated beer parlor is amazing with a brand new bar and an entrance that leads to the main Dining Room Off the main Dining Room is a more private dining area with a fireplace and an elevated view of the grounds and Seneca Lake The staff was friendly and were proud to show off the brand new heated high top event tent, which also has a picturesque view of the lake The solo acoustic guitarist played and sang a great mix of tunes that were relevant to different age groups at the buffet The whole Father’s Day event met our expectations and we’ll be back next year I’m excited to see what happens next! Jerry

2. Miami Motel

  • Address: 4126 NY-5 & US-20, Canandaigua, NY 14424
  • Phone: (585) 394-6700
  • Ratings: 4.8 (273 reviews) Excellent
  • Website : Miami Motel
  • Check-in time: 2:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Unassuming property built in the 1950s featuring casual rooms with a retro vibe & free Wi-Fi.

About this hotel

Off Highway 20, this laid-back motel built in the 1950s is 2 miles from both Canandaigua Lake and Roseland Waterpark, and 5 miles from Sonnenberg Gardens and Mansion State Historic Park.Relaxed rooms with a retro vibe feature free Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs, as well as microwaves and minifridges. Some rooms add whirlpool tubs. Bungalows are also available.Parking is complimentary.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the clean rooms and the kitchenettes
  • Guests praised the bathrooms
  • 6 min drive to the Roseland Waterpark
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests mentioned “retro style” 12 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast
  • Guests praised the nightlife
  • Guests praised the hot tub

Feedback From Real Customers

Mike Scinta

Cleaned, we’ll maintain, and friendly!Stayed overnight to catch a concert, would definitely recommend (and have)! It’s obvious the owners care about what they do and their business, it shows in the meticulous work they have done on the grounds and in the rooms The owners were super nice and friendly I look forward to staying there again!I stayed there because I read all the positive reviews on here, and I was not disappointed

Alisa Gail

We came to this place by accident and I’m so happy we did ❤ Beautiful well stocked rooms Great restroom great water pressure

It’s close by to stores The whole scenery is beautiful and well maintained I have allreafy told many people how happy I was I wish I could have stayed longer The owners are amazing I’ll be back when I can afford it again I wish I could go back for my birthday this month Everyone should experience this motel there is nothing bad I can think of

Synetra Lazzar

I absolutely recommend this place, me and my husband stayed here and we more than enjoyed our stay, the room was beautiful, cozy and very clean! The owners were a delight, so sweet and welcoming The price was definitely great and I highly recommend the Miami Motel to any who’s looking for a beautiful, affordable place to stay overnight or for a romantic weekend getaway! Me and my husband will definitely be going there this weekend to celebrate his birthday and I’m very excited and looking forward to another beautiful night at the Miami Motel!

3. Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Geneva Finger Lakes (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

Set in a commercial area, this casual hotel is 8 miles from Interstate 90. It’s 2 miles from Belhurst Castle and Winery, and 4 miles from Seneca Lake State Park.Warm, modest rooms offer free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs and minifridges, plus tea and coffeemaking facilities. Suites add microwaves and seating areas. Cots and/or cribs are available.A hot breakfast buffet is complimentary, and served in a casual dining room. A garden features picnic tables and BBQ grills. There’s also an indoor pool and a fitness center. Parking is available.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the rooms, which have coffee makers
  • Guests praised the bathrooms
  • 4 min drive to Seneca Lake State Park
  • Guests praised the service
  • The fitness center has treadmills and elliptical machines
  • Guests praised the indoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Doohwan Kim

Stayed at this hotel for 2 nights during my trip to the Finger Lakes Overall, I give it a solid 3/5 (good) The bedroom and bathroom were clean (most important) as well as the overall facility

The reason why I didn’t give it a 4 or 5 is because:1 The room lacked USB port to charge electronics Odd that the rooms were this archaic in 2022 Make sure to bring a 120v charger if you stay here2 The water pressure from shower was pretty weak Probably the weakest pressure out of all the hotels I’ve been to3 The free breakfast were mostly packaged foodsOther than these 3 minor complaints, we were satisfied with our stay

Laura G

Stayed 4 nights for HWS Colleges graduation weekend Absolutely fantastic Staff including GM extremely personable and professional

Many nice welcoming features to families attending grad festivities Banner, Decor, welcome notes It doesn’t get better than this! Rooms spacious, great location and parking ease I commend Steve GM who sets the bar high and is a great mentor to his staff and they seem to love working with and for him Marriott take note They are doing in right in Geneva NY

Brian Avsec

Way over priced for the value delivered Paid $400/nt in AugustRoom was clean and coffee was good but that is it

Breakfast is a joke Only fruit is a sugary fruit cocktail cup Cereals are all sugary Weekend scrambled eggs were made from powder and very salty Weekday you get to microwave a Jimmy Dean sausage sandwich Bed was awful as we woke up sore each morning The rooms have no USB ports so you can’t charge a phone without your brick The shower water pressure is very weak I get it is August and prime time but I wouldn’t complain if we pad $120 nt Since we are paying $400 a night at least do some upgrades Very disappointed and won’t be returning

4. Belhurst Castle and Winery (4-star hotel)

  • Address: 4069 W Lake Rd, Geneva, NY 14456
  • Phone: (315) 781-0201
  • Ratings: 4.1 (1228 reviews) Very good
  • Website : Belhurst Castle and Winery
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Refined hotel in a landmark 1880s castle with antique furnishings, free wine, restaurants & a spa.

About this hotel

Set inside a landmark 1880s stone castle, this stately hotel sits on the northwestern shore of Seneca Lake, 1.8 miles from the Geneva History Museum and 3.5 miles from Seneca Lake State Park.The individually decorated quarters range from simple to palatial. All have antiques, original art and en suite bathrooms; some have balconies, elaborate woodwork, fireplaces and stained-glass windows.Amenities include a relaxed tavern with lake views, an elegant fine-dining restaurant and a spa and salon. There’s a winery on the property, and complimentary wine on tap in the lobby.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests liked the rooms but some disliked the kitchenettes
  • 2 min drive to White Springs Winery
  • Guests mentioned “Steakhouse” 14 times
  • Guests praised the lake views
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a spa
  • Guests praised the bar and the bar drinks

Feedback From Real Customers

Kelli Otis

The staff were very accommodating and did their best The food at Edgar’s for dinner was wonderful! Unfortunately, the rooms need an update and the amenities were of a Motel 6 quality from the tissues to the lotion They were all extremely cheap and not what I would expect for the price

Bring your own tea if you’re a tea drinker but then you have to deal with coffee water so maybe just don’t expect to drink tea! Again, not what I would expect for the price and the supposed quality

Susi Davidson

It is an old castle

we kept our expectations a little low because of that but sleeping was very uncomfortable our bathroom door stayed half open the whole time since it was stuck (pocket doors) and our was sweltering The wedding coordinator was terrible and kept disappearing without communicating with us for long periods of time Unfortunately they had multiple weddings scheduled for the day and it definitely made our daughter’s day not so special with all the chaos and too many people all over the place Most of our guest didn’t eat the food eitherit was a great disappointmentbland and dryWe expected more for what we paid for the room and what was paid for the weddingPeriodWe are well traveled and stayed in many places all over the world I cannot recommend it for a special event The area around was beautiful So A + for that

PUPET WORLD

First off it was my birthday weekend We paid 500$ for a room that had coffee stains on the TV stands There was white crumbs all over the floor

To top it off there was confetti on the bed so basically the bed was never even cleaned for 500$ That’s insane! I brought it to the hotels attention when I checked out and they offered me nothing except saying we can reclean the room Like hello I already cleaned it! The beds are terrible ho to a cheap hotel and the beds are better Not worth the price not worth the drive I’m very upset I lost out on 500$ The parking lot was covered in ice nobody salted or cared about people carrying in luggage n falling Don’t waste your money!

Featured Options

Tripadvisor.com

5. The Yorkshire Inn (3-star hotel)

  • Address: 1135 NY-96, Phelps, NY 14532
  • Phone: (315) 548-9675
  • Ratings: 4.9 (40 reviews) Excellent
  • Website : The Yorkshire Inn
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Historic inn offers plush, individually styled rooms plus a hot hearty breakfast.

About this hotel

This historic inn was built circa-1796 to service the stage coach run (now Route 96) and lies 1.2 miles from Phelps’ main drag, while the historic town of Geneva, perched on the banks of Lake Seneca, is 7.6 miles away Individually styled rooms include the Victorian themed Bolero which boasts a whirlpool tub, and the Rose Suite, which sleeps up to 6 and has direct access to the deck. All have private bathrooms, pillow-top mattresses and TVs with HBO There’s a cozy guest lounge with a brick fireplace and a piano, plus a full hearty breakfast is included in the rate.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the rooms
  • 9 min drive to Foster Cottage Museum
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests praised the breakfast

Feedback From Real Customers

Randall W.

The Yorkshire Inn was a great place to stay in every way It was easy to book on-line, the descriptions of the rooms are accurate and honest We actually did end up making a change in the room we wanted, Micah (owner) handled the change personally

The room we stayed in (The Lodge) was better than we had even expected Very comfortable and inviting We had two mornings of breakfast at the Inn Both were way above and beyond excellent The attention to detail and professionalism that Micah and Darcy exhibit is exceptional Book with confidence!

Jeff Digital

We had an amazing experience here July of 2021

hosts were wonderful and we were able to socially distance and felt safe the entire trip Having multiple wings was awesomeDaily breakfasts and coffee were delicious, and the rooms were quiet and spotlessIts tough to travel with a bunch of kids and the Yorkshire Inn really took the stress out of itThe kids really loved playing with the dog too! 10/10 would recommend

Nathan Temple

After a long day of driving, it was nice to arrive at the Yorkshire Inn Everything felt homey and relaxing, not like our usual cookie cutter hotel stays Our room and beds were very comfortable and we all slept soundly

Breakfast was fantastic Everything was fresh, homemade, and delicious and the service was spot on Again, far superior to what we’re used to from a chain hotel We enjoyed playing with the family dog, our kids especially Yet another great experience you don’t get at a standard hotel Overall a wonderful, memorable experience I wish we were in town longer, but maybe some other time If we find ourselves in the area, we would definitely love to stay here again Very affordable, very nice accomodations, great food and drink, very friendly hosts Thank you Micah and Darcy (and Cooper) for being part of our ’22 summer vacation

6. Microtel Inn & Suites by Wyndham Geneva (2-star hotel)

About this hotel

This unpretentious hotel is a mile from the Geneva Historical Society, 2 miles from Smith Observatory and 3 miles from Seneca Lake State Park.Laid-back rooms and suites offer complimentary Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs and minifridges, as well as safes and en suite bathrooms. Some have pull-out sofas, whirlpool tubs and/or microwaves. Children age 17 and under stay free in a parent’s room.Complimentary perks include breakfast and parking. Other amenities consist of guest laundry facilities, an exercise room and meeting space.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests mentioned the rooms are clean
  • Some guests disliked the bathrooms
  • 3 min drive to Geneva History Museum
  • Guests liked the friendly service
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a restaurant
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a casino

Feedback From Real Customers

Michael Levin

A solid 4 stars The room was very clean, bed was comfortable, staff were very friendly, and the hotel is generally well-keptMy only qualm, and thus for a reduction of a star, was the breakfast

It is free breakfast, so I definitely did not expect a gourmet meal, but the options were really lacking I understand the need for shelf-stable items, as to save costs on cooking staff labor, but offering perhaps nicer yogurts or fresh fruit (even just some apples or bananas) would have made a big differenceWith that said, the hotel was very well-priced, so the cost savings just went towards breakfast at a nice place in the area, of which there are several optionsIn sum, if you don’t care about the free breakfast, this is a great place to stay

Tina P

Check in process was seamless Hotel was very clean and organized Breakfast was great

Tim helped us checkout and was very accommodatingAll staff was very friendlyLocation of the hotel is unparalleled Away from crowded, noisy downtown, but only a 5 minute drive from the action Also very close to tons of wineries and breweriesWe would definitely recommend staying here when you are visiting the Finger Lakes

John and Jody Vossen

We were not sure how old the place was but felt brand new The young man at the front desk was very helpful and the town was very cool We would have loved to spend more time there to explore, but we were passing through

The place deserves a higher rating that I saw on Expedia Rooms were clean and felt new It’s nice to enter and room and not be disghusted

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *