5 star hotels in Hampton Bays, NY

1. Hyatt Place Long Island/East End (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

Set on Long Island’s North Fork, this informal hotel overlooking the Peconic River is a mile from the Long Island Aquarium.Casual, warmly furnished rooms provide free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs, and separate living areas with sofabeds, as well as minifridges and coffeemakers. Upgraded rooms have views of the river and harbor.Parking is complimentary. There are indoor and outdoor pools, plus a 24-hour gym and a business center. Dining options include a cafe/bar and a snack shop.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the large rooms
  • Walking distance to the Long Island Aquarium and Exhibition Center and the Railroad Museum of Long Island
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests praised the restaurant
  • Guests mentioned pools 46 times
  • Guests praised the views
  • The fitness center has weight machines

Feedback From Real Customers

Madeleine Metzler

We booked a block of rooms with this hotel for our wedding weekend on the North Fork of Long Island We worked with Suzanne Lincoln who was SO incredibly helpful in arranging the block, sharing information, answering questions, and assisting with last-minute requests All our guests were very happy with their stays and it was nice to be able to gather with other guests in the spacious lobby, at the bar, and over breakfast

We would absolutely recommend this property for groups or for family travelers One thing that could be improved is the layout of the rooms There was no closet (which for a wedding with lots of things to hang was challenging) and the room arrangement was a little strange Also, we were staying off-season and it was very hard to find food, coffee, lunch within walking distance of the hotel The hotel restaurants are either not open off-season or are closed from Monday-Wednesday which is when we were there There are very limited take-out/delivery options in Riverhead You would need to drive to get food, which might not be ideal for everyone But, honestly, all the staff at the Hyatt were amazing and so great to work with They were patient and helpful and we would definitely return and recommend it to others

2. A Room at the Beach (4-star hotel)

  • Address: 2668 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton, NY 11932
  • Phone: (631) 899-4006
  • Ratings: 4.6 (32 reviews) Excellent
  • Website : A Room at the Beach
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Trendy boutique hotel offering tranquil rooms & suites, plus a tree-filled garden, a sauna & a pool.

About this hotel

In a leafy area off Montauk Highway, this hip boutique hotel is 1 mile from Bridgehampton train station and 3 miles from Sagg Main Beach.Trendy, tranquil rooms offer flat-screen TVs, ceiling fans and minibars, as well as Nespresso machines. Some add direct garden access. A suite has a soaking tub, heated floors and a private garden, while another suite adds a sofabed and a sitting area.There’s a tree-filled garden, plus an outdoor pool and a sauna.

Things You Need to Know

  • The rooms have minibars and coffee makers
  • 2 min drive to Wölffer Estate Vineyard
  • 62 min drive to Long Island MacArthur
  • Guests praised the service
  • The hotel has a sauna

Feedback From Real Customers

Julie Saint Joy

This review is long overdue I spent a few weeks at A Room At The Beach end of last summer 2021 for work and I must say I have nothing but good things when I speak on my experience The staff was very helpful and sweet

Very accommodating Rooms were clean and always set up nicely Check in was easy and stress free I’m definitely thinking of coming back this summer just to spend time in the area again!

D Woj

The room smells of intense mold and made us sick after several hours Grounds are full of bugs and had several bites after unpacking and more by the next day Bathroom windows looked out to a shared path with other rooms and did not have curtains

The toilet seat is not screwed on properly The bathroom door did not shut all the way Trash containers were over full with lids open Suppose the toxic mold in the room wasn’t harmful enough, breath in the nasty diesel car and truck fumes from the constant backed-up traffic on Montauk Hwy This place needs to be better maintained, cared for, and cleaned😷


Very nice garden, but unfortunately the room was not Stained carpet, stained settee, stained upholstered bed The black-out curtains did not cover the window entirely

The bathroom looked a bit tired, to put it mildly There was not enough toilet paper, the coffee machine had to be carried to where the outlet was The door handle on the door was totally crooked Windows were not clean All supposed to be so chic and trendy – what about maintenance?

3. The Quogue Club (4-star hotel)

  • Address: 47 Quogue St, Quogue, NY 11959
  • Phone: (631) 653-0100
  • Ratings: 4.6 (52 reviews) Excellent
  • Website : The Quogue Club
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Genteel hotel in a 19th-century building featuring a stylish restaurant, a swanky bar & a gym.

About this hotel

In a charming building dating from 1824, this elegant hotel in a residential neighborhood is 2 miles from Village Beach and 3 miles from Westhampton train station.Featuring high-thread-count sheets and haute decor, the airy, individually styled rooms offer Wi-Fi and flat-screens. The 1- and 3-bedroom cottages add living rooms with sofabeds.Breakfast is available. There’s a stylish seafood restaurant, and a chic bar with lounge seating. Other amenities include a gym, a kids’ club, and a library with a fireplace, plus exercise classes and access to a private beach. Massages and bike rentals are available. Minimum-stay rules may apply.

Things You Need to Know

  • 4 min drive to Quogue Wildlife Refuge
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a 24-hr front desk
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a restaurant
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Brendan W

We were a group of four looking to enjoy a late fall weekend together and stumbled upon this Gem! One of the group accidentally booked the wrong room type and were upgraded immediately without a blink of an eye The hotel and staff were very warm and the food at the resturant was amazing We will definitely be coming back

What we also liked:Hotel was new and very cleanRooms were quite large (King)Excellent food (got the strip steak)Cocktails were strong!Service at the resturant was 5 starBreakfast was included the next day and was made to order!Lovely facilities including an excellent gym and sitting roomsWhat we didn’t like:We only stayed one night 😢

Alexis Goldberg

Honestly, I can’t describe in our words how amazing our wedding at the Quogue Club was Zachary and the entire staff were outstanding They blew my expectations out of the water

I feel incredibly lucky My family and i will never forget the food and drinks, the beauty of the venue but above all- the service Our guests said it was one of the best weddings they had ever been to

Marie Sorbera

A stunningly beautiful club offering up great service and delicious food Most amazing was the very interesting dessert which featured a cornbread textured style square vanilla cake topped off with vanilla Gelato garnished with virgin olive oil and salt I think I have the ingredients right

We were a table of 10 eating a price fixed luncheon with this soecifw choice of dessert All of us balked but we decided to try it and found ourselves eating the entire dessert and found it to be absolutely delightful Truly an amaxing treat

4. Canoe Place Inn & Cottages

About this hotel

239 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY 11946(631) 763-6300

Things You Need to Know

  • 10 min drive to شاطئ Ponquogue
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a 24-hr front desk
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a restaurant
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a fitness center
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a spa
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a bar
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a beach

Feedback From Real Customers

Gina Pannone

We didn’t stay but got a sneak peek of this beautiful inn – the rooms are all very large, well decorated & NEW! The cottages are beautiful as well Pool area looks nice & the grounds are all well kept with beautiful plantings We got to enjoy lunch and drinks at the indoor restaurant

They have many different options which were all delicious Drinks hit the spot! Staff is all super friendly & helpful and looking to cater to guests in anyway possible The team here did a great job It’s going to also be a beautiful venue for events!

Cathleen Kevin Kinne

Canoe Place is SPECTACULAR!! Proud to have been one of the first guests and can truly say it was absolutely perfect The room was immaculate with all the modern conveniences in a beautifully restored historic building They paid attention to every detail from superior staff to outstanding landscaping and tasteful interior design

This place ranks up there with the finest hotels in the country The Hamptons have a new gem Don’t miss an opportunity to stay at Canoe Place

5. Shou Sugi Ban House

About this hotel

Set in a rural area off the Montauk Highway, this serene spa hotel is 3 minutes on foot from the Parrish Art Museum and 4 miles from Cooper’s Beach.Zen-like, TV-free rooms feature minimalist, Japanese-inspired decor. All have deep soaking tubs, fireplaces, and private gardens with massage areas.Communal areas include a streamlined lounge, and a kitchen that offers culinary workshops and farm-to-table meals. There’s also event space, a cherry orchard and an outdoor saltwater pool, plus a spa with saunas and a steam room. Parking is available, as are yoga, Pilates and meditation classes. Guests age 16 and over are welcome.

Things You Need to Know

  • Walking distance to the Parrish Art Museum and Duck Walk Vineyard
  • 53 min drive to Long Island MacArthur
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a fitness center
  • The fitness center has free weights and weight machines
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a hot tub
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a spa

Feedback From Real Customers

Anna Quan

Recently visited the Shou Sugi Ban House with my boyfriend from NC for a spa day and first time trip to the Hamptons We had 3 experiences, a massage, tea meditation and lunch I cannot say enough how much we enjoyed this experience

The staff was all so kind and attentive Literally every experience we tried was amazing The food is a dream, the massage was amazing and the tea meditation was 10/10 I also ordered something from the shop and they were so helpful and mailing my order to me This would definitely be one of the reasons I would come back to visit the Hampton’s

Mandy Wynn

Doesn’t belong in any Best Of list The list of customer service failures is really too long to write out The worst? The group class instructor telling my Mom she couldn’t handle the class

It’s a group class – provide accommodations and make us feel welcome Or maybe it was the lack of hot water or zero communication after the 2:30 am fire alarm Oh! Maybe that three of our scheduled appointments were left off our itinerary Wait, maybe that we were told thirty minutes before our arrival that our dinner reservation was canceled for a private event Being served the same food at each meal? It’s a well maintained landscape and nice architecture, but it’s not luxury It could be with customer service training and a customer focused program

Malissa Young

We decided to visit for a 24 hour staycation, signing up for 2 hydrotherapy sessions (this is just access to a room with steams, sauna, hot/cold dips for $100/pp), a facial, a soundbath, and a private session with the practitioner of the moment We also reserved for the 6:30 seating of dinner (one seating) Prices are at the level where one expects great service and to feel respected, yet we were treated with a great lack

After our hydrotherapy finished, we headed to our room with a half hour to get dinner ready The shower was only providing cold water Three calls and one email later and 15 minutes of hoping later, we quick rinsed in cold water to make dinner We found we were one of two tables (the other allegedly the owner who was also our breakfast neighbor and never said hello while we actually did make friends and exchange info with other guests) I was freezing (chilled to the bone as they say) after the hot/cold experience followed by a cold shower I was told they couldn’t turn the AC to a warmer temp or it would be stuffy I used a thick blanket and cup of hot water to take the deep chill off but sat through two and a half hours of dinner with goosebumps The boiler was fixed, and I was told “thanks for being so cool about this” The next morning when checking the bill I asked if anything was being done, and the response was, “Didn’t they fix it?”The fix didn’t change the disturbance it had created and my serious discomfort for over three hours until I could take a hot bath I was told they would look into it but nothing changed I called to follow up, great apologies, we’ll look into it, nothing changed After spending money on food (lovely dinner, the $50 dollar rice bowl for lunch was great, but really?), 4 services, and a high priced room one would expect perhaps a small gesture to ensure satisfaction (Perhaps a small room discount, or waive the hydrotherapy service that was not using staff resources) As a business owner, I am shocked, as a customer, appalled, and as someone who has been trained in many and taught a few types of yoga, baffled at the lack of actual spiritual respect, kindness and appreciation that should be a the foundation of a place like this I will spare details on the other services, and say the facial was very good The sound bath, who knows, my husband snored and the practitioner didn’t think to turn or adjust him so it was a struggle for me She mentioned in groups they have ways of dealing with it, guess i would have been better off not having the private experience I would have maybe gone back, but prefer to take business someplace that actually appreciates their customers This left us with the opposite feeling It’s unfortunate that a small gesture that had to be asked for (yes that feels gross but we felt our stay was greatly disturbed) is ignored leading to feeling like a google review is necessary I would look elsewhere for a spiritual spa experience Oh, and to avoid yoga in a room that is wall to wall rubber, and smells like a tire store

6. Jedediah Hawkins Inn (4-star hotel)

  • Address: 400 S Jamesport Ave, Riverhead, NY 11901
  • Phone: (631) 722-2900
  • Ratings: 4.6 (317 reviews) Excellent
  • Website : Jedediah Hawkins Inn
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Elegant rooms in an 1863 boutique hotel, plus an upscale New American eatery & a rustic speakeasy.

About this hotel

Set on 22 acres, this classic boutique hotel occupies an 1863 Italianate mansion, and is a 12-minute walk from South Jamesport Beach.The 6 refined rooms have individual themes, and come with Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs, plus Nespresso machines and Italian linens. Most have fireplaces.Gourmet breakfast is available. There’s an upscale restaurant serving New American cuisine, and a casual speakeasy offering pub fare. Other amenities include a gift shop, an art gallery and gardens. Guests also receive wine-tasting vouchers for local vineyards. Parking and use of bikes are offered.

Things You Need to Know

  • 13 min walk to Jason’s Vineyard
  • Guests mentioned “speakeasies” 12 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast
  • Guests praised the bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Laurette Wafer

Where do I start! We had our daughter’s wedding there this past weekend The property and accommodations are beautiful, extremely well-maintained, comfortable and overly welcoming! The staff couldn’t be more gracious and helpful, we wanted for nothing and everything was taken care of exactly the way we requested and beyond! Also, cannot say enough about the food, delicious! If anyone is considering holdings an event there, do not hesitate, you will not be disappointed! If you have no celebrations on the calendar, I would definitely consider booking a weekend getaway or, at the least, going for an outstanding meal! Looking forward to our next visit!!!

Gail Simons

Very pretty & charming with an old fashioned feel The inside is tastefully decorated and the staff is quite nice For such an upscale spot, though, I did expect more high-end type service

Food, when delivered, for example was just plunked down, not “presented” as one would expect from a more lavish spot Nothing terribly wrong, I just think their servers need a little extra training in “fine dining” The food was good but the sides were super basic White rice with zero garnish or flavor just was “meh” I would recommend this spot, but hope that my review is taken constructively for the management to train their staff a bit more Coming from YEARS in the service industry myself, I do know what I’m talking about

Sneha Clark

I had my wedding at Jedediah Hawkins a week ago The moment we had dinner there on our engagement weekend I was convinced this was it We visited the venue and after that the owner, Lia, was extremely available answering all my questions and very accessible via text and phone

In addition, the staff is amazing!!! It didn’t matter who was my bridal attendant, each person checked up on me and made sure everything was perfect We had Korryn, Collin, Olivia, Eugenia and Elias taking care of us but honestly – they were all so sweet They were so kind, easy going and caring I felt so much support and care from the team and really couldn’t have had a more perfect wedding Not to mention the food is amazing!!! My guests have been raving about the wedding and have booked weekends to visit through the summer If not host a wedding you at least need to visit for a really awesome weekend You will not be disappointed!!

7. Rose Hill Vineyards & Inn (4-star hotel)

About this hotel

In a restored 1880s farmhouse surrounded by vineyards, this upscale bed-and-breakfast on a working winery is 2 miles from both Bailie Beach Park and Mattituck Airport.Featuring vineyard or winery views, the 4 country-chic rooms have free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs and hardwood floors, along with private or en suite bathrooms. Distinctive touches in individual rooms include a 4-poster bed and a cathedral ceiling.Wine tastings and afternoon socials are complimentary. A continental breakfast buffet is served in a bright dining room. There’s also a deck with vineyard views, plus a cozy living area with a fireplace. Kids age 14 and older are welcome.

Things You Need to Know

  • 5 min drive to Pellegrini Vineyards
  • Guests liked the service
  • Guests mentioned “Charcuterie” 10 times
  • Guests mentioned rooms 21 times
  • Guests liked the bar and praised the bar drinks

Feedback From Real Customers

Joe Boocheck

Wonderful atmosphere and vibe Whenever friends or family visit and they want the North Fork winery experience, Rose Hill is always on the list of musts Plenty of seating, indoors and out (weather permitting)

I’d call it casual contemporary rustic I’ve been here at least five times in the past two years Everyone working there has been pleasant and helpful

Ursula XVII

What an amazing magical place Decorated by the Brains at Lumber and Salt The re branding of this establishment goes above and beyond

Not to mention the wines produced by winemaker Patrick have such an attention to detail You can feel his passion in every step The staff is so over-the-top friendly and welcoming if it wasn’t for work I could be here every day From time to time they offer especially curated pairings classes and events and I might even one day trip my husband into a staycation at the B&B I must say this vineyard being off the beaten path on Oregon Road makes it a gem in the rough Cannot say enough good things

Chris C

Great stay at the Rose Hill Inn Staff is welcoming, polite, and respectful Room was beautiful, highly recommended getting the one with a bathroom just for added privacy

Wine is delicious can’t go wrong with a flight and tasting them all Keeping it short and sweet, you will enjoy this vineyard off the beating path, less crowds friendly people and just an overall great experience

8. The Preston House & Hotel (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

In a leafy residential area, this casual hotel within 5 minutes’ walk of shops and eateries is a 2-minute walk from the shores of the Peconic River and 14 minutes’ walk from the Riverhead train station.Warmly decorated studios come with free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs and minifridges, as well as coffeemakers. The 1-bedroom apartments add separate living areas with sofabeds, while suites provide kitchenettes. Room service is available.There’s a stylish restaurant. Other amenities include a gym and in-room massage services. Pets are welcome, and parking is offered.

Things You Need to Know

  • Walking distance to the Long Island Aquarium and Exhibition Center and the Railroad Museum of Long Island
  • 14 min walk to nearest train station
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests mentioned restaurants 26 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast

Feedback From Real Customers

Madeleine Metzler

45 stars – We stayed at the Preston House for our wedding weekend and had a very positive experience from start to finish The hotel is beautiful, immaculately clean, well-appointed and well-located

Parking was easy and free All of the hotel staff, especially Alberto and Rose, were so kind, helpful, and professional We had to check out early unexpectedly and Alberto was an amazing and helpful resource We will definitely come back and enthusiastically recommend this hotel and restaurantWe also hosted our Wedding Rehearsal Dinner at the hotel restaurant The food was delicious and we and our guests were very happy and well-fed I will say that planning the dinner was challenging–it took numerous calls and emails to get a response about booking the event Be wary about booking events around the change of seasons We had chosen items from the Winter Menu that we then learned were all unavailable because the chef had changed to the Spring Menu without informing the manager who was coordinating with us This was a frustrating situation that could have easily been avoided with better communication among staff and between staff and guests Everything worked out just fine, but there was room for improvement in this regard

Racquel W

The customer service is top-notch! We were stranded in Long Island after or BNB was cancelled and thankfully this hotel had a cancellation and we were able to stay here The service is phenomenal as the hostesses provided accommodations for everything we needed-from the room, to breakfast and even providing late-checkout-this is a place I’d recommend to anyone Thank you for your accommodating and treating us with exceptional customer service

Andi Hartmann

We stayed in The Preston House & Hotel for two nights before flying back to Germany after traveling the US for two weeksWe had a suite for two adults and two teenage kids The rooms were very spacious, very clean and furnished to a very high standard

Staff was lovely and very helpful!It was such a wonderful stay, we will definitely visit again

9. The Hampton Maid (3-star hotel)

  • Address: 259 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY 11946
  • Phone: (631) 728-4166
  • Ratings: 4.5 (270 reviews) Excellent
  • Website : The Hampton Maid
  • Check-in time: 4:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Seasonal windmill-shaped hotel with polished rooms & an outdoor pool, plus a breakfast restaurant.

About this hotel

Set on 5 acres overlooking Shinnecock Bay, this polished seasonal hotel with a windmill-shaped main building is 4 miles from the Shinnecock Hills Golf Club and 6 miles from Cooper’s Beach.The airy rooms are individually shaped and feature free Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs. Some rooms have exposed wood beams and/or sloped ceilings, others have wood floors or sleep up to 4 guests.Amenities include an outdoor pool with a sundeck and an elegant wooden gazebo overlooking the pool. There’s also a country-style breakfast restaurant set on a covered patio, plus a lawn, a playground and a veranda with seating. Minimum-stay rules may apply.

Things You Need to Know

  • 11 min drive to the Southampton Arts Center
  • One of the few hotels in the area with room service
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a restaurant
  • Guests mentioned “brunch” 10 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast
  • The hotel has a boutique store
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a bar
  • The hotel has childcare

Feedback From Real Customers

Francine Brock

I loved staying at the Hampton Maid The staff are so friendly and helpful Feels like you are a member of their family

The rooms are spacious, very nicely decorated, clean and have a great back porch to have drinks on or to order room service breakfast in the morningThe chef Alex has an excellent repertoire of food and every meal is delicious and beautifully arrangedThe restaurant has a great ambience and excellent serviceHampton Maid is in a great locationIt’s worth coming back to year after year after yearThanks for making my stay so specialFrancine

Ines P

Room 42 is not a standard room, which would according to their own definition accommodate 2 queen size beds No way would 2 queen beds fit in that room According to them, all their rooms are standard

This is deceptive, especially for people who are new to staying in hotels Rooms 38-43 appear to be the same layout The door was tricky to lock We called and someone came to assist us Breakfast was good, but “small plate” We waited for our food a long time I’m glad we ate elsewhere for dinner after inquiring whether they could accommodate a low sodium diet The man was honest He said that their food is Spanish and therefore salty The room was clean & decor was actually nice However, it bothered me that the lamp on one night stand was tall enough to interfere with 2/3 of the giant solitary picture in the room They need to get shorter lamps or smaller pictures Also, we had 3 conversations with different people before booking One woman was honest She said that no room had a view of the water One man stated that room 42 had a partial view of the water because it’s “higher” By partial, he meant a vague 15 percent patch of blue between branches that are still bare at this time of year

M Johnson

Had a wonderful stay! It was extreme clean and well decorated Love that you have a cozy sitting area outside the room as well as a picnic table Great customer service, from the room cleaning to the property owners

Upon arrival Sarah at the front desk was most helpful, I asked what are some things to do and she emailed me a list of things to do even of her own personal interests being from the area, we went to a few suggested places and it was great suggestions (thank you Sarah!) The owners are on-site, which we encountered and they both were extremely pleasant We had trouble turning on the TV and called for assistance and in no time someone came to the room and explained what to do Breakfast was absolutely great as well as service The pool area was enjoyable, a few people left their belongings on the pool chairs and tables to hold without being present for an extended period of time, this should probably be discouraged We all loved our stay and looking forward to returning

10. Southampton Inn (3-star hotel)

  • Address: 91 Hill St, Southampton, NY 11968
  • Phone: (631) 283-6500
  • Ratings: 4.2 (192 reviews) Very good
  • Website : Southampton Inn
  • Check-in time: 4:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Tudor-style inn offering an outdoor pool & a tennis court, plus a free beach shuttle & dining.

About this hotel

This polished Tudor-style hotel is a 9-minute walk from the Southampton Historical Museum, 1 mile from Coopers Beach and 3 miles from Shinnecock Hills Golf Club.Upscale, individually decorated rooms come with free Wi-Fi, minifridges and flat-screens with cable channels.Cooked breakfast (fee) is served in a modern restaurant with indoor and outdoor seating, and a farm-to-table menu. There’s a heated outdoor pool (seasonal), a croquet lawn and a tennis court, as well as a children’s play room. The library features a fireplace and a piano. A free beach shuttle operates in the summer.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the clean rooms
  • 7 min walk to the Southampton Arts Center
  • Guests liked the service
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a restaurant
  • Guests mentioned beaches 12 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Kevin L

A decent hotel for the price in Mid February Rooms are very clean, the heater keeps the room nice and toasty The best part is they allow dogs with a pet fee

Bright spacious rooms Bonus of having a couch at the foot of the bed for tv watching On the surface everything is perfect, but there’s tiny things that can be touched up like the shower rack that was rusty, and the winter dust that covers the ice and vending machines that keep the place in the middle tier of hotels

Hope Swaim

We really enjoyed our stay at the Southampton inn! The rooms were very well kept and clean, the review photos don’t do it justice The only thing was there was a large amount of bumble bees/bees outside of the doors who made it hard to get in and out There is a sweet black and white cat that stays by the front office who greeted us

Overall it’s very close to the village and the beach, you can walk to almost everything I would recommend staying!

Alex NYC

Clean decent place within walking distance of the town of southampton Which is good except the town lacked really anything to do and the restaurant menus were uninspired and pricey We stayed there because we were visiting a friend who didn’t have room in the house

Not sure why anyone else would stay there except if you want to go to the beach, however that is a shuttle ride away (free of charge] Room was clean and staff was nice and attentive and the pool served its purpose

11. Baron’s Cove (3-star hotel)

  • Address: 31 W Water St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
  • Phone: (844) 227-6672
  • Ratings: 4.3 (500 reviews) Very good
  • Website : Baron’s Cove
  • Check-in time: 4:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 12:00 PM
  • Quick Summary: Chic waterfront getaway with free breakfast & a beach shuttle, plus an outdoor pool & dining.

About this hotel

This upscale waterfront resort is a 6-minute walk from Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum, and 4 miles from Wölffer Estate Vineyard.Nautical-style rooms and suites have free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs and minifridges. Upgraded rooms include decks; some feature gardens. Suites (some in lofts) add separate lounges with pull-out sofas. In-room spa treatments are available.Free perks include breakfast, bike hire, parking and a beach shuttle. There’s also a classic American restaurant with a patio, as well as a cozy bar with fire pits. Other amenities include an outdoor saltwater pool with bar service, plus tennis courts, a gym and yoga classes.

Things You Need to Know

  • 7 min walk to the Sag Harbor Whaling Museum
  • One of the few hotels in the area with room service
  • Guests praised the classic restaurant
  • Guests mentioned “Patio” 11 times
  • Guests liked the breakfast
  • The fitness center has treadmills and free weights
  • Guests liked the nightlife

Feedback From Real Customers

J. Salima Patel, PhD

Every time I stay here I’m reminded of how beautiful Sag Harbor is, and how fantastic the staff, the food, the location, the view… One of the best experiences is the Nespresso machine in all the rooms The restaurant is great and food, delicious However, don’t believe them when they tell you the room service menu is exactly the same as the restaurant – it is not

The restaurant menu is extensive A real pet peeve I have with staying in Baron’s Cove is The lack of smart TVs If you want to spend the evening relaxing in your room, your options are extremely limited I will keep coming back because I love it here! But please upgrade the TVs Every staff member here is amazing, especially the front desk folks

Lauren F

Honest review of the good and bad hereGood: Everyone I met was extremely friendly and eager to help The bar and pool staff were amazing

The location is perfect with a quick walk to adorable downtown sag harbor The bikes I used daily and were always available I liked the shuttle option to the beach but I get car sick The pool area itself was very pretty The outdoor seating for each room was perfect and I had coffee out there each day My room was very clean Oh, and there’s ample parking The food was also great and the wood burning fire each night in the lobby was perfectThe bad: The room itself is a 3 star room in my opinion For the rate they are charging, the linens should be higher end, the bathrooms larger, blackout curtains available, central AC instead of wall units I was awoken each morning by the sun at 6am even though I had my blinds shut Not exactly what I was hoping for on my vacation I was also constantly warm in my room as the wall units only blow so far The water view is more of a marina and there’s a street between so it’s not direct view I didn’t love that there was no hot tub, nor that the beach shuttle stopped at 5 (wanted to see sunset)Would I stay here again? Probably not I stayed at many nicer hotels for the same rate and next time I’ll probably stay at the beach

ioanna dafermou

This hotel is an excellent destination in the Hamptons We love the loft-style rooms overlooking the harbor The hotel has a great cocktail bar buzzing with a beautiful Crowd night after night

If you are traveling with kids, there is a gym and a pool-As well as tennis courts and a basketball hoop The rooms are extremely clean and well appointed– a fun place to be!

12. Aqua by American Beech

  • Address: 15 Bay Ave, Aquebogue, NY 11931
  • Phone: (631) 722-3212
  • Ratings: 4.5 (202 reviews) Excellent
  • Website : Aqua by American Beech
  • Check-in time: 4:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Upscale hotel offering contemporary quarters with canal or bay views, plus a private beach.

About this hotel

Set on Peconic Bay in Long Island Wine Country, this upmarket hotel in a New England-style property is 2 miles from white-sand South Jamesport Beach, and 5 miles from hiking and outdoor recreation at Hallock State Park Preserve.Airy rooms with contemporary decor feature private balconies with canal or bay views, flat-screen TVs, minifridges and Nespresso machines. All also provide designer toiletries and complimentary Wi-Fi.Amenities include a private beach, and a garden with a bocce ball court.

Things You Need to Know

  • 6 min drive to Paumanok Vineyards
  • The hotel has a concierge
  • Guests mentioned “wineries” 11 times
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a beach

Feedback From Real Customers

lisa tyner

Hospitality is above and beyond You can feel the love and care that is put into here We stayed room 2 and was awesome

Lovely Grounds especially enjoyed the little heated garden room while room was being cleaned Light music playing through the day and night Isabella is a Darling and Javier is running a superb place You can’t help but feel relaxed and invited from the moment you check in Rooms are immaculate The housekeeping deserves to be recognized they do a great job and are always smiling so tipping is suggested Our winter stay was extended a day due to how much we enjoyed our stay Restaurants and sunsets picnic baskets are a great touch

Lucinda Rampath

Beautiful spot with access to a private beach that is so calm and relaxing , you feel as if you are in another place (not long island) Staff was very lovely

the property is very well kept and clean The rooms are very comfy with flat screen tvs, king beds, and access to a patio with a personal hot tub Wonderful place to stay after a day of wine tasting Hit the beach right after and just relax They have paddle boards and kayaks for guest use as wellSomething to notethe vibe is a very quiet, low key kind of place I felt as if we were being disruptive by playing some music from our phone while on the beach Wanted to play a couple of beach games, but after reading the atmosphere, we decided not to Not a bad thing, but it is worth keeping in mind if you were interested in a more upbeat type of pace

Tionna P

What an amazing experience! Aqua is a beautiful boutique hotel, that makes you feel like family I enjoyed the privacy, attention to detail and communication from the staff The jacuzzi and bed were fantastic

A delightful picnic basket is delivered to your room in the morning for breakfast If you’re looking for a peaceful getaway close to home this is the place!!

13. Hotel Indigo Long Island – East End, an IHG Hotel (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

This modern hotel in a low-rise, redbrick building is 2 miles from Splish Splash waterpark and 4 miles from the Long Island Aquarium and Exhibition Center.Contemporary rooms come with free Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs, as well as desks, and tea and coffeemaking facilities. Upgraded poolside rooms have patios. Suites are available.Parking is included. There’s a modern bistro and bar with outdoor seating, plus a terrace with an outdoor fireplace. Other amenities include an exercise room, an outdoor pool and a spa. Pets are permitted for a fee.

Things You Need to Know

  • 3 min drive to Splish Splash
  • Guests praised the clean rooms but some complained about the kitchenettes
  • Some guests complained about the bathrooms
  • One of the few hotels in the area with room service
  • Guests mentioned “outlet stores” 13 times
  • Guests praised the nightlife
  • Guests liked the outdoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Tommy Shi

Just did five nights and couldn’t have been more pleased with our stay Friendly service, clean, comfortable rooms (esp the beds) and a chill vibe They have pleasant, mellow live music in the evenings (maybe only weekends), a nice pool and a tasty free breakfast

Location is great for exploring the north and south forks of long island Plenty of good restaurants in the immediate area, although the restaurant on site is quite good This is our third stay and we’re already looking forward to coming back next summer

Henry Peterman

Disappointed with my stay IHG listed Hotel Indigo as part of their premier hotel category It’s modern design left much to be desired

Our room was in some disrepair and did not meet the description presented I regularly use Holiday Inn Properties in my travels and found this to be subpar in comparison to their other regular and budget properties I would strong advise those who choose to list this property as a premier property reconsider this classification if other properties under this label are in a similar state The staff was friendly and helpful and was the shining part of my stay It would be hard for me to consider staying at another Indigo property

14. The 1708 House

About this hotel

Set in the Hamptons, this refined B&B occupies a Colonial house dating from 1708, plus annexes. It’s a mile from Coopers Beach and 2 miles from Parrish Art Museum.Featuring free Wi-Fi and flat-screens, the polished, country-style rooms and suites feature individual touches such as exposed wood beams, antique furniture, living rooms, claw-foot tubs and 4-poster beds. Woodsy-chic cottages add kitchens and porches.Free parking and afternoon drinks are included. Breakfast is served in a posh dining room or on a patio. There’s also a lounge with a fireplace, and a wood-paneled library. Minimum-stay rules may apply.

Things You Need to Know

  • The rooms have microwaves and refrigerators
  • 6 min walk to the Southampton Arts Center
  • 50 min drive to Long Island MacArthur
  • Guests praised the service, which has a concierge
  • The hotel has a boutique store

Feedback From Real Customers

Barbara Mankuta

We stayed here for 2 nights with our adult kids My husband went to Southampton College back in the day and he wanted to see it and the area The 1708 house was perfectly situated to the main street and especially to Sip n Soday- a mecca from back in the day

The house is stately, old, well fixed up and charming The rooms have lovely vintage furniture and comfortable beds The bathrooms are modern and stocked with all the amenities We had a lovely breakfast every morning and came back in the afternoon to a lovely tea with nibbles spread out Our daughter loved the outside hammock under a tree We would absolutely come and stay again The hosts were incredibly hospitable A gem !

Cheryl Holdcroft

Such a lovely old inn The attention to detail- carefully restored public rooms and comfortable bed rooms with modern baths makes this the perfect getaway We were here for two nights for a wedding- and it made out time in Southhampton extra special

The staff are warm and friendly There is afternoon tea with wine and a lovely continental breakfast in the morning

Featured Options


15. Bayview Resort (2-star hotel)

  • Address: 53 W Tiana Rd, Hampton Bays, NY 11946
  • Phone: (631) 594-2370
  • Ratings: 4.1 (83 reviews) Very good
  • Website : Bayview Resort
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Relaxed lodging with bay views, an outdoor pool & a bar, plus a fitness room & free Wi-Fi.

About this hotel

Set on the Shinnecock Bay, this casual motel is 4.4 miles from Ponquogue Beach and 9 miles from the Long Island Aquarium & Exhibition Center.The relaxed rooms feature kitchenettes, free Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs. Upgraded rooms have balconies and/or water views. Penthouse rooms have private decks and full kitchens.There’s a relaxed bar and an outdoor pool, plus a picnic area with a fire pit. Other amenities include a fitness room and a business center.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the clean rooms, which have kitchenettes
  • 10 min drive to Quogue Wildlife Refuge
  • Guests liked the friendly service, which has a concierge
  • The fitness center has treadmills and elliptical machines
  • Guests praised the beach

Feedback From Real Customers

Nicole Newton

Loved it, and would go back The room was as described and clean The grounds were great – you can kayak, hang by the pool, sit by the fire pit, or have coffee on the deck on the bay

The staff was the best part — so helpful and friendly They set us up with beach towels, beach passes and chairs — so we were able to go to multiple beaches in the area

16. Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island East End (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

In a commercial area off Interstate 495, this relaxed all-suite hotel is a mile from the Splish Splash Water Park, and 14 miles from a beach on the Atlantic Ocean.Informal studios come with kitchens and living areas, as well as free Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs. The 1- and 2-bedroom suites add separate living rooms.Parking and hot breakfast are complimentary. Other amenities include a modern lounge and bar, plus indoor and outdoor pools, a hot tub and a gym. There’s also a convenience store and a coin-operated laundry. Pets are allowed.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the rooms, which have microwaves
  • 3 min drive to Splish Splash
  • Guests liked the service
  • Guests praised the restaurant
  • Guests mentioned “outlet stores” 12 times
  • Guests praised the indoor pool and the hot tub
  • Guests liked the modern bar

Feedback From Real Customers


Great location! Hotel was clean, the pools were great and I loved the outdoor lounge areas Rooms were clean Used the couch pull out bed and called the front desk for linens

They said that they had to check if they had any linens left for us to use The room description said that linens would be in the closet but they were not there Would’ve been upset if they did not have any linens for us to use but luckily they did Breakfast was good

Robin Lamb

We stayed at the Marriott with our 2 small dogs last night We came to the area to visit our child who is away at college The hotel was perfect! It was very clean

Even though the place was sold out, it didn’t feel crowded or loud We were able to get breakfast without difficulty It was very reasonably priced There are lots of food options nearby The only thing that would make this pet-friendly hotel better would be a gated dog walk area, since the hotel is located on a busy highway Overall, we look forward to staying here again the next time we visit our child

Ricky Long

We enjoyed our stay very much! Staff was courteous, and rooms were clean Abundance of parking The complimentary buffet was top notch

There were to-go boxes ready for guests to eat in their rooms Hot food was individually packaged and constantly topped off by the staff Can’t say enough good things about how clean and well run the breakfast buffet was This Residence Inn is right next to the Tanger Outlet However, in order to get to the outlets, we drove down the road, and then back around We would have walked it, but there’s not direct path across Old Country Road It’s very close to Lavender by the Bay and Windy Acre Farm We definitely would recommend Thank you for making our first overnight stay with our babies as smooth as it could have gone Will be back!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *