5 star hotels in Ithaca, NY

1. Fontainebleau Inn (2-star hotel)

About this hotel

This historic inn on an 1814 estate in the Finger Lakes region is on the shores of Cayuta Lake, 9.6 miles from Watkins Glen and 20 miles from Ithaca.There are 6 guest rooms, each individually decorated and furnished with antiques and traditional furnishings. All have private bathrooms, free WiFi and irons/ironing boards. Most have lake views and some include 4-poster beds.A full gourmet breakfast is included and served in the elegant dining room or on the panoramic porch. Guests are free to relax on the porches and to explore the grounds and the lakeshore.

Things You Need to Know

  • 4 min drive to Cayuta Lake
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests mentioned “lakes” 13 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast

Feedback From Real Customers

Kimberly Wolcott

We held our wedding here in September of 2021 This place is so unbelievably special Our only regret was not staying longer, seriously!Terri and Jon are great to work with and just all around incredible hosts

Terri’s homemade baked goods and breakfasts are absolutely delicious and the perfect way to start busy mornings leading up to the wedding They are very responsive and helpful on the day of and their team at the Inn do great workWe stayed for 3 nights with our families and wedding party We swam in the lake, did yoga on the dock and enjoyed hours relaxing on the porches The grounds are so beautiful and Terri and Jon have gorgeous flowers on each porch—decorating outside for the event was not needed The view from the Inn down the sloping yard to the lake is breathtakingThe rooms are so amazing each with its own on suite Beautiful and comfortable and the suite we chose was perfect for a Bride and GroomWe cannot way to go back in future years with friends, maybe kids(!), and relive that amazing weekend again Stay as a guest or book your wedding here you will not regret it! One of the best locations in the finger lakes! Thank you Terri and Jon!

Anonymous

Called to inquire about this location for my wedding venue The woman I spoke to immediately shut me down after I told her our guest count and literally told me “we’re probably not the place for you Your guests would just get lost in the space

” What? I understand they probably wanted to keep dates open for larger parties that would pay more but I just thought they would value my business and money and want to be a part of someone’s special day Even small parties shell out a lot of money She said their guest count minimum was clearly stated in their information I had to ask where this was written and it was not clearly stated, it was written on page 3 of their prices and policies under the bar information If they do not want to bother with smaller parties I suggest to them that they CLEARLY state the minimum on their website If you are looking for a venue and have a smaller party do not bother with this place

Benjamin Stevens

I had my wedding at the Fontainebleau in October 2017, and I genuinely could not have wished for a better venue Not only were the staff and owners helpful, kind, and efficient, but the entire grounds is straight out of a dream The little stone chapel for a ceremony, and this beautiful Inn for the reception and a beautiful weekend stay, and I could not possibly recommend them higher

2. Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Ithaca (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

This relaxed hotel is 2 miles from both the Sciencenter museum and Cornell University. It’s 3 miles from the Herbert F. Johnson Museum of Art.Contemporary rooms offer free WiFi and flat-screen TVs, as well as coffeemakers, minifridges, microwaves, and desks. Suites add sitting areas with pull-out sofas.Complimentary amenities include a hot breakfast buffet and off-street parking. There’s also an indoor pool, a fitness center, and a lobby lounge. Other amenities include a business center and a coin-operated laundry.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests liked the clean rooms and praised the beds
  • Walking distance to Buttermilk Falls and Buttermilk Falls State Park
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests mentioned lobbies 14 times
  • The fitness center has weight machines and elliptical machines

Feedback From Real Customers

Elliott Tso

This seems to be an old hotel remodeled If they spent half the money on the rooms and just paint the building white, this might be a better rating I asked to be moved because my front door didn’t open because the door would get caught on the carpet

My remote didn’t turn on my TV which had to be done by hand The thermostat didn’t react to changes made Room said it was 69 I changed it to 72 Laid down then noticed heater didn’t kick on so changed to 73 Nothing 74 and heater started up Bed seemed like it was an older model with heavy use It’s next to a Mexican restaurant that’s good enough and across from a speedway so that’s a plus There was a young lady with glasses who was super helpful up at the front desk which helped as well I hardly rate hotels but I’ll start after this

John Hector Heinen

Most hotels provide you with soap and shampoo Some bring their own You get in the shower and there is no shampoo or soap what do you do? Hope you can pump out enough to wash

Housekeeping forgot to fill soap and shampoo bottles I like this concept since this prevents more plastic waste in our landfillsOther than that I had a pleasant stay and staff very kind and helpful with all my needs Thank you all

Chris Parker

It’s a nice Fairfield Inn The breakfast is minimalist but fills your belly OK Super nice front desk staff and checking in on the app beforehand made it fast and our key was waiting for us

The pillows are down so you may need two at night AC worked well in the room My only complaints were the gym was set to 78 and was locked so it couldn’t be changed which made running on the treadmill quite toasty and the shampoo in the shower was basically water Some paper towels or regular towels in the gym to clean up sweat after would be good The hotel is 2 minutes from Buttermilk Falls, 35 minutes from Watkins Glen State Park and about 10 from the farmer’s market which is a must go to on the weekend

Featured Options

Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Ithaca
Visit Site
Expedia.com
Visit Site
Booking.com
Visit Site
Hotels.com
Visit Site

All Options

Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Ithaca
Visit Site
mobytrip
Visit Site

3. Canopy by Hilton Ithaca Downtown (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

Set off Highway 79 and surrounded by shops and restaurants, this hip hotel with a brick exterior is a mile from both Ithaca Falls Natural Area and Cornell University.Trendy rooms offer Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs, plus minifridges and coffeemakers. Upgraded rooms add living areas with sofabeds.There’s an industrial-style restaurant and bar with floor-to-ceiling windows, plus an elevated outdoor terrace and a gym. Parking and breakfast are available.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the rooms, which have TVs
  • Walking distance to The History Center in Tompkins County and Cayuga Lake Scenic Byway, Inc.
  • The hotel has a concierge
  • Guests mentioned restaurants 21 times
  • The fitness center has free weights
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a bar

Feedback From Real Customers

KarenClarksteno

The BEST Hilton property I have ever stayed at From beginning to end, we were treated professionally and made to feel welcome Super clean rooms, lobby, breakfast/bar area

Trendy and comfortable sixty restaurants within a four-block radius The Ithaca Commons are not even a block from this hotel I loved how green they have manged to achieve I felt good about being at this hotel My husband and I will return again and again Especially during the summer

Brenda

Found this little gem while attending a boat show in Ithaca The well designed lounge area offers fireside options with plenty of seating The cocktail bar and restaurant were fantastic with excellent customer service and a decent menu selection

The front desk “lady boss” was my first impression, and she rocked it Both professional and very personable, shared a common ground conversation about my hometown of Canandaigua and sailing Comfortable beds and cleanliness expected with Hilton, did not disappoint Only downside was the off site parking garage, not a far walk but very low ceiling height for truck clearance Would stay again, but find alternate plans for parking

Kristina Johnson

We paid a little over 2 grand to stay for a week due to educational responsibilities in the area, Only to arrive to no complimentary breakfast, if you wanted the breakfast (which granted we should have verified prior to our stay) It consisted of cold coffee, eggs, bacon, hash browns and the occasional pancake All together you had to pay an extra $14 for everything The rooms were nice, pretty small and intimate which was fine since it was just my husband and myself

The rooms did not have a microwave, nor did they have a small regular size refrigerator The refrigerator was a pull out draw disguised as a cabinet beneath the coffee station in the room Now, please if your going to stay here, your going to have to store food , to which your going to have to go downstairs to use the microwave in the hallway behind the front desk to warm up so please prepare for that The customer service was great, it was quite and everyone was kind, however we will never stay there again Way to over priced for what was provided By the way we stayed in a regular King room, I’m sure they had other room layouts so this review is specifically for that room and our all around experienceAlso go to the near by Walmart after checking in if you do decide to stay here and download the door dash to see the restaurants in the area The local mall is literally, a BJs, Target, and like two other stores Treat yourself to one or two of the many beautiful wine vineyards in the areaParking is a few blocks down the street, in a parking garage to which you have to pay nightly for No valet is offered

Featured Options

Expedia.com
Visit Site
Hotels.com
Visit Site
Booking.com
Visit Site
HotelsCombined
Visit Site

All Options

Canopy by Hilton Ithaca Downtown
Visit Site
ZenHotels.com
Visit Site

4. La Tourelle Hotel & Spa (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

Set on 70 acres, this upscale hotel is 1.6 miles from Ithaca College, 3.3 miles from Cornell University and 3.4 miles from Downtown.Traditionally decorated rooms offer free Wi-Fi, TVs and DVD players, plus coffeemakers, minifridges and dual showerheads. Upgraded rooms add fireplaces, 4-poster beds, balconies and/or whirlpool tubs.There are 2 circular rooms in the inn’s tower, and some rooms feature tile floors and fenced-in decks. The barn houses an elegant 3-bedroom suite with a kitchenette and a 2-story living room.The farm-to-table bistro serves breakfast, brunch and lunch, and there’s a steakhouse. A spa offers treatments (fee).

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the clean rooms, which have refrigerators
  • Guests praised the bathrooms
  • 7 min drive to Wells Falls
  • One of the few hotels in the area with room service
  • Guests praised the restaurant
  • Guests mentioned “a fireplace” 18 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast

Feedback From Real Customers

Nancy Egan

Relaxed and welcoming Our room was large, clean, and had an outside porch Complimentary coffee, cookies, and a hot cocoa bar! In the evening we enjoyed a complimentary glass of wine in front of the fireplace

There is also a Bistro on site where we enjoyed a hearty breakfast Great experience overall Enjoyed the charm this hotel offered Looking forward to our next visit No big corporate hotels for us!

Virginia

My husband and I recently stayed at the hotel for a ” winter weary” break We live up on Lake Ontario and had to add an extra day due to bad weather at home The staff was outstanding in taking care of everything for us

We thoroughly enjoyed the Bistro and the Spa as well as the wine tasting Our room was very cozy and comfortable We plan on returning soon We would love to see the grounds in the warmer weather

Carmen Garcia

This stay was very excellent! I stayed in the upper king room which had a private entrance from the outside pictures of this room does not do it justice!!! very welcoming very clean I have never stayed in a place like this before and I am definitely coming back

I have never felt so at home at a hotel before it really was exquisite Exactly what I was looking for to get away from my busy life for a night I have already recommended to everyone I know!!!

5. The William Henry Miller Inn (2-star hotel)

About this hotel

This B&B in an ornate Victorian property with stained glass windows and a turret is on the corner of a tree-lined street in bustling downtown Ithaca, and is an 11-minute walk from Cascadilla Gorge and 2.6 miles from Buttermilk Falls State Park.Set between the main house and 2 separate buildings, the 9 elegant rooms and suites are individually decorated in country-house style. They all have private bathrooms (some with whirlpool tubs), flat-screen TVs and DVD players.Free perks include parking, Wi-Fi throughout the main house, a gourmet 3-course breakfast, homemade evening desserts and all-day tea and coffee.

Things You Need to Know

  • Walking distance to Cayuga Lake Scenic Byway, Inc. and The History Center in Tompkins County
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests liked “desserts”, mentioned 11 times in reviews
  • Guests praised the breakfast

Feedback From Real Customers

Logan Bonn

Fantastic stay! The room was beautiful, cozy, and clean Comfortable bed and tasty breakfast We stayed in the Dane’s room and thoroughly enjoyed the warm jacuzzi

Great location! Inn Keeper Amy was fast to reply to our messages and recommended great places to eat close by Lily and Casey were friendly and provided a tasty breakfast in the morning 10/10 Would recommend to any and all Thank you Amy for a great stay!

J Snyder

I think the breakfast was lovely My husband values breakfast over bed I however value the comfort of my sleep over the meal served! Yes, it was a great visit, no I did not like it

I did not sleep for two nights the mattress was like cardboard If they wanted repeat customers they would fix it, my guess is they don’t get a lot of repeat customersThanks, but please get better mattresses!

Henry Collins

I just returned from a three-night stay at the William Henry Miller InnLet me start with an absolute, unconditional recommendationOur room was spacious, and had a comfortable chair and chaise for sitting and reading and knitting

(And a desk with chair)The bed was large and comfortableThe location is perfect – walking distance to everything downtownA real standout/high point is the breakfast This is NOT just cold pastries and a large bowl of little yogurts in a tub of iceThe oppositeEach morning we were served a breakfast of juice, fruit cup, freshly prepared eggs, frittata, or quiche, toast or pancake or waffle (they scrupulously observed my gluten free diet), sausage, and delicious herbed home fries (not yesterday’s leftovers reheated and fried)Each day a small dessert was delivered outside our room and again my GF diet was scrupulously observedThe women who cooked and/or served our food were cheerful, friendly, and helpful DelightfulBecause of Covid, no housekeeping was provided, as fully disclosed before we made the reservationAnd it was wonderful – we never had to worry about vacating to let housekeeping come inThe remainder of the common areas were clean and well appointedVery fairly priced tooOverall – fantastic, and on our next trip to Ithaca we will most definitely return

Featured Options

Expedia.com
Visit Site
Booking.com
Visit Site
Hotels.com
Visit Site
trivago.com
Visit Site

All Options

The William Henry Miller Inn
Visit Site
mobytrip
Visit Site

6. Country Inn & Suites by Radisson, Ithaca, NY (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

Set 3 miles from Cornell University, this relaxed hotel along State Route 96B is also 4 miles from both Ithaca Falls and Six Mile Creek Vineyard.The unfussy rooms feature free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs, and tea and coffeemakers, plus microwaves and minifridges. Suites add separate living areas, pull-out sofas, and/or whirlpool tubs; some have kitchens. Children stay at no charge with an adult.Complimentary amenities include a hot breakfast buffet, a local area shuttle, and parking. There’s also an indoor pool, a hot tub, a gym and a business center.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests liked the beds
  • 4 min drive to Buttermilk Falls State Park
  • Some guests complained about the unclean bathrooms
  • One of the few hotels in the area with room service
  • Guests praised the restaurant
  • Guests mentioned “dogs” 12 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a hot tub

Feedback From Real Customers

Dorothy Franzo

After searching the area for a budget friendly decent place to stay we decided on the the Country Inn and Suites My daughter is a first year student at Ithaca and we have stayed at two other places One was sold out the other was much more expensive

We just needed the room for the night so figured this would work We arrived and the place was nice, it was so close to campus! The front desk was so very nice though the whole trip even when an issue arrive The room was much bigger then expected, clean and comfortable Everyone had a good night sleep Breakfast was really a full buffet The pool was nice the only downside was the hot tub was out of order Hope it is working next time because we will be back!!

Kathy Smith

The pluses: The place was clean and the bed was comfortable These two items are important But then there was a rather long list of dissatisfactions

One complaint is petty: I had my taste buds set on waffles I can’t remember the last time I had one, and I was looking forward! They were included in their write up but the waffle irons sat in the kitchen area, not offeredNot a petty complaint: The tub was very poor draining I take a rather quick shower and when I finished, the water was up over my ankles The sink was equally as slow to drainAnother not petty complaint: The pool water was like ice, and the temperature of the pool area was extremely cold This probably explains why we never once saw the pool in use The hot tub was broken Leave your bathing suit homeAnd yet another complaint: Breakfast is between 6-9:30 Both mornings, we arrived at 8:45 At both coffee stations, the decaf (a requirement for me due to a heart condition) was stone cold NO coffee with breakfast, a major bummer for meThe complaints are enough for us to warrant looking at another hotel on our next stay This place was a disappointment

Shannon Kauderer

I’ve been here a few times over the year and they’re reasonable with solid pricing Everything is clean but some of it has run down over the years The whole parking lot could due with a repaving and the room itself smelled a bit off

(Luckily I brought an air filter which worked like a charm) With its location near the middle of Ithaca I’ll still come again, but it could do with a few improvements

Featured Options

Country Inn & Suites by Radisson, Ithaca, NY
Visit Site
Priceline
Visit Site
Booking.com
Visit Site
Expedia.com
Visit Site

All Options

Country Inn & Suites by Radisson, Ithaca, NY
Visit Site
Snaptravel
Visit Site

7. Argos Inn – Ithaca’s Boutique Hotel (4-star hotel)

About this hotel

A 14-minute walk from shops and dining in the town center, this sophisticated inn set in a restored neoclassical mansion is 0.5 miles from Cornell University.The 10 chic rooms feature period features, original artwork, free Wi-Fi, smart TVs, and sleek bathrooms with heated floors and rainfall showerheads. Distinct touches include daybeds, antique furniture, exposed brick walls, skylights and/or floor-to-ceiling windows.Free continental breakfast is served in an airy sunroom. There’s a courtyard, and a posh pub with a custom zinc-top bar. Kids age 12 and over are welcome. Discounted passes to a gym and a spa, both 1.2 miles away, are included.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the rooms, which have kitchenettes
  • Walking distance to The History Center in Tompkins County and Cayuga Lake Scenic Byway, Inc.
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests liked “cocktails”, mentioned 76 times in reviews
  • Guests mentioned “Patio” 11 times
  • Guests liked the breakfast
  • Guests praised the nightlife
  • Guests praised the bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Hannah Williams

This Inn was the loveliest, most comfortable space I have ever had the pleasure of staying in The rooms are gorgeous and the area is incredibly historic; they are within walking distance to Ithaca Commons but with a nice, spacious, private parking lot My sister and I really enjoyed the free luxury espresso machine on the beautiful solarium in particularly

This is a beautiful place and I cannot talk enough about how much we adored our stay!

Bea Rue

We had the absolute loveliest stay at this gorgeous hotel! The mansion was painstakingly restored to its original glory and had the most beautiful furniture and fixtures throughout All the staff were so very friendly and accommodating, the bluestone patio and back tented area were such great additions to lounge in, and every space was incredibly clean and bright with plenty of natural light The hotel was also a very short 2-block walk to the downtown area of Ithaca Commons with all the shops, bars and restaurants

We loved every second there and can’t wait to return!

John Catlett

We had an excellent stay at the Argos Inn The staff was friendly and attentive, the atmosphere was very relaxed, and the space was really comfortable The room was beautifully furnished and the recent snowfall made everything seem serene and magical, especially looking down over the lanterns on the back patio through our window

We will be back the next time we come back to town

8. Ithaca Marriott Downtown on the Commons (4-star hotel)

About this hotel

Close to bars and eateries in the downtown area, this upmarket hotel with contemporary styling is a mile from both the Herbert F. Johnson Museum of Art and Cornell University, and 6 miles from Ithaca Tompkins Regional Airport.Bright, modern rooms provide Wi-Fi (fee), flat-screen TVs, minifridges and coffeemakers; some feature floor-to-ceiling windows with city views. Suites add living areas and/or pull-out sofas. Room service is available 24/7.An airport and university shuttle is free. Other amenities include a restaurant, a 24-hour fitness room and a business center. Parking is available at additional cost.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the clean rooms
  • Walking distance to The History Center in Tompkins County and Cayuga Lake Scenic Byway, Inc.
  • One of the few hotels in the area with 24-hr room service
  • Guests liked the restaurant
  • Guests mentioned lobbies 14 times
  • Guests liked the bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Ronette Williams

The hotel management (Kellen) and staff were incredibly polite, professional and efficient! My room was clean and quiet I really enjoyed my meal with family at the Monk’s restaurant in the hotel Affordable and decent wine list, fast elevators, clean inside and outside of the hotel

Great location for access to local restaurants, stores, parks, Cornell and Ithaca College I will be back!

Tina Hoff (LifeBeats)

We have stayed in the Marriott in downtown Ithaca NY twice and each time the rooms were immaculately clean, and the service was excellent (even though, like all service industries, they are short staffed) The breakfast at Monk’s Restaurant is really good, tooDuring our most recent stay, my son worked out with me in the fitness center, and did too much after a large meal

He got sick, and after calling the front desk, a very kind custodian came to help His name was Jose, and he was very understanding and helpful We were very grateful for him He should be commended for his service and his kindness

M

This hotel has potential because it’s a great location and I like the more modern features and thoughts in the room It seemed like there was fresh air pumped into the room and you with a little work to get the room dark at night And quiet with the idea of putting the fridge and microwave further away in a cabinet

There was some nice efficient feel to a couple of the hospitality staff I dealt with but mostly felt inconsistent and inconvenient, especially at the beginning before I knew my way around and the limitations You are very much on your own now with mobile phone key entry They don’t leave a phone number or a menu in your room so you know where to order food when you arriveIt seems possibly they hire some people quick to do some jobs around there without the right training or value in hospitality or allowance to accommodate, and that matters for everybody

Featured Options

Ithaca Marriott Downtown on the Commons
Visit Site
Booking.com
Visit Site
Expedia.com
Visit Site
Hotels.com
Visit Site

All Options

Ithaca Marriott Downtown on the Commons
Visit Site
mobytrip
Visit Site

9. The Hotel Ithaca (3-star hotel)

  • Address: 222 S Cayuga St, Ithaca, NY 14850
  • Phone: (607) 272-1000
  • Ratings: 4.2 (844 reviews) Very good
  • Website : The Hotel Ithaca
  • Check-in time: 4:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 12:00 PM
  • Quick Summary: Warm rooms & suites with flat-screen TVs, plus an informal American restaurant & an indoor pool.

About this hotel

Located a block from Highway 79, this functional hotel is 0.9 miles from Cornell University and 3.2 miles from the Museum of the Earth.Bright, warmly decorated rooms come with free Wi-Fi, and flat-screen TVs with premium cable channels. Polished suites include separate living rooms. Room service is available.Parking is free. A casual restaurant serves traditional American cuisine, and there’s a heated indoor pool with a deck with lounge chairs. Other amenities include an exercise room, a business center, and a conference center with a ballroom.

Things You Need to Know

  • Walking distance to The History Center in Tompkins County and Cayuga Lake Scenic Byway, Inc.
  • One of the few hotels in the area with room service
  • Guests praised the large, clean rooms but some complained about the kitchenettes
  • Some guests complained about the air conditioning
  • Guests liked the service
  • Guests praised the fitness center

Feedback From Real Customers

Marion Campbell

We stayed here August 2-4 in room 237 It was the worst hotel experience we have both encountered When we checked in, two employees were in our room already, which was very strange

They claimed to be “checking to see if everything is ok” which is “why” they were in our room However, I noticed immediately the dank smell as well as the prior guests’ hair that was not cleaned up on the bathroom floor, so I am not sure what those employees were doing in there It kept getting worse We looked outside the dreary drapes and over the air conditioner from 1970 and noticed we had a view of absolutely nothing A concrete wall No sunlight The room was extremely dark and smelt of mould when the 1970’s air conditioner was not on There was no water pressure in the sink, there would only be a dribble of water that came out if you turned it on to its full capacityThe best part was when the family with a baby moved in next to us and we realized the walls were made out of paper as it seemed that we were in the room with them The baby cried for hours at a time, including during the period of 1 AM to 230 AM We were fed up and called the front desk to ask if they could help but they did absolutely nothing They didn’t even call the other room to see if everything was okay (we know this because we could hear every single word of what was happening in room 239)Because of all of this we decided we were going to leave one day early and give up our second night This was one the worst place we have stayed in our travelling life (we have travelled quite a bit too all over the world)

Randall Barnes

I’m simply TRYING to spend money with these people by making a reservation I was on hold for 20 minutes until I hung up Called back and got a recording

Called back and pressed the option for the Director of Sales, got a recording, Hung up called reservations again, and was told I was going to be put on hold I said I had already been on hold for 20 minutes, etc The woman on the phone said they were just really busy and I’D have to call THEM back No offer to take my number and call me I told her if they couldn’t help make a reservation, which is the basis of any hotel’s existence, I guess I’d shop elsewhere The woman basically said “whatever” and hung up I can only imagine what a stay at this place would be like if they could care less when you are trying to give them business I’d say move on!

Doss Freel

Very disappointing for the price I was there for a Wedding and will not be staying there again Here’s the list

-couldn’t get into our room until 4 hours after check-in time-found hair, bottle caps, and half drunk coffee in the room from previous guest-internet was patchy at best-room phone was broken-bubbling wallpaper and ceiling damage in bathroom-full length mirror and mini fridge missing entirelyInformed the front desk about these items during our three night stay and nothing was done

Featured Options

HotelsCombined
Visit Site
The Hotel Ithaca
Visit Site
trivago.com
Visit Site
Expedia.com
Visit Site

All Options

The Hotel Ithaca
Visit Site
Agoda
Visit Site

10. Courtyard by Marriott Ithaca Airport/University (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

This modern hotel is 2.6 miles from Cornell University and 4.1 miles from Stewart Park on Cayuga Lake.Contemporary rooms offer free WiFi, desks, flat-screen TVs with premium cable channels, minifridges and coffeemakers. Suites add separate living areas and sofabeds.Social spaces include a living room-style lobby. The American restaurant serves breakfast and dinner as well as all-day drinks, including Starbucks coffee. There’s also a business center with workstations and printers, and a meeting room. Other amenities include an indoor pool, a whirlpool and an exercise room, a complimentary area shuttle and free on-site parking.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the beds
  • 7 min drive to Cornell University
  • Guests praised the service, which has a concierge
  • Guests mentioned “Bistro” 13 times
  • Guests mentioned lobbies 10 times
  • The fitness center has elliptical machines and treadmills

Feedback From Real Customers

Michael Cimini

Really happy with the service we received Because it was a busy weekend and because our plans changed a few times leading up to it, we ended up booking multiple rooms and multiple different time frames With one quick chat message through the app, the team at the hotel had our rooms all sorted exactly as I asked! Breakfast counter served us 15 minutes after closing

Rooms and common areas were clean and in good repair The near airport location is actually in a very nicely landscaped office park with streams, ponds, deer, ducks and bunnies Great stay!

Chris Christofilakes

Clean and well maintained Things that were aggravating: I was out in a wheelchair accessible room, the layout and features of the room were less than stellar for someone without special access needs The room was right near the elevator and the commotion from the elevator bank ruined two nights sleep

The air conditioning wasn’t sufficient to keep the room cool enough for me to sleep And worst of all, the water pressure was barely effective for hygiene Good location, but I would avoid if possible

Joyce Ho

Picked this location for the price and availability nearby during first week of June Travelling with 2 adults and 1 medium size dog from Boston on my way back to CALocation – was good, located in a business park area, very quiet at night

Parking was spacious and free 15 mins drive to core areaStaff – were nice and helpful, they did serve Starbucks coffee in the morning at the bar, as there is literally nothing nearby the hotelRoom – It was a bit disappointed for the price I paid for It was spacious, however its a bit outdated, and run down Carpet was dirty, I have paid extra $75 for the pet stay, I was expecting spotless I saw dirt, food crumbs on the carpet when I first walked in The bathroom also need some update, the faucet, bathtub, sink were a bit old with stain on itI think the overall room probably need some upgrade and more effort on cleaning if charging your guest $235 a night, with an additional $75 pet feeParking – I think is time to consider adding a few EV charging station at the parking lot to keep up with customer needsFor EV Owners: There are no EV charging station at the parking, I droved to the core area for charging before heading to the hotel

Featured Options

Expedia.com
Visit Site
Courtyard by Marriott Ithaca Airport/University
Visit Site
Booking.com
Visit Site
Hotels.com
Visit Site

All Options

Courtyard by Marriott Ithaca Airport/University
Visit Site
mobytrip
Visit Site

11. Cayuga Lake Inn – Ithaca Hotel Alt

About this hotel

Overlooking Cayuga Lake, this refined bed-and-breakfast on the Finger Lakes Wine Trail is 20 miles from Taughannock Falls and 17 miles from Cayuga Nature Center.The individually decorated rooms with a European flair provide lake views, Jacuzzis, and complimentary Wi-Fi. The 1-bedroom suites have separate living rooms. Some offer furnished balconies; others have private garden courtyards.Parking is free. Breakfast is served in a cozy dining room.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests liked the rooms
  • 4 min drive to Myers Park
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a hot tub

Feedback From Real Customers

Scott Williams

Contacted Diane in advance as I was traveling for business; had some questions regarding the flexibility of my stay Diane was very prompt in her reply, and said it wouldn’t be an issueAs a small business owner, I greatly appreciated the non-chain hotel “feel” of her beautiful accommodations, and Diane herself is so genuinely friendly and helpful

I wound up being there 4 nights, and Diane was ever so willing to let me come and go as I pleasedI would not hesitate to recommend a stay here- absolutely gorgeous views of Cayuga Lake, a few minutes to several good places to eat/drink, etc I will definitely be staying there again next time I am in the area Thank you again Diane for everything!

Jim Del Garbino

Although our room was spacious and clean, the rest of the property is extremely cluttered and dirty The common area tables were full of odd things and crumbs, deflated old balloons, lots of dust The outside seat cushions are old, flat and very uncomfortable

The grounds are terribly neglected with overgrown grass and weeds everywhere The outside terrace furniture needs to be replaced and the whole thing cleaned up It was clear Diane was not aware we had booked breakfast and literally pulled leftovers out of her fridge and made a very strange dish that was not very appealing She never asked about dietary allergies or preferences This is unfortunate since she could easily get some bakery pastries, fruit, yogurt, granola etc without much effort and make it quite nice for guests We decided to go somewhere else for breakfast on the additional daysThere was also a very stale dusty smell in our room, on the bedding and towels I sprayed air freshener in the hopes to make it better but it only masked the smell for a little while Yes, the inn is quirky which could add to the charm, but instead it just makes it look dated, dusty and in need of a huge makeover I am pretty sure the comforters, pillows etc haven’t been washed in a really long time If you are considering this inn, please just be aware that all of the photos are very old The inn and grounds do not look anything like what you see I wish I had done a better job in checking the reviews and considered the poor ones, not just the good ones I feel like there was a bit of a bait and switch here

Abhishek Das

We stayed here during 4th of July weekend Absolutely awesome location and gorgeous views from the deck of the inn Diane was amazing too with her sweetness and energy! She cooked fresh breakfast every morning for us

Lots of attractions nearby including Myers park only 5 minutes awaywe had a great time Highly recommend!

Featured Options

trivago.com
Visit Site
Tripadvisor.com
Visit Site
MOMONDO.com
Visit Site
mobytrip
Visit Site

All Options

mobytrip
Visit Site
Next Day Hotels
Visit Site

12. Thomas Farm Bed & Breakfast

  • Address: 136 Thomas Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850
  • Phone: (607) 539-9916
  • Ratings: 5.0 (130 reviews) Excellent
  • Website : Thomas Farm Bed & Breakfast
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: A B&B set in 120 lush acres, offering vintage-style rooms/suites & included gourmet breakfast.

About this hotel

Tucked into a wooded hillside, this family-run B&B is in a country residence which sits amongst 120 acres of hiking/ski-ing trails, forests and a pond. Six Mile Creek vineyard is an 8-minute drive, while revered Cornell university is 13 minutes’. Ithaca falls is 15 minutes’ away, while Downtown Ithaca itself, with its vibrant restaurants and shopping, is 8.5 miles.Vintage-style rooms and 2 suites feature free WiFi, antiques and private bathrooms; most have electric fireplaces. One suite has a kitchenette and a private deck, while the other has 2 bedrooms.A gourmet breakfast is included and served in a homey dining room.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the rooms, which have kitchenettes
  • The rooms have microwaves
  • Guests praised the bathrooms
  • 8 min drive to Potter’s Falls
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests mentioned “French toast” 10 times
  • Guests liked “gourmet”, mentioned 11 times in reviews
  • Guests praised the breakfast

Feedback From Real Customers

Lynn Hawkins

A group of 11 stayed two nights in March at the Thomas Farm B&B while in Ithaca for a gymnastics meet We were so fortunate to have found such a wonderful place to stay The home and setting is beautiful and the rooms were very comfortable with little extras that were so appreciated! Nancy and Rich welcomed us like family and were so accommodating to our requests for a late breakfast one morning and to add our girls to the group the second morning

The breakfasts were delicious and so enjoyable We definitely want to return to the Thomas Farm B&B when the weather is warmer to enjoy the grounds and more in the Ithaca area Thank you so much for a wonderful weekend!

Barbara Cohen

Nancy and Rich were the perfect hosts; gracious, warm, welcoming, hospitable, and accommodating They achieved a perfect balance of friendly and respectful of our privacy They truly helped make our stay in Ithaca very special and were a wonderful source of information about local events and restaurants

The house was beautiful and our room was lovely; spacious with a kitchenette and direct access to the porch I am vegan and Nancy’s breakfasts were outstanding! She went out of her way to check in with me about my preferences and offered many choices It was almost paradise – if only they had a hot tub We enthusiastically recommend Thomas Farm B & B to all travelers to the area

Todd Stady

What a wonderful stay! My wife and I spent a weekend in Grace’s room We’ve stayed in many B&B’s over the years and hands down one of the best experiences we’ve had! Nancy and Rich are wonderful hosts, warm and welcoming We enjoyed our conversations (and Nancy’s fantastic breakfasts)

The room, house and grounds were all well kept, neat, clean The rooms were full/near full while we were there; nonetheless it was quiet and no issues with getting a good nights rest! Situated along a quiet country road, we’ll be sure to stay here again should we wander back to Ithaca or the surrounding area! Thanks again, Todd and Julie!

13. Inn On Columbia

  • Address: 228 Columbia St, Ithaca, NY 14850
  • Phone: (607) 272-0204
  • Ratings: 4.5 (44 reviews) Excellent
  • Website : Inn On Columbia
  • Check-in time: 4:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 12:00 PM
  • Quick Summary: Bright rooms in a polished guesthouse in an 1830s building, offering a shared kitchen & a lounge.

About this hotel

In a private 1830s home with an annex, this polished guesthouse is a 9-minute walk from shops at the Ithaca Commons pedestrian mall, and less than a mile from Highway 79.The 4 colorful, individually styled rooms feature free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs and coffeemakers, as well as en suite bathrooms. A room in a glass-enclosed gazebo offers a fireplace and a whirlpool tub, while a 1-bedroom apartment in an annex adds a living room and a kitchen. Breakfast is served in-room.Common areas include a guest kitchen, a dining area and an airy lounge, plus a terrace with outdoor seating.

Things You Need to Know

  • The rooms have kitchenettes
  • Walking distance to The History Center in Tompkins County and Wells Falls
  • Guests praised the service

Feedback From Real Customers

Rick Corey

Beautiful, clean, and comfortable place to stay! Loved the location and walked to downtown and to the Cornell campus Kenn and Madeline are great hosts! Very friendly and easy going! The breakfast each morning was unbelievable! So delicious! We had a choice each morning of what to have for breakfast We are so glad we stayed there!

Jackie Beaulieu

We LOVE staying at the Inn On Columbia! Madeline & Kenn are the most wonderful and hospital hosts The options are fabulous and always clean, well appointed, and equip with anything you might need Breakfast scones and muffins are always fresh and yummy, but if you prefer a full breakfast, no need to go anywhere but the main house where Madeline will cook you up an incredible breakfast from scratch! Whether you’re in town for work or a holiday, the Inn will never disappoint! Thank you, Madeline & Kenn!

14. Hilton Garden Inn Ithaca (3-star hotel)

  • Address: 130 E Seneca St, Ithaca, NY 14850
  • Phone: (607) 277-8900
  • Ratings: 4.5 (630 reviews) Excellent Eco-certified
  • Website : Hilton Garden Inn Ithaca
  • Check-in time: 4:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 12:00 PM
  • Quick Summary: Urban hotel with Irish-style restaurant & pub, business center, plus free WiFi & area shuttle.

About this hotel

A 2-minute walk from Ithaca Commons, this downtown hotel is under a mile from Cornell University.All contemporary rooms offer custom-designed beds, flat-screen TVs with premium cable channels, microwaves, minifridges, desks with ergonomic chairs, and free WiFi. Suites add separate living areas with pull-out sofas, and whirlpool tubs.A cooked-to-order breakfast is available (fee), and there’s an on-site Irish-style pub and restaurant, and 24/7 convenience mart. Guests can visit the fitness center, indoor pool and whirlpool. Additional amenities include 2 meeting rooms and a business center, plus a free area shuttle and parking.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the beds
  • Guests praised the bathrooms
  • Walking distance to The History Center in Tompkins County and Cayuga Lake Scenic Byway, Inc.
  • One of the few hotels in the area with room service
  • Guests liked the on-site restaurant
  • Guests mentioned hot tubs 14 times
  • Guests praised the fitness center

Feedback From Real Customers

andrea breitman

I have traveled often for work and staying at this hotel was a breath of fresh air Everything from the check-in process, the room itself, the cleanliness, and the check-out process surpassed my expectations in every way The location is excellent, within walking distance of anything in the downtown area of Ithaca

And I have to give a special shout out and thank you to Kate (Katie?) who helped me check out, who went above and beyond with helping me feel welcome (even as I was leaving!) as well as informed about my options for food and transportation I will definitely be back!

Steven Kiel

Absolutely fantastic Ann and Dwayne were extremely pleasant, and the stay has been excellent The check in process was smooth, and everything was clearly explained upon arrival

They had a room ready for us an hour early, and great suggestions for the area on top of the booklet they had for us The facility itself is excellent Extremely clean Not the fake covid cleaning clean, I mean genuinely clean and cared for Dare I say, without fault I don’t understand why such an establishment has such a low cost The pool looked nice, but by the evening there were several towels sitting around The fitness center is nicer, and has a better variety of equipment, than my local planet fitness If I had to point out something lacking, it would be that the business area is just a computer in the lobby with a printer Honestly, what else is needed than the ability to print? The night clerk at the desk wasn’t very friendly or interested in saying much at all, but the staff in the daytime was great If the valet had top hats, I’d say it was on par with the Ritz-Carlton

Patrick Hallock

I contacted the hotel to let them know I’d be arriving early and within minutes they informed me that a room would be ready hours before the usual check-in time The front desk staff was very friendly and knowledgeable about the area My room was clean with plenty of space and a nice view of Ithaca

And the food at the attached pub was very good I would recommend and stay there again

Featured Options

Booking.com
Visit Site
Priceline
Visit Site
Expedia.com
Visit Site
Hotels.com
Visit Site

All Options

Hilton Garden Inn Ithaca
Visit Site
HotelWiz
Visit Site

You May Also Like

Sharing is caring!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *