5 star hotels in Jamestown, NY

1. Chautauqua Harbor Hotel (4-star hotel)

  • Address: 10 Dunham Ave, Celoron, NY 14720
  • Phone: (716) 489-2800
  • Ratings: 4.6 (699 reviews) Excellent
  • Website : Chautauqua Harbor Hotel
  • Check-in time: 4:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Down-to-earth quarters in a casual lakefront hotel with a restaurant & a bar, plus a fitness center.

About this hotel

Set 4 miles from I-86, this laid-back lakefront hotel is a 4-minute walk from Lucille Ball Memorial Park and 3 miles from the National Comedy Center.Down-to-earth rooms and suites feature complimentary Wi-Fi, plus flat-screen TVs and minifridges. Some add balconies with lake views.Amenities include a restaurant and a bar, plus an indoor pool and an outdoor pool. There’s also a gym and a conference center.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the clean rooms and the beds
  • Walking distance to Lucille Ball Statue and Lucille Ball Memorial Park
  • Guests liked the friendly service
  • Guests mentioned “the sunset” 10 times
  • Guests praised the grounds
  • Guests praised the breakfast
  • Guests praised the lake views
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a hot tub

Feedback From Real Customers

Sarah Broecker

Beautiful property!!! Was so impressed with it Right on the lake, gorgeous promenade along the water, indoor & outdoor pools, hot tub, bar & restaurant, outdoor games like a small putting green, all amenities of a full hotel The food at the restaurant was very good

Has a clean, & upscale feel Highly recommend the lake view rooms with balconies We watched the sunset from it & the bed! Just a gorgeous place The direct surrounding area is definitely not the same feel, but there are lots of other nice things to do within a short distance

Maryjane Hutton

Lovely sunsets Room was comfortable Inside and outside pool

Room looked clean, but a stuffed purple animal with ample dust bunnies from a former resident was under the bed I found it checking to leave nothing of mine behind It wasn’t as clean as expected Linen was sparseI stayed end of August 2020 Rates were close to $200 a nightFood was adequate Grounds were lovely Lake was filled with blue green algae which is “normal ” now for New York Very pretty resort

Ajay Ojha

Great location and even better service Right in front of the lake Plenty of boat rentals nearby

Most nearby restaurants deliver with door dash etcIt’s a bit expensive and they don’t have laundry facilityThe food is great Very limited options for vegetariansThere are 2 pools The outdoor pool is heatedTheir products like moisturizer etc are premium quality and for sale too

2. Wind Rush Cottage Inn

About this hotel

14722, 18 Simpson Ave, Mayville, NY 14757(716) 753-0599

Things You Need to Know

  • Walking distance to Miller Bell Tower and the Chautauqua Institution
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a hot tub

Feedback From Real Customers


The Wind Rush Cottage is open year-round and I can’t imagine a nicer place to stay in Chautauqua The décor is charming, the rooms are comfortable and clean (looks like they’ve been remodeled very recently), and the shared sitting/dining room is perfect for getting to know and enjoy the company of the other guests The owner, Betty, is very sweet

My room, on the second floor with a queen bed, was very spacious and included a Jacuzzi tub and direct access to a screened-in porch which opened to another porch overlooking Simpson Avenue The location can’t be beat There’s also a shared kitchen, A/C, and laundry What a great find This is the kind of place where you don’t want to leave, but you can’t wait to get home to write a great review Thanks Betty! Five stars plus is definitely very well deserved!!

3. Maple Springs Lake Side Inn (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

Overlooking Chautauqua Lake, this stately B&B on a sprawling property with a private dock is 4 miles from I-86. It’s also a mile from the 360-acre Long Point State Park, and 10 miles from the renowned cultural programs at the Chautauqua Institution.Quaint rooms furnished with antiques offer Wi-Fi and en-suite, shower-only bathrooms. Some suites add TVs, fireplaces, kitchenettes and dining areas; 2 feature whirlpool tubs. All have lake views.A full breakfast is available. There’s a serene garden and a private beach, as well as dock space for guests’ boats.

Things You Need to Know

  • 15 min walk to Midway State Park
  • Guests praised the service, which has a concierge
  • Guests mentioned “bonfires” 12 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast

Feedback From Real Customers

Rebekah Stanley

Honestly, I can’t say enough about how great this experience was! Rose and Paul were fun, flexible and overall wonderful hosts My husband and I stayed for a week in August 2021 for our 15th anniversary I am allergic to lactose and gluten intolerant, and we had pretty much given up on B&B’s years ago because of those things and how poor the experiences became

We decided to give it another shot when we came across The Maple Springs Inn I was blown away by the AMAZING job Rose did as chef!  She went above and beyond! Stuffed blueberry french toast, delicious breakfast quiches with lactose friendly cheese, fresh scones and muffins in different flavors everyday You name it, we had it We’ve traveled all over, and her food was truly amazing, gourmet level We ate so well we didn’t even need lunch most days We stayed in the Downstairs Carriage House It was beautiful, clean, very comfortable, and has a lovely view of the inn and the lake The staff and service of the room was great, and they had good suggestions of places to visit or things we might enjoy checking out in the area We went out on the boat and had breakfast at the marina one morning, which was a special treat to spend the morning on the water The lake access is peaceful and beautiful, and sitting by the bonfire was the perfect way to end each day   Thank you, Rose and Paul for a really amazing, fun experience that we will treasure! We look forward to coming back 🙂

Chris D

We stayed at this Inn over Memorial Day weekend and it was quite wonderful Beautiful view of the lake Very Very relaxing and peaceful

Just what we neededI grew up in Chautauqua County but hadn’t been back in 20+ years The weekend brought back some great memories The room was clean and comfortable The Saturday morning breakfast boat ride was a fun treat and the Sunday morning breakfast was utterly delicious OMG the scones! We found lots of fun things to do in the area as well! We’ll be staying here again next time we venture back to Chautauqua

Terri Carney

We absolutely LOVED our stay at Maple Springs Lake Side Inn with Paul and Rosemary (and Mike!) It was our first visit to Chautauqua and we will definitely be back We stayed one night just before the Memorial Day weekend and though we were the only three in the house we got the full treatment from our hosts: a bonfire by the lake (a very short walk down the driveway!) with blooming lilacs all around; a gorgeous breakfast of quiche, fresh fruit, and homemade lemon-blueberry scones; an upgrade to accommodate my adult daughter joining us; and dinner recommendations (a short walk away)

We enjoyed meeting Laila (the owner’s dog) as she chased a ball on the stunningly beautiful lawn (dotted with mature trees) and splashed in the fountain and had lovely conversations with Paul (about Chautauqua history), Mike (about growing up in Chautauqua), and Rosemary (how to start a bonfire–LOL)!

4. Hampton Inn & Suites Jamestown (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

This modern hotel is 2 miles from both Desilu Studios, a museum dedicated to the “I Love Lucy” TV series, and the Roger Tory Peterson Institute of Natural History.All rooms include free WiFi and custom-designed beds, plus both full and lap desks (for working on the bed), flat-screen TVs and coffeemakers. Suites add kitchenettes and sofabeds.Free parking, and hot breakfast or weekday breakfast bags to go are offered, as well as an exercise room and an indoor pool. Additional amenities include 2 meeting rooms and a 24/7 business center.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the clean rooms, which have microwaves
  • 7 min walk to Lake View Cemetery Association
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests mentioned pools 19 times
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a casino

Feedback From Real Customers

Julie Bowles

The location was perfect!! It is right off the highway and there’s a gas station right in front of the hotel The front desk was very nice and helpful The rooms were very clean and the beds were comfortable

The hotel was only 5 minutes from downtown Jamestown and only 25 minutes from Seneca Allegany Casino The rates were good and we had an excellent time!!!

5. Pine Hill Cottages & Motel

About this hotel

This simple motel with chalets and cottages is off interstate 86, set within woodland on the western shore of the Catauqua lake. The surrounding area is known for fishing, golfing and hiking.All of the casual rooms have TVs with cable channels and private bathrooms. The suites have full kitchens and sitting/dining areas, as well as private balconies/terraces. While the 1 to 4 bedroom chalets or cottages have decks. There’s also a log cabin.Down on the lake-shore there’s a dock with boat slips available for hire, while there’s also a kids’ playground.

Things You Need to Know

  • 6 min drive to Chautauqua Lake
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests mentioned “lakes” 12 times

Feedback From Real Customers

Jacki Z

What a find!! First time staying and would definitely stay again The owner and office manager were both friendly and helpful We had a deck motel room with a view of the lake

Quiet and quaint Was only planning to stay one night but decided to stay another since we were enjoying the peaceful setting Highly recommend! Thanks again for a great stay


Owner was very communicative and thoughtful Since we were arriving after dark, she sent detailed instructions with map ahead of time, had the lights on and AC on to welcome us The room was clean and air smelled fresh

Walls were all pine Room was very quiet, except for the AC window unit We would have looked to stay longer to enjoy the lake front, but didn’t have much time in our schedule Would absolutely go back again

6. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Jamestown, an IHG Hotel (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

Just off Interstate 86, this contemporary budget hotel is 2 miles from the Lucille Ball Desi Arnaz & Museum Center for Comedy. It’s also 3 miles from the Roger Tory Peterson Institute of Natural History.The modern, warmly decorated rooms feature flat-screen TVs, minifridges and coffeemakers, plus free Wi-Fi. Suites add kitchenettes, dining areas and sitting areas with pull-out couches. Kids age 19 and under stay free with an adult.Complimentary perks include a breakfast buffet, served in a casual dining area. There’s also an exercise room and an indoor pool.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests liked the clean rooms
  • 10 min walk to Lake View Cemetery Association
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests mentioned showers 18 times
  • The fitness center has treadmills and elliptical machines
  • Guests praised the indoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Laura Alford Paquin

Really nice/clean rooms, staff and breakfast (Get the strawberry pink parfait in the fridge; You’re welcome!)The reason for 4 and not 5 stars is the walls are a bit thin I could hear everything upstairs and next door to me

Pack a white noise machine and you’ll be fine And the ice machine on the second floor was not workingGreat place to stay, regardless Thank you!

Maria George

The hotel was nice Clean room and pool The elevators decided when they wanted to work and not

A few times we had to take the stairs to the third floor Fine for us since we’re young The worst part for us was housekeeping coming in to our room 3 times in the morning while we were sleeping because they thought we left check out isn’t until 12 but they don’t make you feel very welcome Definitely double lock the doors

Jacqueline G

We couldn’t get our king but they got us another spot in no time Lots of sheet dust on the Keurig and counter tops but regardless it’s the best hotel we’ve stayed at on our long trip The receptionists were great and personal

And the breakfast options are great! And the lights above the bed are amazing for a kiddo scared of the dark!

7. Chautauqua Suites Hotel & Expo Center (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

Overlooking Chautauqua Lake, this relaxed all-suite hotel is a 16-minute walk from Lakeside Park and 9 miles from the fun rides at Midway State Park.Featuring separate living rooms with sofabeds, the modest suites include free Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs; some have lake views. Upgraded suites add wet bars, coffeemakers, minifridges and microwaves, plus whirlpool tubs. Room service is available.Complimentary perks include continental breakfast and parking. There’s an Italian restaurant, and a bar offering live music. There’s also a conference center with 8 meeting rooms, and a business center, as well as a gym.

Things You Need to Know

  • 2 min drive to the Pennsylvania Railroad Station
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a 24-hr front desk
  • Guests mentioned “hamburgers” 10 times
  • Guests liked the breakfast
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Lisa Yaggie

Have stayed over night a couple of times after events The venue is great for large gatherings / events They need to figure out how to staff the inside bar – has been an issue for years

Olives, the restaurant and the real bar are cozy and has good service The rooms were always clean- nice – nothing terribly unique but decent price The only issues I’ve ever had were with the desk staff But that changes so often that you can’t count that as a real factor unless you take that as an indicator that management needs to do a better job training their staff

Tanner Buford

This was such a lovely hotel! It blew our entires families expectations out of the water! The staff was so friendly and the rooms were very clean! The bathrooms were so clean and it felt amazing The restaurants in the hotel are very good too! Definitely recommend stopping here if you get a chance! This was an unexpected stop and it turned into one of the best hotel experiences I’ve ever had!

Patty Schmidt

We came here from outa town to do a job on the lake The room was great except the fact it had a thermostat instead of an ac unit When I arrived exhausted after hauling 4 pallets of cement, it was literally hotter than acceptable on the coldest of days

There was a very strange seemingly angry dude that worked alone on the night shift She was rude and yelled at me like a child after working 14 hours that day for simply asking a question I wanted to leave as I got there The burgers we ordered for the crew also tasted like Burger King☆Very clean The day staff was cool and helpful Breakfast was amazing and they gave us tickets for it to be free

8. DoubleTree by Hilton Jamestown (3-star hotel)

  • Address: 150 W 4th St, Jamestown, NY 14701
  • Phone: (716) 488-7227
  • Ratings: 4.4 (431 reviews) Very good Eco-certified
  • Website : DoubleTree by Hilton Jamestown
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 12:00 PM
  • Quick Summary: Relaxed rooms & suites in an unassuming hotel offering a restaurant/bar, an indoor pool & a lounge.

About this hotel

Set along a tree-lined street, this casual hotel with a contemporary vibe is a 2-minute walk from Lucille Ball exhibits at the Lucy Desi Museum, a 4-minute walk from the National Comedy Center and a 6-minute walk from Jamestown Gateway train station.Featuring floor-to-ceiling windows, the relaxed rooms have flat-screens, minifridges and coffeemakers, as well as sitting areas and Wi-Fi access. Suites add wet bars, microwaves and living space. Room service is available.Parking is free. A breakfast buffet is served in an informal restaurant/bar. Other amenities include an indoor pool, a gym and an airy lobby lounge, plus meeting and event space.

Things You Need to Know

  • The rooms have refrigerators
  • Walking distance to National Comedy Center and the Lucille Ball-Desi Arnaz Center
  • Some guests disliked the bathrooms
  • One of the few hotels in the area with room service
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests liked “cookies”, mentioned 17 times in reviews
  • Guests praised the indoor pool
  • Guests praised the airy lobby bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Jera Nicole Piper

The rooms are spacious, VERY clean and comfortable The bathrooms are fantastic with personal lighted vanity mirrors The shower was amazing with great water pressure! I’m still giving 5 stars but, just a heads up, you can hear the people quite clearly in the next room

The location is extremely convenient and the parking garage connects to the second floor via the covered skyway bridge Side note: Jamestown, I can only imagine was an active and thriving city at one point but you can feel the effects of the current economic climate now While staying at the hotel you are only 5-7 minutes from the lakeLastly, the restaurant connected with Double Tree was a delightful surprise The food, drinks and wait staff were great

Dennis Schiraldi

Stayed here recently on a ski trip to Holiday Valley, which puts you there in about 40-minutes The rate was great considering how much you are going to pay to stay anywhere near the ski town There’s a little activity in Jamestown and this hotel is within walking distance of everything, hotel holed up good for a 1-night stay passing through

Ate at the hotel staff was super friendly, food was good, good selection of local beers on tap We enjoyed our stay, rooms were clean, comfortable and what you expect from the Double Tree Parking right outside our door No breakfast in the morning, not a deal breaker, not taking points off for otherwise a solid hotel offering for the price!

Dianna Bennett

Decent hotel in the heart of downtown Jamestown and close to everythingThe rooms were clean and comfortable with a nice view on the street side Large windows allow for a lot of natural light and make the space feel spacious and inviting

Services were short staffed and getting room service or just small requests filled was somewhat difficult due to staffingOur room had a refrigerator but not a microwave The microwave offered to the entire floor outside the elevators is a little worn out and dirty Ice machine on our floor was also downIndoor pool area was fun for our family Poolside towels weren’t the greatestOverall a decent stay for your next visit to the area

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *