5 star hotels in Lancaster, OH

1. Thunder Ridge Cabins B & B

About this hotel

11309 Starner Rd, Rockbridge, OH 43149(740) 385-1386

Things You Need to Know

  • 6 min drive to Clear Creek Metro Park
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests liked “muffins”, mentioned 13 times in reviews
  • The hotel has breakfast
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Arica Reed

Most beautiful view Husband got otter lodge for my birthday and it was beautiful secluded and the owners were so nice and personable Susan’s muffins are my daughters favorite part! They were so yummy! So much to explore and the hot tub was super nice to relax in even when it was 3 degrees out! Community fire pit would definitely be nice in the spring/fall to gather round

We had a nice fire w snow on the ground lol highly recommend this stay So peaceful and that’s what mattered to me Thanks Susan and Micah

Daniel Broderick

My wife and I stayed one night at the Otter Lodge and it was excellent It is close to the other two lodges, but far enough away that we felt isolated The fire pit and grill are shared between the cabins, and we made use of them when no one else was there, but that’s not a guarantee

The cabin (one room with a bathroom and balcony) itself was clean and free of bugs, which was surprising because the property is tucked away in the woods The jacuzzi on the balcony was great as well Thunder Ridge is less commercialized and I think it is run solely by Susan, who helped us check in and provided a cart to lug our suitcases across the lawn to the cabin She was very welcoming and kind and the breakfast muffins were a nice touch Normally they would be baked by Susan herself, but unfortunately her oven had broken and hadn’t been repaired yetOverall, it was a nice, isolated getaway, and close to lots of great spots in Hocking Hills Can’t beat the price either!

2. A Georgian Manner Bed & Breakfast

About this hotel

Overlooking Lake Logan, this plush adults-only B&B in a striking Georgian-style home is 14 miles from Old Man’s Cave in Hocking Hills and 4 miles from Hocking Hills Canopy Tours.The romantic, individually decorated rooms and suites offer antique-style furnishings and lake views, and may include such features as 4-poster beds, balconies and/or private whirlpool tubs. Some units also have private bathrooms.Breakfast is served in a formal dining room. There’s a lakeside pavilion, a wine cellar, and a veranda. Parking is available.

Things You Need to Know

  • 3 min drive to Lake Logan State Park

Feedback From Real Customers

Nicholas Patrick

Charged for a room we didn’t even stay in or take the keys to when we arrived Thought we had cleared it up when we got to the B&B, but came to find out they charged my card anyways At best, we made a simple oversight in our booking

At worst, we were just taken advantage of Either way, i think the fair thing to do would be to only charge us for the services we actually used – two nights in ONE room They might reply to this message stating they knocked off the price of one night for the room we didnt use(which they did) but it’s still very unreasonable to pay an extra 280 dollars over what amounts to a booking error at best Especially on a weekend when we were one of only two rooms occupiedI called the owner and respectfully tried to make my case, but was just brushed off He really seemed like a sweet older gentleman in person, but over the phone he was fairly mean and rude I tried to be calm, collected, and respectful I’m still hoping my view is seen, and I’d be happy to change my review but as it stands now I feel taken advantage of


Beautiful and peaceful setting We checked in after a hike in Hocking Hills and it was so nice at the B&B, we canceled our Next hike to further enjoy the beautiful surroundings of the Manner overlooking Lake Logan We saw deer, an eagle, and other water fowl

We then ordered Pizza-crossing at suggestion of the owner and had a fire pit and a great evening The next morning they served us a wonderful breakfast and we heard interesting stories from the owner We would come again

3. Burtonwood Lodging Co.

About this hotel

148 W Fair Ave, Lancaster, OH 43130(740) 654-0032

Things You Need to Know

  • Walking distance to Rising Park and Georgian Museum
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a hot tub

Feedback From Real Customers

Gojira Chan

Our family stayed at Hidden Valley for Christmas 2021 and we had a wonderful and peaceful time! The property was perfect for us! The kids loved the bunkhouse and the parents loved the peace The game room was really popular also The house is comfortable and felt like home away from home

The only thing about one of the rooms is the lamp doesn’t provide much light That’s not a complaint- it’s just a small observationThe pond and the back are beautiful- even in the winter! We really appreciated the hot tub after hiking We even got to make s’mores in the fire pit!The house is located in a great place and it’s easy to get to the hiking areas and Logan We had fun and time went too fastF Murray

Kim Coomer

There were so many cabins to choose from in Hocking Hills and I believe we chose the perfect one It was very secluded It was new, nicely furnished and clean

I actually took a picture of the couch so I could try to find something similar It was so comfortable This cabin has a pool table in the lower level My husband and I love to play pool so we really enjoyed that

Andrea Murphy

Absolutely loved the experience and stay at Summit Point The early communication and digital handbook set a realistic expectation

the only issue was that seeing and experiencing it in person made us want to stay longer Cozy fireplace, relaxing hot tub, Bluetooth speakers throughoutUnfortunately I left some items behind, Ashley went the extra mile for me and is mailing them to meThank you for helping us celebrate our 26th anniversary with a memorable stay!

4. Sleep Inn Logan Ohio-Hocking Hills (2-star hotel)

About this hotel

Set along US-33, this laid-back hotel is a mile from Lake Logan State Park, 3 miles from Downtown and 9 miles from Cantwell Cliffs.Relaxed rooms with colorful accent walls feature free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs and sitting areas, as well as minifridges, microwaves and coffeemakers.Breakfast and parking are complimentary. Other amenities include a heated indoor pool and a 24-hour fitness center.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the beds
  • Guests liked the rooms, which have coffee makers
  • Walking distance to Paul A. Johnson Pencil Sharpener Museum and Hocking Hills Regional Welcome Center
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a 24-hr front desk
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a fitness center
  • The fitness center has weight machines and elliptical machines
  • One of the few hotels in the area with an outdoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Steve Trethewey

I had my room reserved for almost 3 months I walked in and was impressed by the place, clean and neat Got registered and went to my room

I was pleasantly surprised by how nice it was and couldn’t wait to unpack as I was staying 3 days The room was hot and stuffy so it went to adjust the AC but it threw up an error code and would not reset I went back down (my room was on the 3rd floor) to the front desk They said they would send a maintenance guy to repair the unit Within minutes a nice young man showed up, he unplugged the unit several times and tried to reset it Nothing worked He said I’ll see about getting you another room Back down to the front desk, they said he didn’t reset it right so back he went I stayed in the lobby with my luggage After awhile he came back and said no he couldn’t get it going but another maintenance guy would be there to look at it tomorrow Tomorrow? I said, it’s 80 degrees in there We can give you a fanI said no thanks and went to the front desk again I gave back my key cards and asked for a new room The young lady said they were booked full and there were none available While I was waiting I had checked the website and it was still selling rooms I pointed this out and the lady got a little irritated and said I don’t know anything about that we are booked So you can’t help me? No I’m sorry Not acceptable I said, she then called her boss, came back and said we’ve issued you a refund, you should see it in your account in 3 to 5 business days That’s all we can do We’ll I had paid in advance and didn’t plan for the expense of getting another hotel room I eventually got my refund but won’t do business with this place again Wouldn’t help find an alternative or anything Just left me stranded without a room Thanks Sleep Inn I won’t be back

SueAnn Odam

I wish I could email the manager to personally tell them about their staff, but unfortunately, I couldn’t find an email address, so figured at least I can publicly let everyone know that this place BY FAR exceeded our expectations (Which are fairly high since we travel a lot for sports tournaments and leisure) The staff is soooo incredibly friendly and welcoming, they are locals so they were helpful in giving us ideas outside of our original itinerary planned! Free breakfast (always nice)

The rooms might not be as fancy as a Marriott, but they are well kept, clean, and fairly modern We will definitely be back when we can as they are pet friendly and the staff goes above and beyond for their guests If I could have given more than 5 stars, I would have!

Leah Leister

We had booked a room a few weeks prior to our visit, they made an overbooking error and not only did they reach out, fix it, and upgrade us but the ENTIRE staff was very pleasant! To the young lady cleaning the rooms, two ladies at the front desk at night and the woman in the morning We literally woke up and said “we hope to see those girls again, they were so kind”

literally! The places recommended by them were also amazing The complimentary breakfast was above standards as well! We will definitely be coming back here and recommending it to others! We LOVED our experience! Thank you guys for going above and beyond and having A1 customer service It does NOT go unnoticed!

5. Holiday Inn Express Hocking Hills-Logan (2-star hotel)

About this hotel

This standard hotel off Highway 33 is a 3-minute drive from Lake Logan State Park and a 2.7-mile drive from downtown Logan.The straightforward rooms come with flat-screen TVs and desks, plus premium cable channels, coffeemakers and free local phone calls. Kids 19 and under stay free with an adult and there’s free WiFi in every room, as well as a choice of hard and soft pillows. Suites add separate living spaces with whirlpool tubs and kitchenettes.Amenities include a free breakfast bar, an indoor pool and a fitness center, as well as free parking.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the beds
  • Walking distance to Paul A. Johnson Pencil Sharpener Museum and Hocking Hills Regional Welcome Center
  • Some guests complained about the bathrooms
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a 24-hr front desk
  • Guests mentioned hot tubs 19 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a fitness center
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Jasmine O’Conner

I really enjoyed my stay at this hotel; I was visiting for a wedding To be located in a small town, the hotel was in a good location, near restaurants, stores, gas station, and park activities This hotel is near Hocking Hills State Park

The hotel has three floors, pool, and dining area with free breakfast The staff was very friendly, attentive and helpfulThe only reason I didn’t give the hotel 5 Stars was because it could use a face lift, that I think would help with the smell in the hotels The smell wasn’t bad, but it was noticeableIn the end, I would recommend and would stay at this hotel again The cost was very affordable, in my opinion, for two nights

Emily Klosterman

My family of 3 checked in on a Sunday evening and checked out on the following Saturday morning for a 6-night stay Our 3rd-floor standard room with 2 queen-size beds was clean, comfortable, and spacious, and the buffet breakfast was tasty with a variety of options Our beds were comfortable with plenty of pillows (4 on each bed), and the air conditioner with adjustable controls kept our room nice and cool after a long day of hiking

The mini-fridge in our room was actually quite spacious and had a small freezer section (a welcome addition), and the fridge section kept food and drinks at the perfect temperature The ice machine was handy and a great asset when packing a cooler, and the room’s mini microwave and coffee machine (with K-cups provided) came in very useful The water pressure in the shower was excellent, and the full-size Dove shampoo, conditioner, and body soap in the shower was an added bonus I was even able to use the self-service washer and dryer to do a load of laundry midway through our vacation using an app to pay and monitor when my laundry would be done Although we didn’t find time to use it, the hotel has an indoor pool area, too The hotel manager, assistant manager, front desk staff, and breakfast staff were all very helpful and friendly, especially Glena Smith, General Manager, with whom we interacted quite a bit since we played cards and watched television in the lobby entertainment area 3 of the nights we were there Whenever we asked for anything (such as an extra towel or washcloth, a garbage bag, etc), she was happy to provide it I highly suggest staying here if you’re in the area It was more affordable than a cottage would have been and was spacious enough for a small family

andrew malhotra

Nice and clean hotel Had an issue with mine and my coworkers rewards numbers They were not sure how to fix it, but they spent several hours or days calling around to get help so they could fix it, and they did!!Also pretty nice pool, but FYI the gym has no weights and there is no hot tub

However, there is a lovely outdoor porch off of the pool

6. Hampton Inn Lancaster (3-star hotel)

  • Address: 2041 Schorrway Dr NW, Lancaster, OH 43130
  • Phone: (740) 654-2999
  • Ratings: 4.1 (510 reviews) Very good Eco-certified
  • Website : Hampton Inn Lancaster
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 12:00 PM
  • Quick Summary: Straightforward, modern hotel with an indoor pool & a gym, plus free hot breakfast & WiFi.

About this hotel

This modern hotel is 2.3 miles from downtown Lancaster and 10.1 miles from the Wahkeena Nature Preserve.The relaxed rooms have free WiFi and flat-screen TVs with HD channels, plus coffeemakers, minifridges and microwaves. Some also have pull-out sofas.A free daily hot breakfast is offered, along with an indoor pool, whirlpool tub and fitness center. Other amenities include a business center, laundry facilities and free parking.

Things You Need to Know

  • 3 min drive to AHA! A Hands-On Adventure A Children’s Museum
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Some guests disliked the bathrooms
  • Guests mentioned hot tubs 12 times

Feedback From Real Customers

Lesa Bailey

The whole staff has been so caring and gracious The GM has been the best GM Ive ever dealt with and she has put the best team together here Mary is the breakfast host and is so caring and friendly

The Front desk ladies are fantastic and very helpful Like I said a great team here and made our stay so comfortable and made it feel like home! Thank you to the whole staff We appreciate you!

Anne Hopkins

I had called the day I was arriving to make this reservation I chose this hotel based on price, and the fact that she had a pool When I called this specific hotel not the 800 number to make the reservation they did not mention the pool was closed

I would have stayed at one of the many hotels nearby had I known there was no pool available I had been driving a long time and I’ve always enjoy swimming when I stay in hotels This detail should have been mentioned as it was listed as an amenity

Ted Vartorella

Despite appearing to be an older Hampton the facility and rooms were clean Strong smell of cigarettes as we entered the lobby area but not in the room Despite being clean there was peeling paint in the bathroom, a nonfunctional thermostat shell on the wall and loose wall paper noticed in room and breakfast area

The staff was very friendly and polite The breakfast was above average for a Hampton The facility needs a total interior face-lift

7. Hampton Inn & Suites Canal Winchester Columbus (2-star hotel)

About this hotel

Off Highway 33, this relaxed hotel is set in an area with multiple eateries and shopping plazas. It’s 15 miles from Lou Berliner Sports Park and 17 miles from John Glenn Columbus International Airport.Laid-back rooms with colorful accents provide Wi-Fi and HDTVs, as well as minifridges, microwaves and coffeemakers. Suites add wet bars and sofabeds.Amenities consist of an indoor pool, a fitness room and a terrace. Breakfast, parking and electric charging stations are available.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the clean rooms, which have TVs
  • Guests praised the beds
  • 7 min drive to Pickerington Ponds Metro Park
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • The fitness center has weight machines and elliptical machines
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a casino
  • The hotel has a boutique store

Feedback From Real Customers

Kyleen Hopp

This hotel saved the day after canceled fromA hotel nearby due to no staffing We arrived at 10:15pm and were greeted by the night staff She was AMAZING

She was kind, helpful, and genuinely cared about or quality of stay something we haven’t seen in upwards of 3 years with this pandemicThe hotel is new so most everything was in tip topShape The king beds were so comfortable, and pull out was just as good (according to my kids!) I truly hope that your employees are paid as highly as I recommend this hotel that woman who took care of us upon our late arrival was great She made us feel right at home We hope that when we return for a future event this hotel is available AND that it is in just as amazing condition!


From the moment I walked in this hotel I knew I’d be pleased with my stay here The front desk agent, Henry, was very nice and accommodating

Excellent customer service from him overall The room was comfortable Big flat screen TV, mini fridge, microwave and plenty of room for my daughter and I to stretch out and not be on top of each other The bed was amazing Even the pillows were amazing I enjoyed my stay here and I’d definitely return

8. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Lancaster, an IHG Hotel (2-star hotel)

About this hotel

Less than 5 miles from Highway 33 and a 13-minute drive from Lancaster’s historic downtown, this modern lodging is also 5.1 miles from the University of Ohio.Straightforward rooms come with flat-screen TVs and desks, plus minifridges, microwaves and premium cable channels. Kids 19 and under stay free with an adult and there’s free WiFi in every room, as well as a choice of hard and soft pillows. Suites add separate living spaces with pull-out sofas, kitchenettes and dining tables.The facility also offers a free breakfast bar, indoor pool and fitness center, as well as a business center, guest laundry and parking.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the rooms, which have microwaves
  • The rooms have coffee makers and TVs
  • 8 min walk to AHA! A Hands-On Adventure A Children’s Museum
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests liked “a pillow”, mentioned 10 times in reviews
  • The fitness center has treadmills and elliptical machines
  • Guests praised the indoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Sandy Becker

We have stayed at this hotel MANY times over the past 15 years Our family lives in Lancaster and we travel there to see them 2-3 times per year We ALWAYS stay at this hotel because the staff are excellent and the rooms are very nice

We love the convenience, the indoor pool but especially the fact that we can bring our pets The accomodations are very clean and nice and the breakfast is wonderful! We highly recommend this hotel SB

Rich Brady

My brother, Craig, and I were supposed to have a handicap accessible room with a roll-in shower for me We we there for our dad’s calling hours and funeral We didn’t get that

We had a bathtub that I had to slide into Well, I ended up with bruised butt bones, and broken tailbone ’cause I thuded down when I slid in, ’cause the grab bars wouldn’t let me lower myself down safely And, the shower hose wouldn’t reach me very well, as I had to sit in the bottom of the bathtub to shower The bed, well it was too high and hard to get into it We needed a wheelchair accessible room, but didn’t get it But the breakfast was awesome!

Dannielle Martin

If I could give zero I would Extremely irritated So June 15 I booked a 2 bed queen size standard room for 1 night cost over 200$

Got email confirming reservation and beds June 20 get email stating I have a 1 king bed room Immediately called and got run around called manager and basically told same thing that they don’t know what happened Won’t reduce cost of room and basically got told sorry bout you luck

9. MainStay Suites Logan Ohio-Hocking Hills (2-star hotel)

About this hotel

Among casual eateries, this relaxed all-suite hotel is a mile from both US-33 and Lake Logan State Park. It’s an 11-minute walk from the quirky Paul A. Johnson Pencil Sharpener Museum.Straightforward studios provide flat-screen TVs and free Wi-Fi, in addition to kitchenettes. Suites add separate living rooms with dining areas.Complimentary perks include all-day coffee, a hot breakfast buffet, and parking for cars and trucks. There’s also a fitness room, a heated indoor pool and a convenience store. Guest laundry facilities are available.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the rooms, which have coffee makers
  • The rooms have refrigerators and microwaves
  • Walking distance to Paul A. Johnson Pencil Sharpener Museum and Hocking Hills Regional Welcome Center
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a 24-hr front desk
  • Guests praised the friendly service, which has a concierge
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a fitness center
  • One of the few hotels in the area with an outdoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Kathy Mata

Great hotel, can be seen from 33 and easy to find Room was large and clean Everyone was very friendly and the young lady who checked us out on July 29th even gave my husband a print out of directions to our next destination, Walnut Creek, Ohio

We took a back roads route that was very scenic and we loved it Special thanks to her for giving us those directions It was very kind of her to take the time to find and print the directions for us Would definitely consider staying at Mainstay if ever in that area again

Kimmy K

Very nice, newer hotel which is immaculately clean However, breakfast was just ok They had a lot of choices, but the food was not good quality

Potatoes were salty, egg omelets were barely warm, the hard bolied eggs were old and rubbery, sausage was rubbery The room only had a chair and so both my husband and I could not sit down comfortably The room is large enough to have a sofa, so I don’t know why it doesn’t The bed wasn’t very comfortable The room was noisy, (we faced the freeway) Not enough lighting in the room at night There was no bath mat, so the floor in the bathroom got wet However, it was still a nice stay I wish that they would fix these things and it would be 5-star Staff, Cheyanne, was bubbly and helpful

Juliette B

Spent 4 nights with my son for a mom/son hiking getawaythe hotel was clean, accomodating and in a great location

TBHWe are used to staying in fabulous VRBO’s or AIRBNB’sbut because of the pandemic repercussions we could only get a hotelwe reserved the suite equipped with a full refrigerator, microwaveetcKitchenetteOur accomodations were fantastic and the most important part of this review isI spent a most amazing 5 days and 4 nights with my 18 yr old son, laughing and hiking and making everlasting memories after all???I could be living in a van down by the riverit wouldn’t matter!!But I don’t live in a van down by the riversoOur stay was faband the MAGICAL beauty of the Hocking Hills was(simply stated)A most wonderful experience

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *