cheap hotels in Deer Park, NY

1. Residence Inn by Marriott Plainview Long Island (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

This casual extended-stay hotel is 5 miles from Adventureland and 8 miles from the Walt Whitman Birthplace State Historic Site.The homey rooms, ranging from studios to 2-bedroom suites, come with fully equipped kitchens and separate living areas with sofabeds, as well as free Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs. Suites add additional TVs; some have balconies.Hot breakfast, a weekday evening social with snacks, parking, and a grocery delivery service are complimentary. There’s also a bar serving light bites, an Italian restaurant and a 24/7 convenience store. Other amenities include 2 pools, a fitness center, and coin-operated laundry.

Things You Need to Know

  • 7 min drive to Bethpage State Park
  • Guests liked the service
  • Guests praised the breakfast
  • Guests liked the bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Karen Sue

Went for dinner and drinks with work friends We were a group of 8 people Had called in advance for seating and the table was set and ready for us at the appointed time

They sat us right by the fish tank which is very pretty The waitress, Kathy, was excellent and courteous We all had the price fix meal which was great Appetizer, dinner and dessert It was spaced out perfectly, not rushed but not so long between courses for us to wonder where our food was This allowed us to enjoy our dinner and have nice conversation It was a great evening Everybody enjoyed the food, the surroundings and the service

Andrew W

I love this Residence Inn by Marriott! It is one of the nicest I’ve ever stayed and everyone was super niceWe had an event for our stay and the staff made it so memorable It was the perfect venue and our guests were blown away at how nice the hotel is

The hotel is tucked off Old Country Rd which makes it so quiet and comfortable The rooms are very spacious and luxurious I really like having a kitchen in the room for leftovers or to keep drinks cold The breakfast every morning is tasty and it’s awesome that it’s offeredI recommend if your staying or planning to stay on Long Island to stay here!

Alexandre Dumontet

Nice hotel if you are in the area for an extended stay The rooms have all the amenities necessary for a comfortable stay Enough TV channels to keep you entertained, free wired and wireless wifi that is fast enough for most of your needs

Free breakfast every morning with a good selection of things to eat and an awesome full free dinner from Monday to Thursday including beer and wineIt looks like a hotel from the 60’s/70’s by the decor, but it is really well maintained and charmingTwo pools and a really nice patio in the rear of hotel to make the most of your time here

2. Blue Waters Hotel

About this hotel

Half a mile from the beach, this casual adults-only hotel is 4 miles from Fire Island Lighthouse, 7 miles from Captree State Park and 23 miles from CM Performing Arts Center.The relaxed rooms feature free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs with cable channels, and DVD players. Some feature sitting areas with sofas and sliding glass doors leading to a sun deck.Free perks include parking and breakfast. Additional amenities include a restaurant open for lunch and dinner, a bar and a rooftop garden, plus a sun deck and a bike rack. Guests aged 25 and older and welcome.

Things You Need to Know

  • 16 min drive to Sunken Forest
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests mentioned beaches 10 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast

Feedback From Real Customers

Pablo M

This place is taking advantage of people wanting to visit fire island I was misled and lied to by Elaine and other staff members at the hotel while booking a weekend at there Beach House from having extra beds available to not having adequate dishware and silverware to support not even 4-6 people They weren’t accommodating at all they wouldn’t except anything but cash for the $3500 bill

We were a couple hundred dollars short they wouldn’t even let us put it on the credit card The only thing they allowed to put on the credit card was the thousand dollar security deposit for a service dog that we had with usTo top it all off after all the problems we had they ended up keeping $150 because there was some dog hair on one of the flat sheets This place is a joke stay elsewhere save yourself the aggravation!!!!

Michelle Bruno

My friends and I absolutely loved our stay here! We came for MDW and it was the best location, right next to the ferry and next to all the best bars/stores/ and restaurants The hotel staff were the nicest ever and so helpful There was also free breakfast in the mornings and it was great! The rooftop deck is adorable to sit out on to relax/eat

I cannot wait to stay here again, loved everyone at Blue Waters!

Andrea Balsamo

We had a great weekend at the Blue Waters Hotel The room was clean and the staff were very accommodating – went above and beyond to make sure we were enjoying our stay The outdoor deck was a beautiful spot to have a glass of wine, and read a book

Breakfast (served on the deck) was fabulous So many choices and everything was delicious We were provided with beach towels and chairs which made packing for the weekend much easier The location was perfect – a very short walk from the ferry and on the main path of restaurants and shopping I highly recommend the Blue Waters Hotel if you are planning a trip to Ocean Beach!

3. Hilton Long Island/Huntington (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

This contemporary hotel is 3.4 miles to Bethpage State Park Golf Course and 11.9 miles to the Vanderbilt Museum with its mansion and planetarium.All rooms offer sophisticated decor and custom-designed beds, plus flat-screen TVs and WiFi (fee). Executive rooms provide free WiFi and access to the Executive Lounge’s free breakfast and evening appetizers. Suites add separate living areas.Amenities include 2 relaxed restaurants, a fitness center, tennis courts, and both an indoor and seasonal outdoor pool. There’s also a business center and over 26,000 sq ft of flexible meeting space, plus a complimentary local shuttle service.

Things You Need to Know

  • 4 min drive to Adventureland
  • Some guests complained about the unclean rooms but others thought they were large
  • Some guests complained about the bathrooms
  • One of the few hotels in the area with room service
  • Guests mentioned “Ballroom” 18 times
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a hot tub
  • The hotel has a sauna

Feedback From Real Customers

Jason vernick

I can’t even believe how amazing this hotel is Pulled up in front and the guy is there with the luggage cart waiting Another person immediately takes an ice cream cake I’m holding and puts it in a freezer

Another person is waiting at the desk to check me in Get to the room the man that brought everything up to the room unloads everything and doesn’t leave until he makes sure everything is as expected I rented a regular room for one night my daughter and 3 friends and an joining one for me I asked if they could have a table set aside for my daughters birthday dinner They called me the day before I arrived to not only tell me they would have a special table but that they would make special menus with her name on it Went over all safe food because we had one child with allergies I can’t even tell you how many little things each person working here did to make our stay special because there were so many! For dinner They had a room to themselves with their own waitress, they decorated the table with different color napkins in each glass and a birthday sign This was all done as standard service, all I paid for was the rooms!The pool is amazing! The desk found out two of my daughters friend had to leave for a short time and they offered to keep the pool open later so they didn’t miss out on any pool timeI’ve never stayed at such an amazing hotel!

Venetia Farrell

Update- I was refunded $50

honestly at that rate don’t bother refunding money, id just take the loss My family got about as much sleep as we’d have gotten if we slept in a tent in the parking lot and it would have been a heck of a lot less expensive I’ll be staying at the Marriott down the road next time we’re in town Do not recommendPositives- sufficiently safe and no bedbugs Also the staff at breakfast was lovely and helpfulNegatives- sticky floor, dirty walls, hair all over the bathroom, no fresh towels, no working vending machines, but the best part was the fire alarm in our bedroom going off at 2am when we were sleeping After calling the front desk, who very nonchalantly told us to call back if it went over again (it did), we had to wait for someone to come upstairs to look at it Apparently there was a miscommunication between them and the front desk because the gentleman who came into our room spent a few moments trying to wrench the thermostat off the wall, leaving piles of wall on the floor before we pointed out the problem was with the fire alarm He removed it and told us they’d replace it the next morning They did not We had to call multiple times to have them send someone up with what I’d consider a basic safety requirementOther notes: everything is outdated, the walls are thin and you can hear everything

Matt Fisher

This is a fabulous hotel with very clean rooms and the most magnificent pool and hot tub! The staff was friendly and took care of all our needs right away and the food at the breakfast buffet was exceptional I highly recommend the omelet station and fresh baked croissants even the kids were raving about all the choices!!! Very spacious rooms and a gorgeous lobby bar with lounge seating all around was the icing on the cake!

4. Viana Hotel and Spa, Trademark Collection by Wyndham (4-star hotel)

About this hotel

Built with recycled materials, this upscale hotel powered by solar energy is a 7-minute walk from the NYCB Theatre and 4 miles from the 200-acre Old Westbury Gardens.The Feng Shui-inspired rooms have marble bathrooms (some with whirlpool tubs), plus minifridges, flat-screen TVs and free WiFi. Suites feature balconies, separate living rooms and/or kitchenettes.Outdoor parking is free. Amenities include a spa, an indoor pool and a hot tub, as well as a steam room, a sauna, a gym and a game room. An modern restaurant serves Italian, Asian and fusion dishes and has a bar.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests liked the large, clean rooms
  • 9 min drive to Old Westbury Gardens
  • Guests praised the friendly, professional service
  • Guests mentioned “Champagne” 20 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a hot tub
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a spa

Feedback From Real Customers

Deb Schultz

For our daughter’s wedding, our guests stayed at the Viana We held our daughter’s wedding-after-party at the Viana and had a fabulously, fresh breakfast the following morning We worked with Erin to help plan the many details that were needed

She was extremely responsive to our emails and able to add her experience to the many questions we had to make the evening run smoothly The staff was very friendly and helpful The bartenders were great-friendly and accommodating All of our guests were very happy!

Bri Barbieri

I just had my room block here for my wedding last weekend and everything was perfect from beginning to end Erin was so sweet and made the process so easy I had to add on additional rooms after my first block was filled and there was no problem at all

The night of the wedding, the shuttle transported people back and forth in a timely and safe manner We even had a little after party at the bar and everyone was so kind and friendly All our guests said the rooms were nice and clean and we enjoyed our honeymoon suite–they decorated with rose petals and had a bottle of champagne on ice with us and chocolate covered strawberries! I wouldn’t have changed a single thing 🙂 thank you Erin and team!

S Michael

The front desk staff was amazing and hospitality was on point The beds were comfortable and the room was clean We needed more blankets and they accommodated our request without hesitation

Hotel in need of minor aesthetic improvements however only noticeable if you are a designer The location is great close to the mall and eateries Overall good experience and will return

5. Hyatt Regency Long Island (4-star hotel)

  • Address: 1717 Motor Pkwy, Hauppauge, NY 11788
  • Phone: (631) 784-1234
  • Ratings: 4.1 (1468 reviews) Very good
  • Website : Hyatt Regency Long Island
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: High-end hotel offering 2 pools, 2 tennis courts & a golf course, plus dining & a conference center.

About this hotel

Within the same grounds as the Wind Watch Golf & Country Club, this upscale hotel is 4 miles from Lake Ronkonkoma and 6 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport.Modern rooms come with Wi-Fi (fee) and 46-inch flat-screen TVs, plus minifridges, coffeemakers and desks. Suites add separate living areas. Room service is available.There’s a gym and a high-end restaurant/bar, as well as indoor and outdoor pools, a hot tub and saunas. Additional amenities include an 18-hole golf course, 2 tennis courts and a conference center.

Things You Need to Know

  • 8 min drive to Blydenburgh County Park
  • Some guests disliked the bathrooms
  • One of the few hotels in the area with room service
  • Guests mentioned lobbies 41 times
  • Guests praised the fitness center
  • One of the few hotels in the area with an outdoor pool
  • Guests praised the bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Bob

Great accommodations Hotel in very good condition Our room was spotless and refreshed on each day of our 6 night stay

Very comfortable beds (some might say a little firm, but I slept like a baby) No issues with anything (TV, lighting, A/C, etc) during our stay Hotel was very busy on the holiday weekend but had no impact whatsoever on our experience Staff was on top of their game Excellent price compared to some 2 star hotels in the area No free breakfast, but it was nice to see complimentary Starbucks coffee available in the lobby and if your on Long Island you’re not far from a fresh bagel Plenty of dining choices within a couple of miles Will certainly stay here again

Mary

Hyatt Regency Long Island made our one-night stay so incredibly special We brought out kid for a special celebration for graduating kindergarten I called ahead and asked the housekeeping manager to make the room special and he said he would make the room have towels folded into the shape of animals and he also made a special trip to get small balloons saying ‘happy graduation’ and a graduation card

The pools were great – indoor and outdoor The breakfast restaurant was very tasty and the service was very nice The dining room / bar restaurant upstairs was just fine for a quick bite – if you want something more private or intimate, look elsewhere for a romantic dinner because it was very much a hotel lobby restaurant as opposed to a restaurant that happened to be in the lobby of a hotel The room service we ordered arrived incredibly quickly though they were unable to make an espresso martini (we managed to survive) All around a very lovely stay

Dotti Gallois

I have had the pleasure of staying at this hotel for the week because of work I cannot say enough about the great experience Every staff member I have encountered have been the best and friendliest people

And let’s talk about the food at Nu Bar & Lounge I had two meals therethe Long Island Cobb salad with chicken and the Turkey Club sandwich with grilled vegetables every bite was amazing!

6. Courtyard by Marriott Long Island MacArthur Airport (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

This straightforward hotel is 2.1 miles from Ronkonkoma Beach.Contemporary-styled rooms offer free WiFi, desks, flat-screen TVs, minifridges, microwaves and coffeemakers. Suites add separate living areas and whirlpool tubs.Social spaces include a living room-style lobby and an outdoor courtyard with a fire pit. The American restaurant serves breakfast and dinner as well as all-day drinks, including Starbucks coffee. There’s also a business center with workstations and printers, and 6 meeting rooms. Other amenities include an indoor pool, a whirlpool and an exercise room, as well as a free airport shuttle and on-site parking.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the clean rooms
  • Some guests disliked the bathrooms
  • 11 min drive to Lakeland County Park
  • 12 min walk to nearest train station
  • Guests liked the friendly service
  • Guests mentioned hot tubs 12 times
  • Guests mentioned fitness centers 10 times

Feedback From Real Customers

Laurie Simmons

Very nice hotel Pool and hot tub indoors, room kept very hot Coin laundry very cheap

Nothing really near hotel except Red Lobster and Smokey Bones No breakfast Large pantry, items expensive Room fridge very tiny so really unable to stock and eat for cheap Stayed on business Not sure I’d pay that price for no breakfast and tiny fridge on a vacation

nasha nicole

The room was very spacious, I took a room with double beds for my kids and myself It was clean, I really love the individually wrapped cups and overall cleanliness even though I take wipes to do a once over as well Tiny fridge but enough room to store leftovers

Quiet and peaceful area It was a really hot day so we used their indoor pool, it was fantastic There is also a hot tub available as well The staff was friendly and my stay was wonderful There are two restaurants in walking distance The Ronkonkoma train station is close by and it’s an easy jump to the LIE On site parking for a fee Small pantry area with plenty of stock

Ruby Bolduc

This place was clean and quiet, the beds were comfortable and the towels were normal size (lol) The rooms were not brand new but the beds were very comfortable and the TV was a 55 in (I have stayed at a few lately with itty bitty TVs and terrible cable service) Everyone who works there that I spoke with was extremely professional and friendly

I would say the only part that was weird was the way they had breakfast for sale items set up in the pantry To that same note, the pantry area was stocked extremely well compared to many other Marriott courtyards that I have stayed at recently I will definitely stay here again

7. Holiday Inn Plainview-Long Island, an IHG Hotel (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

Set in a commercial area off the Long Island Expressway, this relaxed hotel is 7 miles from Bethpage State Park and 31 miles from New York City.Contemporary rooms offer free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs, coffeemakers and minifridges. Suites add whirlpool tubs and separate living areas. Kids stay at no extra cost with an adult. Room service is offered.Parking and coffee in the lobby are included. There’s a warm restaurant/lounge serving American cuisine (free for kids 11 and under). Amenities consist of a seasonal outdoor pool, as well as both a 24-hour fitness room and a business center. There’s a coin-operated laundry. Breakfast is available.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests liked the clean rooms, which have TVs
  • 7 min drive to the Old Bethpage Village Restoration
  • Some guests complained about the air conditioning but others praised the beds
  • Some guests disliked the bathrooms
  • One of the few hotels in the area with room service
  • The fitness center has elliptical machines and treadmills
  • One of the few hotels in the area with an outdoor pool
  • Guests liked the bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Debb Frost

My husband and I had to change hotels multiple times for our wedding Covid postponed it 4 times and it seemed like every date we got the hotel wasn’t able to accommodate our large group Holiday Inn took care of us and made sure that our guest and us were taken care of

They gave us space to be able to do hair and makeup and gave us the option to keep the bar open late! We had a BLAST and they were pleasant every step of the way! We had our wedding 8/14/21

Steven

Last time I stayed here the fire alarm went off every hour for 4 hours between 1am and 5am I ended up checking out earlyThe room is disgustingly dirty and nothing feels clean

The room originally given to me was preoccupied The second room the carpet felt dirty and had crumbs all over the placeThe bed was saggy and not comfortable at all It was by far the worst stay at a hotel I ever hadThe location to the highway is probably the best part of this hotel

Gene Melton

The rooms were nice and clean and appeared to be recently remodeled The staff at the desk were friendly and accommodating When I checked in I was told the hotel had not started serving breakfast yes because of the pandemic but the did serve lunch and dinner

The website said continental hot breakfast served Guess the owners are too cheap to serve breakfast and use the pandemic as an excuse The cons was the halls smelled like marijuana at any time of day I figure the staff were in their work areas smoking marijuana No matter what time I returned, always some shady characters sitting in the parking lot or outside the buildings I would watch them approach cars for about a minute and car would drive off Selling drugs? not sure but that seemed to be what was going on Never felt safe walking from the car to the front doors No one ever threatened me but I was watched real hard walking in I travel to the area on business Definitely will not stay their again and I would not recommend others to stay there especially if you are a lone woman or a family with kids

8. Comfort Inn Syosset-Long Island (3-star hotel)

  • Address: 24 Oak Dr, Syosset, NY 11791
  • Phone: (516) 921-1111
  • Ratings: 4.2 (505 reviews) Very good
  • Website : Comfort Inn Syosset-Long Island
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 12:00 PM
  • Quick Summary: Modern rooms & suites in a laid-back hotel offering free hot breakfast & a colorful lobby bar.

About this hotel

This relaxed hotel off Highway 25 is 7 miles from Sagamore Hill, former home of Theodore Roosevelt, and 12 miles from Eisenhower Park.The unfussy, modern rooms feature free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs and coffeemakers. Upgraded rooms add microwaves and minifridges, and suites also have living rooms with sofabeds.Complimentary amenities include hot breakfast served in a cozy dining room, and parking for cars, trucks and buses. There’s a colorful lobby bar and a fitness room, as well as a business center and coin-operated laundry facilities.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the bathrooms
  • 10 min drive to Bethpage State Park
  • Guests mentioned the rooms are clean but small
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests mentioned lobbies 19 times
  • Guests mentioned microwaves 10 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast

Feedback From Real Customers

Michael Michaelides

So let me say the 1 star rating is because of the service or lack there ofThe hotel is nice Clean

Room was a little small but comfortable Good areaI travel quite a bit I’m a good or platinum member for choice hotels, Hilton, Marriott etc… My connecting flight got cancelled and I had to drive in as opposed to fly I called to change the check in and yes I was past the 24 hour window, however I called at 7AM plenty of time to book out the roomThey refused to cancel or change the check in and charged me the room That’s fineThat’s their prerogative It’s just disappointing when I know they could have helped me out, and didn’t Other comfort inns and choice hotels honor those requests So do Hilton and MarriottThis was the first time in the last 3 years a hotel refused

JP Kelliher

Clean, affordable, and an amazing staff!We had to leave another high end hotel nearby because of mold in the room After a terrible night sleep and being desperate for a clean place to stay, the management at this Comfort Inn took us in early, and made sure we had a comfortable place to stayThe room was half the price of the high end hotel down the road, twice as clean, and way more comfortable

Thank you Jonathan and Dave for saving our weekend

Jerome Mabb

The manager was very helpful in every way during our 3 day stayThe breakfast was very good and the area was very cleanThe room was impeccably clean and the service was awesome

The covered parking area was handy being that we had freezing rain during our stayRestaurants and diners were pointed out by the manager and his picks were on pointHighly recommended!

9. The Palms Hotel Fire Island (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

Set along Great South Bay, this chic hotel is 3 miles from the Fire Island ferry terminal.The brightly decorated rooms feature Egyptian cotton linens and stylish furnishings, as well as free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs, iPod docks and minifridges. Suites sleep up to 8 people. In-room breakfast is available for a surcharge.Complimentary continental breakfast is served in a restaurant on weekends (seasonally). There’s access to a private beach with barbecue grills, and a courtyard with sunloungers and sitting areas, plus loaner bikes and beach gear. Kayak rentals are on offer.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the rooms
  • 19 min drive to Sunken Forest
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests praised the restaurant
  • Guests mentioned “Umbrella” 10 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast
  • Guests praised the beach

Feedback From Real Customers

jackie marinace

Such a great spot! The rooms were immaculate and the staff was so great They were very pleasant to work with and flexible as well, we booked an additional room last minute for a friend to stay as well and they got his room ready very quickly They had bikes, beach towels, they let us store our luggage before check in and after check out which was so nice to be able to enjoy the rest of the day after check out and not have to drag our bags around

They even let us sign out bikes to use even though we were technically checked out as guests already, they still were super accommodating and very generous with the time they allowed us! Will definitely be back!

Yan Wu

Great for a short stay in Fire Island It’s a hotel, so all the amenities you would expect, plus a small breakfast spread, champagne hour(s), water bottle, use of beach supplies, towels, bikes, etc It’s actually a collection of several properties (we stayed at Bayside, I believe, it was maybe a 4 minute walk from the main building)

At our room location, there was the shore side private sand beach and lounge, and bar service – which I didn’t get a chance to use The main building has the lounge and dining area The staff was super friendly and very helpful Other than a little issue with the door (which the front desk addressed), it was exactly what we neededA con to note as others have mentioned is that the room size is on the smaller side We were 2 adults and 2 kids in 2 double beds and it was just enough room for usWe stayed a Monday and Tuesday night, so can’t speak on the noise level (Monday had a few night revelers, but nobody else in my party noticed and Tuesday was very calm) The shared wall with our neighbor had the adjoining door, so it wasn’t very insulated, but they were very courteous (we tried to be as well) about noise levels before and after certain hours (we were both traveling with children)The area is right in the commercial district, so no shortage of restaurants, bars, stores, dessert shops also a playground and the ferry are less than 5 minutes away

James Williams

Nice friendly staff but I wouldn’t recommend to be honest due to the size of the rooms!! My best mate booked the rooms with another friend of mine and his wife We had the impression that we were going to have some sort of shared suit you sometimes get where you have a communal area but separate rooms (en-suite bathrooms) We got two rooms with adjoining door which I can only describe as door which didn’t shut properly or lock! Room size I would guess as I’m 6ft1 as around 8ft by 10ft at best (you couldn’t swing a cat inside!!)

The bed was comfortable but the window opened to the outside communal area where everyone came to sit and chat (I loved listen to the two loud annoying ladies discussing their marital issues whilst their husbands where out fishing what a joy!!) The en-suit bathroom was in my friends room so as he was with his wife I gave them privacy and used the shower at the end of the hall along with toilet which wasn’t kept very clean as a lot of people were using it!! To top off the stay we had a fire alarm as some BRIGHT SPARK decided to light a cigarette in the non-smoking room (no apologies from the hotel staff about this which I thought was slightly lame!)Price!!!! OMG I found out late that my best mate had paid $1600 for 2 nights including taxes… not even worth half that amount I get was Fire Island but it wasn’t in the season quite yet However I guess it’s a captive market so these rates can be charged…

10. Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

A 16-minute drive from the West Sayville Golf Course, this modern hotel is 6 miles from Caleb Smith State Park Preserve, and 4 miles from the Hauppauge Education and Conference Center.Rooms offer free Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs with HD channels, as well as minifridges, microwaves and coffeemakers.Freebies include parking, takeout breakfast bags offered on weekdays, and daily hot breakfast served in a contemporary dining room. There’s an indoor pool and an exercise room. Other amenities include an area shuttle, a business center and a meeting room.

Things You Need to Know

  • The rooms have refrigerators
  • 7 min drive to Blydenburgh County Park
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests praised the indoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Jacqui Earle

Great location, near shopping centers I am a fan of Hampton Inns, they provide quality, affordable temporary rooms Our room was clean, there weren’t enough linens or toiletry supplies available

It was nice that the pool was open Breakfast was good Midday snack, and all day hot beverage station is a nice touch Convenient to where we needed to be I would definitely stay here again

Paul Baran

I have stayed at this Hampton Inn many times and have never been disappointed But by far this last visit was awesome (4/27/22 thru 5/2/22) The desk staff are wonderful and very accommodating

They took care of all of our needs during a very difficult time for my family We had booked 3 rooms and the staff made sure the rooms were kept together on the first floor for us A special recognition to Bobby(at the front desk) and Gabrielle (Sales Director) for helping me set up our rooms before my family had arrived from Florida The breakfast was a perfect start to the day and we enjoyed the quiet evenings sitting in the lobby with family The Evening staff even provided a nice care package to put a smile on our face during our tough time We have stayed at many Hampton Inns and by far this was our best experience, Kudos to the entire staff If you want your room cleaned you must tell the front desk, which was never a problem A++++++ Thank You

Darlene B

The complimentary breakfast was great I was surprised and pleased that the breakfast was a Hot breakfast of eggs sausage hashbrowns and fruit fresh real bagels (not packaged) Loved it

Nice hotel updated new Very Clean It smells good and clean The bed clean and comfortable Had a good sleepDisliked · I cannot think of anything that I didn’t like

11. Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

This straightforward roadside hotel is a 6-minute walk from the Islip Town Firefighters Museum.Airy, relaxed rooms offer free Wi-Fi, air-conditioning and flat-screen TVs, plus kitchenettes and en suite bathrooms. Upgraded rooms add pull-out sofas.Amenities include an indoor pool, a fitness room and a polished restaurant. There’s also a fire pit. Continental breakfast is available for a fee.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the clean rooms
  • 6 min drive to Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park
  • Guests praised the friendly service, which has a concierge
  • Guests liked the indoor pool
  • Guests liked the bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Debu Tante

Decent hotel I was there for work travel Asked for a quiet room on a high floor away from elevator bank and ice machines

They put me on the top floor but on the side next to the busy street and athletic fields which were quite loud at night I was also put in a room that had potential to be an adjoining room and could really hear my “adjoining” neighbor So I would say only 50% of my request was fulfilled Food and bar were decent but limited Hotel was very busy on the weekend and definitely much more quiet on weekdays No hairdryer in my room Had to ask for one Other guests varied – business travel people, wedding guests, athletic teams, people attending court nearby I will probably stay here again for business travel, but now know what to expect

Tom Childers

Great hotel The staff was friendly professional and helpful Clean environment and laid out well

Place to drink and eat and relax Outdoor fire pit, good seating area Nice pool and fitness center Clean rooms The only item I can list was one coffee cup in the room for two adults That would not stop me from going back Great hotel

Brittany DeSalvo

The coolest mermaid-y hotel rooms in the Islip/Patchogue area with great decor Very spacious Mostly nice front desk staff, but the fact that they made us hunt down the luggage cart ourselves by getting off the elevator on every floor and searching for it at 1am (after calling an hour earlier to ask if it could be available when we arrived) loses them a star

They told us no promises because someone else could be using it (fair), but they didn’t say they’d make us go find it ourselves if a rude guest just left it outside their room!

12. Dune Point Guest House (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

Set in a lively, pedestrian-only hamlet on Fire Island, this straightforward apartment hotel is a minute’s walk from the Atlantic Ocean and a 2-minute walk from the Arts Project of Cherry Grove.Unpretentious studio to 2-bedroom apartments come with kitchenettes or full kitchens, as well as satellite TV. Upgraded quarters add private decks and/or ocean views.Amenities include a scenic deck, 2 gazebos and BBQ grills.

Things You Need to Know

  • 3 min drive to Sailors Haven Visitor Center
  • Guests praised the service

Feedback From Real Customers

Kevin D.

We have stayed at Dune Point Guest House two years in a row and will definitely make this an annual getaway First, Cherry Grove is incredible It’s so beautiful there, and you never get tired of walking around and exploring the wooden walkways

As for the guest house, it is super clean, modern but not cold, and it offers so many extras that make the stay incredible The location couldn’t be better either Highly recommend this guest house

Vonia Adams

We went the first weekend in May and the weather was awful, cold and rainy The rooms are not built for the cold so it was a bit chilly but the heater worked well The management was great and even gave us some rolls and coffee when we arrived in the first ferry before any of the stores and restaurants opened, which was very nice

Everything was clean and comfortable and I would definitely recommend this place

Mike Dallas

We had a great 4 days staying at Dune Point The room itself was nice and very clean and has everything you need, including beach equipment (chairs, towels, umbrellas etc) and the kitchen was fully equipped The little private deck outside our room was super cute and comfy

Access to the beach was great through the building with the big deck, gazebo and awesome ocean views I’d definitely stay there again

13. Hilton Garden Inn Stony Brook (3-star hotel)

  • Address: 1 Circle Rd, Stony Brook, NY 11794
  • Phone: (631) 941-2980
  • Ratings: 4.4 (844 reviews) Very good Eco-certified
  • Website : Hilton Garden Inn Stony Brook
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 12:00 PM
  • Quick Summary: University hotel with upscale rooms & suites, plus an indoor pool & a casual bar & restaurant.

About this hotel

Located on Stony Brook University’s campus and across the street from Stony Brook University Hospital, this contemporary hotel is a 4-minute drive to Long Island Railroad’s Stony Brook Station.Flat-screen TVs, microwaves, minifridges and free WiFi are offered in each room, as well as upscale decor and custom-designed beds. Suites add separate living areas and pull-out sofas.There’s a casual bar and a 24/7 market, in addition to the cooked-to-order breakfast (fee) and restaurant serving American cuisine. There’s also a indoor pool with a hot tub and fitness center. Other perks include 4 meeting rooms and a business center.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the clean rooms and the beds
  • 5 min drive to Gallery North
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests praised the restaurant
  • Guests mentioned fitness centers 13 times
  • Guests liked the indoor pool
  • Guests praised the casual bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Michael Rudolph

The service was excellent The hotel room was spacious, had a nice big comfy bed, a flat screen to, and a nice bathroom Room was very clean

There is a nice pool and fitness room They were very accommodating to me and my family that stayed there The breakfast was good, they gave plenty of food to us I’d highly recommend staying here

K

We were very pleased with our spacious and comfortable suite, which was very clean Whenever we needed anything, the front desk staff was most helpful The restaurant was a pleasant surprise as there were many options, something for everyone, and we recommend the all you can eat breakfast

The service was also wonderful The hotel is in a perfect location, well maintained grounds, and we explored the campus and local sites Laundry room and shuttle to LIRR were pluses

John Coleman

Stayed here over weekend attending our daughters wedding at a nearby venue Staff was great! Very accommodating and friendly Room was clean, fresh and comfortable

5 stars all day for this Hilton!Great restaurant inside as well-who’s staff and manager was also-just terrific

14. Four Points by Sheraton Melville Long Island (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

Off I-495, this low-key hotel is 4 miles from Adventureland amusement park and a mile from the living museum Old Bethpage Village Restoration.The simply furnished rooms offer flat-screen TVs and coffeemakers. Suites add living areas and whirlpool tubs. Wi-Fi is available for a fee.Parking is complimentary. There’s also a casual bar/restaurant. Other amenities include a seasonal outdoor pool and an exercise room, as well as 4 meeting rooms and a business center.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the rooms and liked the beds
  • 5 min drive to the Old Bethpage Village Restoration
  • One of the few hotels in the area with room service
  • Guests liked the restaurant
  • Guests mentioned bars 41 times
  • The fitness center has treadmills
  • One of the few hotels in the area with an indoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Ernst Georges

I was driving after long fly to the Hampton than I felt tried So I decided to stay for a night at this Hotel for the first I love it The interior is awesome clean an the staff offers and outstanding customer care

I love the price I paid $ 141 for the night for a walk in with no reservation what’s so ever I love and I will comeback I recommend this hotel to everybody

June C

1) very strong smoke smell when I just opened the door But The room actually is non smoking room!2) duplicate charge for pet fee Called them asking for refund and they never pay me back!We booked 2 rooms for 2nights on November 2021

The policy says each pet is $25 per night We only have one dog stayed in one room so it’s $50, but they changed me extra $25 for no reason So I eventually paid $75 for pet fee I didn’t realized that until I saw the credit card statement Called them and the person said they can refund me on the credit card Now it is 7 months after, no one contact me and no refund to my accountThe nonsmoking room has super strong smoke smell and when I stepped in the window is opened ac is on fan is on It literally just like someone just smoked In the room one minute ago and left Front desk lady changed the room for me with no problem But I think it should not happened like this if it is NON SMOKING ROOM

Joyce Venezia Suss

This hotel is updated, beds are clean and comfortable, and front desk people are friendly BUT if you are handed a key to a ground floor room, REFUSE IT Our room had an overflowing humidifier and smelled musty, and our window faced the outdoor pool, with no privacy

Our children’s room across the hall was dark, blocked by shrubs next to the parking lot The pool crew was using a loud power washer on the deck while I was trying to rest before a wedding The front desk receptionist offered to try to get me a new room, but it was almost time to get ready so I refused Lesson to share: AVOID THE GROUND FLOOR ROOMS!

15. Whitman Motor Lodge (2-star hotel)

About this hotel

Set along Highway 25, this simple hotel with a vintage vibe is 1 mile from the Walt Whitman Birthplace Historic Site and Interpretive Center, and 3 miles from Oheka Castle.The relaxed rooms feature flat-screen TVs and free Wi-Fi; some have modern furnishings. Extended-stay suites add kitchens, dining areas and living rooms.Parking and continental breakfast are included.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the clean rooms and the beds
  • 4 min drive to the Walt Whitman Birthplace State Historic Site
  • Guests liked the friendly service

Feedback From Real Customers

Tammi I.

I’ve stayed here numerous times and have never had an unpleasant experience staying here The rooms are clean, smell fresh and clean when you walk inI’d like to take this review and give praise to the housekeepers that work there

The rooms I’ve stayed in were all extremely clean, smelled clean, the beds are made up very nice and neat I notice your hard work and always leave a tip for you in the room when I check out Your hard work shows and it’s appreciated Thank you 🙂

DAVID HICKEY

This has to be the most disgusting place I’ve ever stayed at The carpets in the room were old and dirty Kept my shows on the entire time

The toilet bowl wasn’t even cleaned The room smelled like someone had been getting high The place is very old with furniture from the 70’s This place needs a major renovation If they were charging $25/night, it would have been to much Please stay away from this dirty Motel We only stayed to change before a wedding we were attending We ended up driving home after the wedding Do not Believe all of the other Reviews online If anyone is telling you this place is good don’t BELIEVE ITI’ve been traveling this country for 30 years on business and personal This just made it to the top of the Worst Motor Inn To Never Stay at

16. Inn At Jericho (2-star hotel)

  • Address: 101 Jericho Turnpike, Jericho, NY 11753
  • Phone: (516) 338-0300
  • Ratings: 4.0 (278 reviews) Very good
  • Website : Inn At Jericho
  • Check-in time: 2:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Laid-back motel featuring contemporary rooms, in addition to complimentary Wi-Fi.

About this hotel

In a commercial area off the Long Island Expressway, this laid-back motel is a 15-minute walk from the NYCB Theatre at Westbury and 4 miles from Old Westbury Gardens.The contemporary rooms are accessed from exterior corridors, and come with complimentary Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs. All also feature minifridges, microwaves and desks.Parking is available.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the kitchenettes
  • 8 min drive to Old Westbury Gardens
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests mentioned microwaves 15 times
  • Guests liked the refrigerators, mentioned 17 times in reviews

Feedback From Real Customers

brian h

The outside may be scary but inside the room is pretty clean and spacious I was surprised The people here are pretty friendly

It’s not perfect but for the price that they ask especially during weekdays is a steal On weekends it’s pricey but what place isn’t They have no security deposit You pay online or in person and that’s the final price No extra fees in person This has been my go to spot for the past year Great place Highly recommend especially because there’s a 24 hour drive thru McDonald’s right next store and a 7-11 down the street There’s also a KFC, Dunkin(not 24hours) and it’s right next to the highway So you could hop on it and head home or wherever you need to go Very convenient Not noisy in the rooms There’s sometimes people smoking outside or talking but that’s alot of inns Other than that I would recommend if you looking for good price and cheap food nearby Usually packed All in all it’s a 37 average

Carly Fuchs

I spent 188 for one night I went back at midnight after the event I attended and packed my stuff and drove 25 hours home

It was not safe to say the least Someone overdosed in the front earlier that day DO NOT SAY HERE the top lock was broken in my room and there was several men standing outside the “inn” when I returned at midnight

Thomas Dennison

Stayed for 5 nights on work travel Was very comfortable leaving my wife and kid at the room No shadiness outside the entire time

Decent/good people stayed here Could walk for food Near alot of stuff Rooms were very clean and look like they were redone, so brand new Had a microwave, great AC and a large sized mini fridge Smaller sized rooms but still stayed very comfortable for 5 days Staff was very helpful and friendly, housekeeping was good to my family Great price! Would definitely stay again!

17. Pines Bluff Overlook

About this hotel

This simple hotel on Fire Island is a minute’s walk from the beach, 1.5 miles from Cherry Grove and 2.8 miles from Sunken Forest.The airy, unassuming rooms and suites all have sliding doors leading out to the deck, private bathrooms, free WiFi, TVs with satellite channels, DVD players, iPod docks and minifridges. There are also wood-panelled apartments available, with sitting areas and kitchens. Daily and weekly rates are available.There’s a free continental breakfast, plus complimentary all-day drinks. Amenities include an outdoor pool, plus loungers and a rooftop hot tub with ocean views. The hotel is open between March and December.

Things You Need to Know

  • The hotel has breakfast
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a hot tub
  • One of the few hotels in the area with an outdoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Rick Mordecon

Was looking for a comfortable somewhat private retreat in the very busy Fire Island Pines and found it here at Pine Bluffs Our suite was Apartment A Clean, quiet, comfortable bed, air conditioned, Cable TV, great rainhead shower

However, the best part of this spot is the upstairs pool area and the roof deck with a hot tub and excellent views of the Atlantic Continental breakfast was well conceived and the all day snacks and wine at cocktail hour a welcome addition to the amenities for this place Jim and James, our hosts were gracious, nice and helpful in all of our needs and the other guests at the B&B were cool, interesting and private as well A wonderful spot to spend a few days in a beautiful place

Nicholas Veneziale

We were looking for a place just for the weekend as most places rent by the week Despite being out to the Pines for years, never knew about Pines Bluff Have to say, it was a great find and a great stay

Hosts are very nice and accommodating, even upgraded us when our room had an issue prior to our arrival They also gave us an adjacent room since it was vacant so our party of four would be more comfortable Great place to stay, definitely recommend

Richard Garnett

Nice relaxing place and wonderful location! Beautiful views from the hot tub at night, and during the day, and well anything time! Jim is a wonderful host, check out his site for amenities and hospitality (food, snacks, refreshments) Coby, a Boston Terrier with a lovely character and disposition was my therapy while on holiday The place is nice, I’ll come back for Coby! If you’re not an animal person, he won’t bother you

I’ve stayed at a different place each time, this is at the top of the list

18. Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

On a tree-lined property 2 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport, this informal hotel is also 4 miles from hiking trails in Lakeland County Park and 27 miles from the beaches of Fire Island.Relaxed rooms come with free Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs, plus microwaves, minifridges and coffeemakers. Limited room service is available.An airport shuttle and parking are complimentary. There’s also a bright restaurant/bar, along with an indoor pool, a fitness room and a coin-operated laundry.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the large, clean rooms and the beds
  • Some guests disliked the bathrooms
  • 9 min drive to Lakeland County Park
  • One of the few hotels in the area with room service
  • Guests liked the friendly, professional service
  • Guests liked the bright restaurant
  • Guests mentioned lobbies 19 times

Feedback From Real Customers

Lori Roman

We stayed here to be close to a wedding in Great River and also to my sister in law’s house in Bohemia It’s our “go-to” hotel for these kinds of weekend visits and we couldn’t be more pleased with this place It’s clean, the rooms are great and spacious, the front desk service is unbelievably pleasant (yes, even during and after COVID) and they had the sweetest, most helpful breakfast server

I don’t know if they’re paying their employees well, but it certainly seems like they’re doing something right to have hired the best staff It’s always an enjoyable stay Thank you!

Bob Wallace

Had an overnight stay for a wedding The block of rooms reserved was not clustered together The room smelled of smoke, despite the big sign at the end of the corridor that it was a smoke free building

The AC was weird- it would kick on very low, then go to full fan very quicklyThe bathroom was clean and modern, good shower pressure and controlThe staff was very pleasant, and despite having guests for 3 weddings, was on top of delivering gift bags for each without problems The breakfast the next morning was scrambled eggs, bacon, muffins, croissants, bagels, yogurt, and coffee There could have been more tables and chairs, based on the number of registered guests for that wedding

Hoya Schaef

I am a Hilton diamond member with over a million miles and I travel to this area twice per month – our corporate HQ is nearby I kept this hotel in my rotation of local places I stay up til now – long after colleagues decided this hotel was no longer up to par for various reasons But today I closed the book on this hotel

Simple issue that could have been resolved so easily, but Albert at the front desk chose to quote hotel policy rather than listen to me As a diamond member every Hilton provides you with free bottled water and quite often they are very friendly and don’t really care if it is water you choose or another drink When I checked in I told the woman at check-in that as a diamond member I get water but would rather have diet cokes She told me to grab whatever I wanted, but must have misheard me, as upon checkout, I noticed I was charged $5 for the diet cokes I explained the confusion to Albert at the desk the next morning at checkout but he would not take the $5 off my $200 bill – just quoted policy – free water – not diet coke As a former manager of a retail store -as well as a frequent traveler – I know how easy it would have been to smile and apologize for the confusion and credit the $5 for the drinks And of course, I am not hard up for $5 – this would be paid for by my company anyway It was of course the principle of the matter To pick a battle with a diamond member over two diet cokes was just stupid and I have canceled my two future reservations and won’t come back This should have been so easy for him

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *