pet friendly hotels in Hampton Bays, NY

1. Hotel Indigo Long Island – East End, an IHG Hotel (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

This modern hotel in a low-rise, redbrick building is 2 miles from Splish Splash waterpark and 4 miles from the Long Island Aquarium and Exhibition Center.Contemporary rooms come with free Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs, as well as desks, and tea and coffeemaking facilities. Upgraded poolside rooms have patios. Suites are available.Parking is included. There’s a modern bistro and bar with outdoor seating, plus a terrace with an outdoor fireplace. Other amenities include an exercise room, an outdoor pool and a spa. Pets are permitted for a fee.

Things You Need to Know

  • 3 min drive to Splish Splash
  • Guests praised the clean rooms but some complained about the kitchenettes
  • Some guests complained about the bathrooms
  • One of the few hotels in the area with room service
  • Guests mentioned “outlet stores” 13 times
  • Guests praised the nightlife
  • Guests liked the outdoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Tommy Shi

Just did five nights and couldn’t have been more pleased with our stay Friendly service, clean, comfortable rooms (esp the beds) and a chill vibe They have pleasant, mellow live music in the evenings (maybe only weekends), a nice pool and a tasty free breakfast

Location is great for exploring the north and south forks of long island Plenty of good restaurants in the immediate area, although the restaurant on site is quite good This is our third stay and we’re already looking forward to coming back next summer

Henry Peterman

Disappointed with my stay IHG listed Hotel Indigo as part of their premier hotel category It’s modern design left much to be desired

Our room was in some disrepair and did not meet the description presented I regularly use Holiday Inn Properties in my travels and found this to be subpar in comparison to their other regular and budget properties I would strong advise those who choose to list this property as a premier property reconsider this classification if other properties under this label are in a similar state The staff was friendly and helpful and was the shining part of my stay It would be hard for me to consider staying at another Indigo property

2. Bayview Resort (2-star hotel)

  • Address: 53 W Tiana Rd, Hampton Bays, NY 11946
  • Phone: (631) 594-2370
  • Ratings: 4.1 (83 reviews) Very good
  • Website : Bayview Resort
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Relaxed lodging with bay views, an outdoor pool & a bar, plus a fitness room & free Wi-Fi.

About this hotel

Set on the Shinnecock Bay, this casual motel is 4.4 miles from Ponquogue Beach and 9 miles from the Long Island Aquarium & Exhibition Center.The relaxed rooms feature kitchenettes, free Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs. Upgraded rooms have balconies and/or water views. Penthouse rooms have private decks and full kitchens.There’s a relaxed bar and an outdoor pool, plus a picnic area with a fire pit. Other amenities include a fitness room and a business center.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the clean rooms, which have kitchenettes
  • 10 min drive to Quogue Wildlife Refuge
  • Guests liked the friendly service, which has a concierge
  • The fitness center has treadmills and elliptical machines
  • Guests praised the beach

Feedback From Real Customers

Nicole Newton

Loved it, and would go back The room was as described and clean The grounds were great – you can kayak, hang by the pool, sit by the fire pit, or have coffee on the deck on the bay

The staff was the best part — so helpful and friendly They set us up with beach towels, beach passes and chairs — so we were able to go to multiple beaches in the area

3. The Hampton Maid (3-star hotel)

  • Address: 259 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY 11946
  • Phone: (631) 728-4166
  • Ratings: 4.5 (270 reviews) Excellent
  • Website : The Hampton Maid
  • Check-in time: 4:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Seasonal windmill-shaped hotel with polished rooms & an outdoor pool, plus a breakfast restaurant.

About this hotel

Set on 5 acres overlooking Shinnecock Bay, this polished seasonal hotel with a windmill-shaped main building is 4 miles from the Shinnecock Hills Golf Club and 6 miles from Cooper’s Beach.The airy rooms are individually shaped and feature free Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs. Some rooms have exposed wood beams and/or sloped ceilings, others have wood floors or sleep up to 4 guests.Amenities include an outdoor pool with a sundeck and an elegant wooden gazebo overlooking the pool. There’s also a country-style breakfast restaurant set on a covered patio, plus a lawn, a playground and a veranda with seating. Minimum-stay rules may apply.

Things You Need to Know

  • 11 min drive to the Southampton Arts Center
  • One of the few hotels in the area with room service
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a restaurant
  • Guests mentioned “brunch” 10 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast
  • The hotel has a boutique store
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a bar
  • The hotel has childcare

Feedback From Real Customers

Francine Brock

I loved staying at the Hampton Maid The staff are so friendly and helpful Feels like you are a member of their family

The rooms are spacious, very nicely decorated, clean and have a great back porch to have drinks on or to order room service breakfast in the morningThe chef Alex has an excellent repertoire of food and every meal is delicious and beautifully arrangedThe restaurant has a great ambience and excellent serviceHampton Maid is in a great locationIt’s worth coming back to year after year after yearThanks for making my stay so specialFrancine

Ines P

Room 42 is not a standard room, which would according to their own definition accommodate 2 queen size beds No way would 2 queen beds fit in that room According to them, all their rooms are standard

This is deceptive, especially for people who are new to staying in hotels Rooms 38-43 appear to be the same layout The door was tricky to lock We called and someone came to assist us Breakfast was good, but “small plate” We waited for our food a long time I’m glad we ate elsewhere for dinner after inquiring whether they could accommodate a low sodium diet The man was honest He said that their food is Spanish and therefore salty The room was clean & decor was actually nice However, it bothered me that the lamp on one night stand was tall enough to interfere with 2/3 of the giant solitary picture in the room They need to get shorter lamps or smaller pictures Also, we had 3 conversations with different people before booking One woman was honest She said that no room had a view of the water One man stated that room 42 had a partial view of the water because it’s “higher” By partial, he meant a vague 15 percent patch of blue between branches that are still bare at this time of year

M Johnson

Had a wonderful stay! It was extreme clean and well decorated Love that you have a cozy sitting area outside the room as well as a picnic table Great customer service, from the room cleaning to the property owners

Upon arrival Sarah at the front desk was most helpful, I asked what are some things to do and she emailed me a list of things to do even of her own personal interests being from the area, we went to a few suggested places and it was great suggestions (thank you Sarah!) The owners are on-site, which we encountered and they both were extremely pleasant We had trouble turning on the TV and called for assistance and in no time someone came to the room and explained what to do Breakfast was absolutely great as well as service The pool area was enjoyable, a few people left their belongings on the pool chairs and tables to hold without being present for an extended period of time, this should probably be discouraged We all loved our stay and looking forward to returning

4. Colonial Shores Cottages

About this hotel

Facing Tiana Bay, this laid-back resort is 2 miles from the Sunrise Highway, and 5 miles from Ponquogue Beach along the Atlantic Ocean.Accommodations range from homey rooms to 1- or 2-bedroom apartments offering sitting areas and kitchens. Cottages feature decks. All provide flat-screen TVs, and bay or pool views.Free perks include a launch ramp, boat docking and parking. There’s also an outdoor pool, a kids’ playground and picnic area. Paddle boats and aqua bikes are available.

Things You Need to Know

  • 10 min drive to Quogue Wildlife Refuge
  • Guests praised the friendly service

Feedback From Real Customers

Tom McBride

A wonderful resort ideal for families or couples Right ron the bay with a marina and fire pit to spend the evening conversing with your companions or guests We found it by chance and we’re very surprised how nice the property was abd the views , and the owners were very congenial

We fell in love with this place and will be coming back for many years and for a longer stay 5 stars doesn’t do this place justice

Cecilia Komosinski

We booked several rooms to celebrate my daughter’s college graduation and We had the most bizarre experience at this resort

there was a dent in the wall in one of the rooms so we reported it and front desk said it was fine i had to leave early and my daughter checked out for our us and our guests and the management demanded a room inspection?? Then claimed they then claimed the dent was our fault and had us pay $250 for damages wow! Didn’t want to bother any further so just paid it as some of our guests had to catch flights But very disappointing! WOULDNT go back or recommend this resort

sheila chang

We stayed at the Colonial Shores in Hamptons Bay this past weekend and we just really had an amazing time! From the cleanliness of the cottage, to their amenities, top that off with their superb service, this place is really a gem Their location is also great There’s nothing negative to say about this place but if there’s one thing, we wish we stayed much longer! But we also love it that much that we already booked for next year! Thanks again for our great stay, that not only my husband and I loved it, but my girls as well

5. Bay Breeze Inn

About this hotel

Set on a leafy residential street and a minute by foot from the nearest beach along the Great Peconic Bay, this relaxed inn with a wraparound porch is 2 miles from Paumanok Vineyards and 9 miles from Interstate 495.The 6 warmly decorated rooms with hardwood floors feature flat-screen TVs, minifridges and free Wi-Fi, as well as en suite bathrooms. A pair of homey 1-bedroom apartments (in a detached cottage) add kitchens, living and dining areas, and sofabeds; 1 has a claw-foot tub.Parking is complimentary. There’s also a casual restaurant/bar, a lounge area and a fire pit.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the rooms
  • 4 min drive to Jason’s Vineyard
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests praised the breakfast
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a bar
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a beach

Feedback From Real Customers

IZ Zayas

I am so blown away by this experienceThe food is so delicate yet wholesome and the environment is so cozy and cleanTonight I shared a dinner with my good friend and we were able to sit, talk, laugh, and try quite a few plates on the menu

We enjoyed the cheese board and a beautiful tagliatelle pasta The cocktails are simple and so refreshing It’s nice to be out of town but surrounded by so many welcoming locals No complaints here I know your stay here will be just as enjoyable as mine♥️ James and Patricia they are the owners and curators of this Inn and Restaurant and they are always present Thank you thank you thank you 🙏🏼

Leanne Hauser

Beautiful! We went for our anniversary, and it was exactly what we were looking for We stayed at the orient cottage, which was perfect! The rooms were beautiful, the bed was so comfy and it was steps from the beach We also had an amazing breakfast and dinner at their watershed restaurant too! It was the perfect place for our mini vacation getaway! Thank you James and Patti for going above and beyond to make it as special as it was!

Melissa Grattan

Seriously the cutest place!!! My boyfriend and I went for a weekend getaway for our birthdays We stayed in the Cutchogue room I can’t say enough good things about it

Comfortable beds Super clean A nice staff I loved drinking by the warm fire at night, so cozy Can’t wait to go back with my girlfriends for a weekend and hit up the wineries!

6. Topping Rose House (5-star hotel)

About this hotel

Housed in a 1842 Greek Revival-style mansion with a contemporary annex, this ultra-chic hotel is 13 minutes’ walk from Bridgehampton train station and 3 miles from Ocean Road Beach.Polished rooms in the main house offer period features, as well as flat-screen TVs, iPod docks, free Wi-Fi and minibars. Modern annex rooms add floor-to-ceiling windows; some have terraces. Suites provide rooftop terraces and/or living areas. Room service is available 24/7.Free perks include parking, and breakfast served in a stylish high-end restaurant that has a terrace and a hip bar. There’s also a spa, a gym and an outdoor pool.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the rooms
  • Walking distance to South Fork Natural History Museum & Nature Center and Children’s Museum of the East End
  • 61 min drive to Long Island MacArthur
  • Guests liked the restaurant
  • Guests mentioned “brunch” 10 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a hot tub
  • Guests praised the bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Ashley B

All the reviews I read seemed pretty positive however, the welcome we got was very vague No offer in recommendations or assistance in reservations, even to their own restaurant There was limited information of the amenities (e

g bikes, car service), and a lack of information relating to events happening during our stayThe restaurant was amazing and food was delicious and great service I had better luck calling the restaurant to get a hold of someone at the front desk because they rarely answered (again, there is a theme of a lack of communication)The room was really nice but for being an “upscale” boutique hotel, I’m really surprised they couldn’t even have a coffee machine in the room Also, our door didn’t lock which the front desk told us it was because they’re European doors but if they were so “unique” it would’ve been nice if someone explained how to use itI was mostly disappointed that there ended up being a wedding during our Thursday night stay which ended up being directly in front of our room at the pool Luckily it ended at 11 pm but we weren’t able to use the pool and there was people all over setting up so we felt in the way that entire day There was also a photo booth setup which lit up the entire bathroom with flash after flash It would have been nice if they put us further down at least and when we said something, they just mentioned they communicate events on their website I don’t think there’s clear wedding dates listed on their site and if there is…it would have still been nice if someone just gave us the heads up when we checked inThey did also have the fire pit setup but didn’t have a fire any of the nights…once again seemed like another amenity we couldn’t use We haven’t been traveling much during the pandemic but this experience was pretty disappointing and feel like I’ve received better service traveling for work and staying at a Marriott I would like to support smaller boutique hotels but I felt like a burden since I wasn’t paying thousands on a wedding…just a few thousand on two nights which is clearly nothing to themAlso, I was really surprised that there was so much traffic The hotel is in front of one of the main roads, it’s only two lanes but there were a ton of large tractor trailers constantly driving by when dining and can easily be heard from the room we stayed in

Ksenia Pavlova

We live around the corner and have been dining in the Topping Rose restaurant for the last 4 years Today was an experience we have never witnessed before Myself, my husband and our 4 children came to have lunch

Our hostess Amelia was very unpleasant and rude Despite having reservations, Amelia refused to sit us at the table we requested The restaurant was not fully occupied and many tables for 6 were available The table we requested was not reserved and was empty the whole time we dined Not making a big deal, we asked to make reservations for the following week Amelia replied she was not able to guarantee the table for the following week either We have dined at the restaurant on multiple occasions and how we were treated today was absolutely unacceptable

Thomas Hoffmann

review from stay in 2021, sorry late but forgot to write it Rooms are great The people who work there are great but I think it is outrageous that you have one pool and on an August weekend you rent out the entire pool area for a bar mitzvah (starting early afternoon till close due to prep time)

At suites that cost $2000 per night coming out with family you would expect that you at least get a heads up! So you can adjust the day plan or cancelIn addition the location being at a major intersection for the Hamptons is not helping either Busses and trucks keep on driving super slow due to traffic Not the hotel fault but definitely gives location a low grade

7. Shorewood Inn (2-star hotel)

  • Address: 1399 Main Rd, Jamesport, NY 11947
  • Phone: (631) 722-4024
  • Ratings: 4.4 (196 reviews) Very good
  • Website : Shorewood Inn
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Unfussy rooms & suites in a motel offering free Wi-Fi & parking, plus BBQ facilities.

About this hotel

This modest family-run motel in a tranquil wooded area is 5 miles from Long Island Aquarium, 6 miles from Cherry Creek Golf Links and 15 miles from Meschutt Beach.Unpretentious rooms with exterior entrances feature free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs and desks, along with tea and coffeemakers, microwaves and minifridges. Suites add kitchenettes, and sitting areas with pull-out sofas.Amenities include complimentary parking and an outdoor space with seating, fire pits and barbecue grills. Pets are welcome for a fee.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests liked the clean rooms and praised the beds
  • 9 min walk to Jamesport Vineyards | Little Oak Wood Fired Kitchen
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests liked the breakfast
  • Guests liked the bar

Feedback From Real Customers

TJ Adams Sr

I had an extremely negative experience with the owner today Upon check in the room was creepy motel filthy Unexplained stains on the kitchen cabinets and floor, the love seat was soiled the outdoor seating area looked like it had not been cleaned all Summer

Very uncomfortable accommodations When I requested a refund well before 3pm (check-in) the owner refused multiples and said that my claims were unfounded He offered another room, after explaining that they had a very busy weekend At that point, I was beyond disgusted and just wanted to leave Since he vehemently refused to issue and immediate refund, we were forced to accept the second room After a few moments and realizing there were too many red flags and over all unsanitary reasons not to stay, we finally called it quits and left after, of course giving the owner multiple opportunities to make this right Poor, poor customer service DO NOT BOOK A ROOM HERE, EVER!!

J Naoki

This was our 2nd time here We like the place and appreciate the good value in an expensive part of the world We rented the tiniest room, and we were happy

We spent most of our time outdoors–at the beach I appreciated the fresh bagels and coffee in the morning I bought my son a breakfast sandwich from the shopping center a 4-min walk away Clean room Clean, fluffy towels Happy for the chance to get away Be sure to check out Iron Pier Beach! And Lenny’s Pizza!!

Shin Xing

WORST!The place is not bad for the price But the worst part was all the window locks are broken even in the bathroom We tried complaining it to the front desk and ask if he could transfer us to another room but didn’t take any actions

Rather than taking risk in staying in an unsafe place we just checked out and find another safer place to stay Not gonna risk my safety just for $194!! (2nights)

8. The Harvest Inn

About this hotel

Set in an area known for its vineyards, this elegant, adults-only B&B is 1.4 miles from Little Peonic Bay, while Causeway Beach is 2.6 miles away.Genteel rooms all have en suite bathrooms, oriental rugs and hardwood floors, while premium linens and free Wi-Fi come as standard.Amenities include a concierge who can arrange wine tours and boat trips, and there’s an exercise room and in-room spa services (extra charge). Beach passes, chairs and towels are available. A hot breakfast is included in the rate. Minimum-stay rules may apply.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the rooms
  • Walking distance to Lenz Winery and Pindar Vineyards
  • Guests liked the service, which has a concierge
  • Guests mentioned “wineries” 13 times
  • Guests mentioned “courses” 10 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast

Feedback From Real Customers

Mike Murphy

It has been a couple months since my stay at the harvest inn my wife and i had such a nice time there that i can’t stop thinking about it Steve and Stacey are so kind and welcoming that we felt like part of their family

The rooms are beautiful and there is a bathroom in each one then there is the breakfast unbelievable Ive never had a breakfast like that it was like a four course meal including homemade muffins, immune boosting fresh juice concoction, and topping it off was a stuffed french toast croissant I still get hungry just thinking about that croissant lol My stay was amazing so relaxing and fun the food was incredible I cant wait to go back again next fall Stacey and Steve thank you so much, you are both amazing hosts!

Robin Kahn

Ah, what a lovely weekend spent at The Harvest Inn Upon entering you are struck by the light, airiness and modern decor Stacey & Steve, the owners, welcome you in with open arms

Immediately, you feel as though you have left all your cares behind you and can finally relax The rooms are beautifully appointed with every possible item you might need including boxed water! The hotel is gorgeous! and beds so comfy! Did I mention breakfast?? Not to be believed-three courses of scrumptiousness, all hand crafted by Stacey! And don’t forget her nutritious shots of juice filled with good-for-you stuff! Highly recommend if you are looking for an Inn that’s stylish and contemporary with the best breakfasts ever!

Amirtha Sureshbabu

This place is beautiful, clean, well-kept, and cozy Stacey and Steve were very friendly and helpful with things to do in the area! Stacey gave us a thorough list of excellent wineries, restaurants, and other attractions in the area, as well as make an EXCELLENT breakfast They even gave us a beach pass for easy access to the bay and sound side! Thank you so much for a wonderful stay – my partner and I had a great weekend getaway in the North Fork

Super romantic and a great distance from so many wineries, restaurants, and other fun places (like Greenport village!)

9. Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island East End (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

In a commercial area off Interstate 495, this relaxed all-suite hotel is a mile from the Splish Splash Water Park, and 14 miles from a beach on the Atlantic Ocean.Informal studios come with kitchens and living areas, as well as free Wi-Fi and flat-screen TVs. The 1- and 2-bedroom suites add separate living rooms.Parking and hot breakfast are complimentary. Other amenities include a modern lounge and bar, plus indoor and outdoor pools, a hot tub and a gym. There’s also a convenience store and a coin-operated laundry. Pets are allowed.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the rooms, which have microwaves
  • 3 min drive to Splish Splash
  • Guests liked the service
  • Guests praised the restaurant
  • Guests mentioned “outlet stores” 12 times
  • Guests praised the indoor pool and the hot tub
  • Guests liked the modern bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Isabel

Great location! Hotel was clean, the pools were great and I loved the outdoor lounge areas Rooms were clean Used the couch pull out bed and called the front desk for linens

They said that they had to check if they had any linens left for us to use The room description said that linens would be in the closet but they were not there Would’ve been upset if they did not have any linens for us to use but luckily they did Breakfast was good

Robin Lamb

We stayed at the Marriott with our 2 small dogs last night We came to the area to visit our child who is away at college The hotel was perfect! It was very clean

Even though the place was sold out, it didn’t feel crowded or loud We were able to get breakfast without difficulty It was very reasonably priced There are lots of food options nearby The only thing that would make this pet-friendly hotel better would be a gated dog walk area, since the hotel is located on a busy highway Overall, we look forward to staying here again the next time we visit our child

Ricky Long

We enjoyed our stay very much! Staff was courteous, and rooms were clean Abundance of parking The complimentary buffet was top notch

There were to-go boxes ready for guests to eat in their rooms Hot food was individually packaged and constantly topped off by the staff Can’t say enough good things about how clean and well run the breakfast buffet was This Residence Inn is right next to the Tanger Outlet However, in order to get to the outlets, we drove down the road, and then back around We would have walked it, but there’s not direct path across Old Country Road It’s very close to Lavender by the Bay and Windy Acre Farm We definitely would recommend Thank you for making our first overnight stay with our babies as smooth as it could have gone Will be back!

10. The Inn Spot (2-star hotel)

About this hotel

Tucked on the shore of Shinnecock Bay, this chef-run hotel and restaurant with panoramic bay views is set in a tranquil, residential hamlet.The quirky rooms with sloping ceilings and beachy-cottage decor offer TVs with cable channels, sitting areas, bay views and bathrooms. There are adjacent villas with private decks; upgraded villas add living rooms and full kitchens.The noteworthy restaurant with a wrap-around veranda is a foodie destination, offering gourmet breakfasts, fresh smoothies and fine dining (extra charges).

Things You Need to Know

  • 3 min drive to شاطئ Ponquogue
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a restaurant
  • Guests liked the breakfast
  • One of the few hotels in the area with a bar

Feedback From Real Customers

Ivy Wan

We paid $658 ($705 after taxes and fees) for the “waterview bungalow” for one night It was as simple as the listing was on Hotelscom: “double bed, bathroom, waterview”

No amenities Not even a microwave or cooler No place to hang clothes unless you count the hooks in the bathroom There is one dresser with shallow shelves No chair Just a double bed, bathroom, and a TV The TV wasn’t set up either Took us a while to turn it on and set up (the remote batteries were put in wrong) No hairdryer eitherThe restaurant opens after 5pm so you have tp look for your own breakfast and lunch There is only one cafe in town that’s 2 min away for brunch so the line is endless We wished there was at least a coffee machine in the roomBeautiful interiorw lovely benches and chairs view outside of room deck with water and a bridge that you can drive across to the beachwhere you have to pay $30 to park or walk 20-30min there for freeThe Inn Spot is still waiting for their beach permit for guests and also has no reception desk so like us, many guests also walked into the restaurant with their luggages confused The desk number rings with no answer (Celia is the one who called us back after we called their sister company EP Marine)We did not receive any check-in instructions via text which would have been helpful Sergio, who worked at the restaurant (?) was kind enough to let us into our roomIt seemed like the place had just reopenedand it needed to be more organized this experience was probably worth around $300 not $700

Nick Jagodzinski

We had a great experience staying here Besides the location being beautiful, the staff was extremely accommodating and helpful with anything we needed and any questions we had about the area The location was perfect too, very close to the beaches and a short drive from some really good restaurants

We’ll be back! Thank you for the wonderful time!

annabel levy

The waiter was nice, as was the view, and the food was okay But the place has no ambiance at all It felt oddly abandoned

The other server/greeter wasn’t exactly rude, but she was brusque, disinterested and slow The food is overpriced They had run out of the fish special by 7:15, despite the fact that the restaurant was about 70% empty The cocktail menu is meh, and when I ordered a vodka tonic with lime I got a very small and slightly brown slice of lime The women’s restroom has two stalls, one of which had a broken door The menu is limited and includes some things that sound plain unappetizing, to be honest There were only two fish dishes on the main menu, plus the special, which again, they no longer hadat 7:15 I would not go back, and I feel bad saying this, because again, the waiter did a good job I’d describe him as heroic in a thankless role I’d call this place the Out Spot

11. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Long Island-East End, an IHG Hotel (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

This laid-back hotel is 2 miles from the Railroad Museum of Long Island, and 3 miles from both Splish Splash Water Park and Long Island Aquarium.Featuring carpeted floors and wood furnishings, the down-to-earth rooms offer free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs and en suite bathrooms. Suites add microwaves, minifridges and sitting areas with pull-out sofas.Complimentary perks include breakfast and parking. Other amenities consist of a 24-hour gym, a heated outdoor pool and meeting space.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests liked the clean rooms and praised the beds
  • 4 min drive to Splish Splash
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests liked the restaurant
  • Guests mentioned “bagels” 11 times

Feedback From Real Customers

Brian Fontanella

The room was good, the staff was friendly the breakfast was above average and had many choices My only complaint was the aggressive manner in which they try to force you out of your room in the morning We attended a wedding nearby and obviously wanted to sleep in a little

The cleaning staff used a card key to enter my room at 8am after a quick knock and we were in bed Thankfully I had locked the safety latch and then we went to have breakfast around 9am and the staff was waiting outside of our room and asked are we leaving?? We replied no we are going to get breakfast and then put the do not disturb sign on the door out of fear of being evicted from the room This was just unnecessary in my opinion Check in for the next guests is not till 3pm This should not be my inconvenience to even think about the logistics of how they will clean all of the rooms in time, meanwhile 11-3 all rooms are vacant I would not stay here again unless I had to I believe that this hotel could do a little better even though they probably get by with the steady stream of business from local vineyards and wedding venues

Victoria Ybabez

It is gone downhill since last year we stayed there One of there elevators wasn’t working upon checking in, we realize that we didn’t have any blackout curtains in out room We notified the front desk and they said they would send maintenance in the next morning

I had to call again that next day to make sure that someone was going to come before they left for the day Maintenance had to hang something to black out the room for night time but then we weren’t able to have any natural light for 6 daysThe curtains weren’t working at all in our room Went down to the front desk one morning and to get some extra towels they said they would have housekeeping bring them up to us and they never did had to go back down again, and we had only use housekeeping one time the whole stay Breakfast was good but you have to get down there early Pool was nice! Customer service wise, the girls were great however there was an on duty manager that you could tell hates his job (Manager On DutyNathaly Joya) Husband had a not so good interaction with him Wouldn’t pay that much to stay there again going to stay at one of the other hotels in town the next time we come

Nugget Queen

First night was great! Quiet hotel and great breakfast Saturday morning! Saturday night wasn’t so pleasant, Girls Dance Team or whatever checked in and it was incredibly noisy and loud then They were running up and down the hallway screaming and just acting like it was a playground Didn’t get any sleep and Was hoping to enjoy breakfast but again the girls dance team ruined that as well

12. Hyatt Place Long Island/East End (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

Set on Long Island’s North Fork, this informal hotel overlooking the Peconic River is a mile from the Long Island Aquarium.Casual, warmly furnished rooms provide free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs, and separate living areas with sofabeds, as well as minifridges and coffeemakers. Upgraded rooms have views of the river and harbor.Parking is complimentary. There are indoor and outdoor pools, plus a 24-hour gym and a business center. Dining options include a cafe/bar and a snack shop.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the large rooms
  • Walking distance to the Long Island Aquarium and Exhibition Center and the Railroad Museum of Long Island
  • Guests praised the friendly service
  • Guests praised the restaurant
  • Guests mentioned pools 46 times
  • Guests praised the views
  • The fitness center has weight machines

Feedback From Real Customers

Madeleine Metzler

We booked a block of rooms with this hotel for our wedding weekend on the North Fork of Long Island We worked with Suzanne Lincoln who was SO incredibly helpful in arranging the block, sharing information, answering questions, and assisting with last-minute requests All our guests were very happy with their stays and it was nice to be able to gather with other guests in the spacious lobby, at the bar, and over breakfast

We would absolutely recommend this property for groups or for family travelers One thing that could be improved is the layout of the rooms There was no closet (which for a wedding with lots of things to hang was challenging) and the room arrangement was a little strange Also, we were staying off-season and it was very hard to find food, coffee, lunch within walking distance of the hotel The hotel restaurants are either not open off-season or are closed from Monday-Wednesday which is when we were there There are very limited take-out/delivery options in Riverhead You would need to drive to get food, which might not be ideal for everyone But, honestly, all the staff at the Hyatt were amazing and so great to work with They were patient and helpful and we would definitely return and recommend it to others

13. Hamlet Inn (3-star hotel)

  • Address: 300 Montauk Hwy, Southampton, NY 11968
  • Phone: (631) 283-2968
  • Ratings: 4.3 (120 reviews) Very good
  • Website : Hamlet Inn
  • Check-in time: 3:00 PM
  • Check-out time: 11:00 AM
  • Quick Summary: Bright hotel on a tranquil bayside offering free Wi-Fi & parking, plus an outdoor seasonal pool.

About this hotel

On 3.5 acres of verdant lawns, this beachy hotel lies on the shore of Shinnecock Bay, off route 27. Southampton’s buzzy shops, art galleries and seafood restaurants are a 7-minute drive, while Cooper’s beach is 4 miles away.The simple rooms offer free Wi-Fi, flat-screens with cable channels, fridges and microwaves, as well as private bathrooms. All quarters have either 2 beds or 1 bed and a pull-out sofa.Free continental breakfast is served seasonally to all guests in the bright dining room. There’s a scenic outdoor seasonal pool with sunloungers. The terrace has outdoor seating. Parking is complimentary.

Things You Need to Know

  • Guests praised the beds
  • 7 min drive to the Southampton Arts Center
  • Guests mentioned the service is friendly
  • Guests liked the breakfast

Feedback From Real Customers

Octavia Ward

Stayed at the Hamlet Inn April 29th-May 1stThe receptionist is really concerned with covid that she will not come near you The first night we to the front office about some ants we seen was told someone would come spray no one ever came

I asked for some towels at 1:30pm and was told they would be in a bag outside of the room came back at 9:00PM and we had no towls called the desk number and was told we should have called before 9pm and they had already left and it would be an hour before they could get back to get us some towels We wake up in the morning our room was infested with ants and when we told the manager Denice all she said was the next time we book with them to mention her name for a discount was not offered any compensation we had ants in our room We should’ve been refunded something

Brian Buck

The manager is absolutely wonderful, she’s friendly and makes excellent recommendations, she can help you with directions and show you routes that will save you HOURS Ignore your GPS, listen to what she says The pool was great, our room was clean, updated, fresh

Air conditioning was great, as I’m always hot and it was more than adequat I adored sitting in the porch, and the property is loaded with beautiful hydrangeas We’ve paid double what we’ve paid here elsewhere and not had half as good as an experience Yes, it’s 20 minutes from east Hampton, bit it’s ABSOLUTELY worth it This will be our go to from now on We adore it

14. Bay Watch Hotel & Marina (2-star hotel)

About this hotel

A mile from both Ponquogue Beach and the lively bars and restaurants of Hampton Bays’ main street, this relaxed, 2-story hotel is 3 miles from Highway 65.Casual rooms have kitchenettes equipped with microwaves, minifridges and coffeemakers plus complimentary Wi-Fi. Suites add patios, and cottages include full kitchens and BBQs.Amenities include an outdoor pool with sunloungers, plus a marina offering slip rentals and boat charters.

Things You Need to Know

  • The rooms have coffee makers and microwaves
  • 4 min drive to شاطئ Ponquogue
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests mentioned beaches 13 times
  • Guests praised the outdoor pool

Feedback From Real Customers

Lisa Altieri

My husband and I stayed here for our anniversary this week We loved the location! We were able to walk to get breakfast and dinner, we walked down to the small beach down the road, and we were only about 10 minutes from other stores/restaurants We stayed in one of the bungalows, and we were happy with it

We had a refrigerator/freezer, microwave, coffee pot and stove, so we didn’t have to go out to eat for every meal The pool was great, we spent the whole day there and the atmosphere was super relaxing Reveka was welcoming and helpful We can’t wait to make this trip an every year event

stephanie sinka

Rebecca and her family were so welcoming and their hospitality was a 10 out of 10! Rebecca got us anything we needed and always was there to help Not only was Rebecca so welcoming but the hotel was great! the rooms were clean and so nice Has AC, wifi and access to a pool and beach down the road

The perfect area to stay in the Hamptons I can’t wait to stay here again someday Definitely worth the stay!

15. The Preston House & Hotel (3-star hotel)

About this hotel

In a leafy residential area, this casual hotel within 5 minutes’ walk of shops and eateries is a 2-minute walk from the shores of the Peconic River and 14 minutes’ walk from the Riverhead train station.Warmly decorated studios come with free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs and minifridges, as well as coffeemakers. The 1-bedroom apartments add separate living areas with sofabeds, while suites provide kitchenettes. Room service is available.There’s a stylish restaurant. Other amenities include a gym and in-room massage services. Pets are welcome, and parking is offered.

Things You Need to Know

  • Walking distance to the Long Island Aquarium and Exhibition Center and the Railroad Museum of Long Island
  • 14 min walk to nearest train station
  • Guests praised the service
  • Guests mentioned restaurants 26 times
  • Guests praised the breakfast

Feedback From Real Customers

Madeleine Metzler

45 stars – We stayed at the Preston House for our wedding weekend and had a very positive experience from start to finish The hotel is beautiful, immaculately clean, well-appointed and well-located

Parking was easy and free All of the hotel staff, especially Alberto and Rose, were so kind, helpful, and professional We had to check out early unexpectedly and Alberto was an amazing and helpful resource We will definitely come back and enthusiastically recommend this hotel and restaurantWe also hosted our Wedding Rehearsal Dinner at the hotel restaurant The food was delicious and we and our guests were very happy and well-fed I will say that planning the dinner was challenging–it took numerous calls and emails to get a response about booking the event Be wary about booking events around the change of seasons We had chosen items from the Winter Menu that we then learned were all unavailable because the chef had changed to the Spring Menu without informing the manager who was coordinating with us This was a frustrating situation that could have easily been avoided with better communication among staff and between staff and guests Everything worked out just fine, but there was room for improvement in this regard

Racquel W

The customer service is top-notch! We were stranded in Long Island after or BNB was cancelled and thankfully this hotel had a cancellation and we were able to stay here The service is phenomenal as the hostesses provided accommodations for everything we needed-from the room, to breakfast and even providing late-checkout-this is a place I’d recommend to anyone Thank you for your accommodating and treating us with exceptional customer service

Andi Hartmann

We stayed in The Preston House & Hotel for two nights before flying back to Germany after traveling the US for two weeksWe had a suite for two adults and two teenage kids The rooms were very spacious, very clean and furnished to a very high standard

Staff was lovely and very helpful!It was such a wonderful stay, we will definitely visit again

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *